K v Police HC Hamilton CRI 2007-419-90

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CRI 2007-419-90

BETWEEN  K

Appellant

ANDNEW ZEALAND POLICE Respondent

Hearing:         16 May 2008

Appearances: Alex Hope and Mania Hope for Appellant

Ann-Marie Beveridge for Respondent

Judgment:      16 May 2008

JUDGMENT OF HARRISON J

SOLICITORS

Till Henderson (Hamilton) for Appellant

Almao Douch (Hamilton) for Respondent

K V POLICE HC HAM CRI 2007-419-90  16 May 2008

Introduction

[1]      Mr K   appeals against his conviction in the District Court at Hamilton on two charges of breaching a protection order (s 49 Domestic Violence Act 1995) and one of theft of property worth less than $500 (s 223 Crimes Act

1961).  He does not appeal against his sentence of 40 hours community work.

[2]      The stated grounds of Mr K  ’s appeal are that (1) there was no evidence of proper service of the protection order on him; (2) in any event he had reasonable grounds for visiting the complainant’s premises on both occasions; and (3) he did not act dishonestly in taking property in that he did not intend to deprive the owner of the goods permanently.

District Court

[3]      Judge Philip Connell convicted Mr K   on all three charges following a summary trial on 29 June 2007.   He contemporaneously imposed the sentence of community work.  He did not, however, give written reasons for his decision for at least another eight months until 13 March 2008.   Mr Hope complains about the delay.  He says that he was forced to prepare and file a notice of appeal in this Court on 13 July 2007 and give particulars of grounds, but that in the absence of a reasoned decision he was forced to correspond with the Registrar of the District Court on a number of occasions in order to obtain a formal decision.

[4]      I  agree   with   Mr Hope’s   concerns.      A   delay  of   such   magnitude   is unacceptable, especially because it suspended indefinitely Mr K  ’s ability to progress his rights of appeal.   The delay is also regrettable because it inevitably taints what is an otherwise comprehensive and carefully reasoned decision particularly on credibility.

[5]      Mr K   and the complainant, his wife, Florence, are Congolese nationals. They  lived   together   in   New Zealand   from   2001   until   separation   in   2002. Mrs K   obtained a temporary protection order in the Family Court at Hamilton on 15 August 2002.  That instrument became permanent on 16 November 2002.  The

parties have continued to live in Hamilton since then, Mrs K   having custody of her son from a previous relationship.

[6]      Mrs K     has   subsequently   entered   into   a   new   relationship   with Mr Charlie Obeira.   Both were living together in Hamilton when Mr K   and others entered their residence on two separate occasions.   The  first occurred at

3.30 am on 23 February 2007.  A little earlier Mrs K   received a telephone call from a young boy she knew.   Within   minutes he arrived on the doorstep of the house.  Mrs K   was concerned about his wellbeing.  She left him in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read K v Police HC Hamilton CRI 2007-419-90 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZHC 708
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard an appeal by Mr K against his conviction in the District Court at Hamilton on charges of breaching a protection order and theft. The appeal centred on three grounds: (1) the lack of evidence for the proper service of the protection order on Mr K, (2) that Mr K had reasonable grounds for visiting the complainant’s premises, and (3) that he did not act dishonestly by taking property, as he did not intend to permanently deprive the owner. The District Court judge had convicted Mr K on all charges but delayed providing written reasons for eight months, causing Mr K's appeal to be filed prematurely.

The court found that the certificate of service provided by the police sufficiently proved service, despite the absence of a specific mode of service. The judge's reliance on other evidence corroborated Mr K's knowledge of the protection order, making this ground of appeal untenable. Regarding the reasonable excuse argument, the court determined that Mr K's actions did not align with genuine or objectively reasonable conduct under New Zealand law, regardless of his beliefs about Congolese law. Finally, the court dismissed the appeal on the theft charge, as Mr K's conduct indicated an intent to permanently deprive the owner of the property.

The High Court upheld the District Court's convictions on all charges, finding no merit in Mr K's appeal. The appeal against the convictions for breach of a protection order and the theft conviction were both dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established