Kaori Limited v Shrinkforce Shrink Wrap Services Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2011-404-4603 [2012] NZHC 2663

BETWEEN  KAORI LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDSHRINKFORCE SHRINK WRAP SERVICES LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing:         10 October 2012

Counsel:         N F Flanagan & E C Rutherford for Plaintiff

T Joseph for Defendant

Judgment:      11 October 2012

JUDGMENT OF KEANE J

This judgment was delivered by  on  11 October 2012 at 4.45 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/ Deputy Registrar

Date:

Solicitors:

Crown Solicitor, Auckland for Plaintiff

Gilbert Walker, Auckland for Defendant

KAORI LIMITED V SHRINKFORCE SHRINK WRAP SERVICES LIMITED HC AK CIV 2011-404-4603 [11

October 2012]

[1]      In December 2009 Kaori, a company registered in the Cayman Islands, which owns the 38 metre sailing yacht 'Kaori', entered into a contract with Shrinkforce to have the yacht shrink wrapped while its teak decking was replaced, and other repairs made, at an Auckland ship yard. The contract price was $84,108. The total cost to Kaori was $118,594.

[2]      In June 2010, when the shrink wrapping was removed, Kaori contends, the paint work to the hull was extensively damaged. A pale blue line ran the length of the hull. The paint work was marred by drip lines, glue residue and blotching. Kaori attributed this to the way in which the shrink wrapping had been applied or removed and  considered  the  damage  so  extensive  that  Shrinkforce  was  incapable  of remedying it. Kaori cancelled the contract.

[3]      In August 2011 Kaori brought this claim against Shrinkforce for $441,000, relying  then  on  an  estimate  given  by  Orams  Marine.  Its  claim  lies  under  the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993 and under the contract. Shrinkforce denies liability and contends that under the contract Kaori cannot claim under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993 and can only claim what it paid out under the contract.

[4]      On 28 March 2012 this case was allocated a four day fixture to begin on 23

October 2012. Then, on 25 September 2012, Kaori applied, under HCR 10.15, to have the quantum of damages severed for separate hearing if it succeeds on liability. Quantum can only be fixed accurately, it contends, once the remedial work has taken place. That has still to happen.

[5]      Shrinkforce opposes this application. Quantum, it contends, can and ought to be resolved at the forthcoming fixture. Kaori's application comes unacceptably late and a split trial will result in duplication, delay and added costs. If it is found liable, Shrinkforce contends, it ought not to be left with an indeterminate liability to be resolved at some indefinite point in the future.

[6]      HCR 10.15 enables an order to be made, as a matter of discretion, splitting the trial as to quantum from that as to liability. It says this:

The Court may, whether or not the decision will dispose of the proceeding, make orders for -

(a)       the decision of any question separately from any other question, before, at, or after any trial or further trial in the proceeding; and

(b)      the  formulation  of  the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaori Limited v Shrinkforce Shrink Wrap Services Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2663
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kaori Limited, a Cayman Islands-registered company and owner of a 38-metre sailing yacht named 'Kaori', entered into a contract with Shrinkforce Shrink Wrap Services Limited for the yacht to be shrink-wrapped during repairs to its teak decking and other works at an Auckland shipyard. The contract price was $84,108, with the total cost to Kaori being $118,594. Upon the removal of the shrink wrap in June 2010, Kaori alleged that the yacht's hull had sustained extensive paint damage, including a pale blue line along its length, drip lines, glue residue, and blotching. Kaori attributed this damage to the manner in which the shrink wrap was applied or removed, and claimed that the damage was so extensive that Shrinkforce could not remedy it. Consequently, Kaori cancelled the contract and sought damages of $441,000 from Shrinkforce, based on an estimate provided by Orams Marine. Shrinkforce denied liability and argued that under the contract, Kaori could not claim under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993 and could only claim the amount it paid under the contract.

The primary legal issue in this case was whether Kaori could claim under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993 or was limited to the contractual claim. This issue was separate from the present application, which sought to sever the quantum of damages from the liability issue for a separate hearing. Kaori argued that it could not accurately determine the quantum of damages until the remedial work was completed, while Shrinkforce contended that the quantum should be resolved at the forthcoming fixture to avoid duplication, delay, and increased costs. The court held that the ordinary position was that both liability and quantum should be decided together at a single hearing, and that the party seeking a severance of quantum from liability bears a heavy onus. The court found that Kaori's application was made very late and carried the potential for indefinite delay, and that Shrinkforce was entitled to know its potential liability. Therefore, the court declined Kaori's application, and both liability and quantum must be resolved at the forthcoming fixture. However, the trial judge may still decide to sever the quantum for a separate trial if it deemed it just to do so after hearing the evidence.

The court ordered that both liability and quantum must be resolved at the forthcoming fixture, but noted that the trial judge may decide to sever the quantum for a separate trial if it deemed it just to do so after hearing the evidence. The court also noted that severance would likely only be granted on terms that protected Shrinkforce and ensured that any quantum trial took place sooner rather than later. Shrinkforce was awarded costs at scale 2B on the present application, but its precise entitlement would be better fixed in the costs award eventually made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established