Kain v Hutton HC Christchurch M 198/00

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY M 198/00

UNDER the Trustee Act 1956

IN THE MATTER of an application to remove trustees and related orders

BETWEEN G KAIN and others
Plaintiffs

AND J R HUTTON
First Defendant

AND W A X COUPER
Second Defendant

AND A E COUPER
Third Defendant

AND W K STARTUP
Fourth Defendant

AND G T KAIN
Fifth Defendant

Hearing: 11 April 2001

Counsel: S P Rennie and R P Todd for Plaintiffs
T C Weston QC for J R Hutton, A E Couper (qua trustee)
and W K Startup
M R Camp QC for W A X Couper
G D Jones for G T Kain
G M Brodie for Mr J F Springford
R A Osborne for Mary Hutton and A E Couper (qua beneficiary)

Judgment: 11 May 2001

JUDGMENT OF PANCKHURST J RE COSTS AND RELATED ISSUES

Introduction:

[1] On 11-12 December 2000 I heard argument in relation to an interlocutory application by beneficiaries for the removal of the defendants from their various positions as trustees of numerous family trusts. In a judgment dated 21 December 2000 the application for removal was dismissed. Costs were reserved for further consideration. On 11 April there was a further full day hearing with reference to both costs and a related order sought by the plaintiffs.

[2] In my last judgment I noted the extent of the dissension between family members. If possible, the more recent hearing served to confirm that matters had deteriorated further. A costs order is sought against the plaintiffs arising from their prosecution of the unsuccessful application for summery removal. It emerged that the trustees had incurred legal and associated costs of over $600,000 with reference to these proceedings. The plaintiff beneficiaries are aggrieved at the level of this cost. Moreover, their application for an order permitting access to the assets of certain vested trusts (to cover costs) was strongly opposed. Finally, applications by trustees directed to be served, Messrs G T Kain and Mr Springford, for costs orders (in the absence of agreed indemnity) were also opposed. Goodwill is nonexistent.

[3] In these circumstances I must rule on each of the various applications in turn.

Costs on the Plaintiffs’ Unsuccessful Application:

[4] Mr Weston QC on behalf of Mr Hutton, Mrs Couper, and Mr Startup as trustees of a number of the trusts, sought costs of $20,000 against the plaintiffs. The matter was put in this way:

“The trustees believe they have a duty to all beneficiaries to seek costs from the plaintiffs and they now make such an application.”

Determination of the actual costs of these trustees in relation to the December hearing was described as “virtually impossible”. However, counsel submitted that an amount for two days of hearing and four days for preparation, being say $20,000, was appropriate. Based on six days at even the highest recovery rate (category 3, $1,900 per day) an award of $20,000 cannot be justified. As to the merits of the application for summary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kain v Hutton HC Christchurch M 198/00 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NZHC 364
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand Christchurch Registry, the case of Kain v Hutton and others involved an interlocutory application by beneficiaries for the removal of trustees from their positions. The court, under Panckhurst J, dismissed the application for removal and reserved the matter of costs for further consideration. At the subsequent hearing, the court was asked to rule on various costs applications, including those from the trustees and beneficiaries. The trustees sought costs against the plaintiffs for their unsuccessful application for summary removal, while the plaintiffs sought to use the assets of vested trusts to cover their litigation costs. The court ruled that while the plaintiffs' application for summary removal had failed, there were serious questions to be tried, and the unevenness in the parties' situations warranted reserving the decision on costs until the substantive hearing. Regarding the trustees' costs, the court allowed reimbursement for reasonable expenses incurred by Mr G T Kain, but denied a similar order for Mr J F Springford due to his adversarial role in the proceedings. Finally, the court declined to make an order concerning the distribution of assets of vested trusts or for payment of costs from such assets, due to the deficiencies in the procedure by which the issue was before the court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established