Kamo v Minister of Conservation

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA519/2018
 [2020] NZCA 1

BETWEEN

JOHN KAMO, MELODIE ERUERA‑FRASER, MONIQUE CROON, STEPHEN TUUTA AND IWIROA WAIRUA being the trustees of the NGĀTI MUTUNGA O WHAREKAURI IWI TRUST
Appellants

AND

MINISTER OF CONSERVATION
First Respondent

AND

HOKOTEHI MORIORI TRUST
Second Respondent

Hearing:

17 April 2019

Court:

Gilbert, Williams and Courtney JJ

Counsel:

T J Castle and T N Hauraki for Appellants
G L Melvin and C J C Pouwels for First Respondent
P J Radich QC and A G Emanuel (joined by D V Williams) for Second Respondent

Judgment:

29 January 2020 at 11.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellants must pay the first and second respondents one set of costs on a band A basis with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Williams J)

Introduction

  1. The appellants are trustees of the Ngāti Mutunga o Wharekauri Iwi Trust (Ngāti Mutunga).  They seek declarations that the Department of Conservation’s current proposal to vest certain lands on Wharekauri/Rēkohu in the Hokotehi Moriori Trust (Moriori) will undermine Ngāti Mutunga’s mana whenua and breach the tribe’s right to property, culture and free movement under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (NZBORA).  In this Court, they have also made Treaty of Waitangi arguments.

  2. In the High Court, Collins J declined to issue declarations in the terms sought.[1]  The Judge found that the Ngāti Mutunga had failed to establish with evidence its mana whenua over the relevant land.[2]  They also failed to convince the Judge that Ngāti Mutunga was entitled to the NZBORA protections argued for.[3]  It does not appear from the terms of the judgment that Treaty rights were a focus in the High Court. 

Background facts

[1]Kamo v Minister of Conservation [2018] NZHC 1983, [2018] NZAR 1334 [High Court judgment].

[2]At [61].

[3]At [78], [80] and [86].

  1. Moriori ancestors had lived on the island they call Rēkohu for many generations before the arrival in 1835 of a Ngāti Mutunga fighting force of around 900.  The force had been conveyed to Rēkohu aboard two British merchant vessels.  Ngāti Mutunga themselves were displaced refugees due to earlier incursions from the north upon their Taranaki territories. 

  2. Moriori culture was distinct from Māori culture.  Moriori were essentially pacifist.  They were therefore quickly subjugated by Ngāti Mutunga and many were killed.  A significant island population of between 2,000–3,000 prior to 1800 had fallen to around 200 by the middle of the 19th century.  While not all of that population loss was a result of the Ngāti Mutunga invasion (diseases introduced by the earlier European arrivals also had a role to play), it was nonetheless a substantial contributing cause. 

  3. As conquerors are wont to do, Ngāti Mutunga superimposed their own nomenclature on the whenua.  They called Rēkohu “Wharekauri”.  By the late 1860s, most of the Ngāti Mutunga invaders were drawn back to the North Island by the cessation of hostilities there between Taranaki iwi and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kamo v Minister of Conservation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZCA 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand was asked to determine whether the appellants, trustees of the Ngāti Mutunga o Wharekauri Iwi Trust, were entitled to declarations that the Department of Conservation's proposal to vest certain lands on Wharekauri/Rēkohu in the Hokotehi Moriori Trust would undermine Ngāti Mutunga’s mana whenua and breach the tribe's rights under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (NZBORA). The Court was also tasked with considering whether the proposed vesting was inconsistent with the Treaty of Waitangi.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether Ngāti Mutunga had established a sufficient basis to claim mana whenua over the contested lands, and whether the proposed vesting would infringe on Ngāti Mutunga's rights under the NZBORA and the Treaty of Waitangi. The Court examined the evidence presented regarding the historical context and cultural significance of the land, the nature of mana whenua, and the applicability of the NZBORA provisions to the claims made by Ngāti Mutunga.

The Court held that the factual foundation for Ngāti Mutunga's claim of mana whenua was deeply contested and insufficient for the Court to grant the declarations sought. The Court found that mana whenua, being a traditional authority over land and its resources, was not property in the classical sense and thus not protected under s 21 of the NZBORA. Additionally, Ngāti Mutunga's Treaty relationship with the Crown was also not property and therefore not subject to the unreasonable seizure provision of s 21. The Court concluded that the proposed vesting could not be assessed for its consistency with the Treaty of Waitangi until the Minister of Conservation had considered Ngāti Mutunga’s submissions and determined the terms and conditions of the vesting.

Accordingly, the Court dismissed the appeal and ordered the appellants to pay the respondents' costs on a band A basis with usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute over the proposed vesting of Taia Farm, a 1,200-hectare property on Wharekauri/Rēkohu, in the Hokotehi Moriori Trust (Moriori). The Ngāti Mutunga o Wharekauri Iwi Trust, represented by its trustees, seeks declarations that the vesting will undermine Ngāti Mutunga’s mana whenua (traditional authority over the land) and breach their rights under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (NZBORA). The dispute traces back to the 1835 invasion of Wharekauri/Rēkohu by Ngāti Mutunga, who subjugated the indigenous Moriori people. The Ngāti Mutunga claim mana whenua over Taia Farm, while Moriori asserts their own customary and cultural interests in the land. The Department of Conservation plans to vest Taia Farm in Moriori under the Reserves Act 1977, pending public notification and consideration of submissions. Ngāti Mutunga objects to the vesting, citing lack of consultation, absence of consideration of their relationship with the land, and the use of public funds for the purchase.

The matter originated in the High Court, where Collins J declined to issue the declarations sought by Ngāti Mutunga. The case was appealed to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, where it was heard by Gilbert, Williams, and Courtney JJ on 17 April 2019. The appeal was dismissed on 29 January 2020, with the appellants ordered to pay costs to the respondents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Ngāti Mutunga have sufficient mana whenua over Taia Farm to warrant the granting of declarations?
2. Are Ngāti Mutunga’s mana whenua and Treaty relationship with the Crown considered property rights under s 21 of the NZBORA?
3. Does the proposed vesting in Moriori violate Ngāti Mutunga’s right to enjoy culture under s 20 of the NZBORA?
4. Does the proposed vesting infringe on Ngāti Mutunga’s freedom of movement over Taia Farm under s 18 of the NZBORA?
5. Is the proposed vesting consistent with the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi?

Held
1. Ngāti Mutunga does not have sufficient mana whenua over Taia Farm to warrant the granting of declarations.
2. Ngāti Mutunga’s mana whenua and Treaty relationship with the Crown are not considered property rights under s 21 of the NZBORA.
3. The proposed vesting in Moriori does not violate Ngāti Mutunga’s right to enjoy culture under s 20 of the NZBORA.
4. The proposed vesting does not infringe on Ngāti Mutunga’s freedom of movement over Taia Farm under s 18 of the NZBORA.
5. The consistency of the proposed vesting with the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi cannot be assessed until the terms and conditions of the vesting are settled.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal found that Ngāti Mutunga's claim for declarations was not supported by the evidence provided and was thus not an appropriate case for granting such relief. The factual foundation for the relief sought, namely, Ngāti Mutunga's mana whenua over Taia Farm, was disputed by Moriori. Given the complexity of the issues of tikanga and law that arise, the Court could not resolve the case without a proper determination of the factual background. Moreover, the Court found that Ngāti Mutunga's mana whenua and Treaty relationship with the Crown were not property rights protected by s 21 of the NZBORA. Mana whenua, as a concept, is not property in the classical western sense and is not capable of treatment as such. Furthermore, Ngāti Mutunga’s Treaty relationship with the Crown is merely a relationship and not property. The Court also found that Ngāti Mutunga's right to enjoy culture under s 20 of the NZBORA and freedom of movement under s 18 of the NZBORA could not be assessed until the terms and conditions of the vesting are settled. The Court agreed with the Crown's argument that the only relevant form of property in this context is the Crown's indefeasible title. Ngāti Mutunga's mana whenua, if it could be established, is not capable of being seized in the manner provided for in s 21 of the NZBORA. Similarly, the consistency of the proposed vesting with the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi cannot yet be assessed for the same reason. The Court concluded that the appeal must be dismissed and that the appellants must pay the first and second respondents one set of costs on a band A basis with usual disbursements.