| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND |
| CA552/2016 [2017] NZCA 261 |
| BETWEEN | ANDREW JONES |
| AND | WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL |
| CA553/2016 | |
| BETWEEN | LOUISE FERGUSON |
| AND | WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL |
| CA554/2016 | |
| BETWEEN | SEFTON GIBB |
| AND | WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL |
| CA555/2016 | |
| BETWEEN | LUKE DOMB |
| AND | WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL |
| Court: | Cooper, Woodhouse and Collins JJ |
Counsel: | A O’Connor for Applicants |
Judgment: (On the papers) | 22 June 2017 at 10.30 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe applications for extensions of time to apply for leave to appeal are granted.
BThe applications for leave to appeal are declined.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Cooper J)
These four applications for leave to appeal have been dealt with together because they all raise the same issue. The question presented is whether infringement notices issued by Wellington City Council parking wardens were in the correct form. Both the District Court and the High Court considered that the correct form had been used.[1] The applicants, all recipients of the infringement notices, now seek leave to bring a second appeal pursuant to s 237 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011.
[1]Wellington City Council v Jones [2016] NZDC 3876; Jones v Wellington City Council [2016] NZHC 2310.
Each of the applicants was charged with the offence of operating a motor vehicle in contravention of s 242(1) of the Land Transport Act 1998 (the Act). It was alleged they had committed that offence by operating a motor vehicle when the vehicle was not licensed. They were convicted and in each case ordered to pay a fine of $200.
Extensions of time
The applicants seek extensions of time for filing the notices of application for leave to appeal. Those applications are opposed by the respondent on the basis that the grounds on which the extensions of time are sought are insufficient. There is, however, no suggestion of prejudice and we consider the nature of the case makes it appropriate for us to extend the time for seeking leave to appeal so that the merits of the leave applications can be assessed.
The relevant provisions
Section 242 of the Act provides as follows:
242 Motor vehicles must be registered and licensed
(1) A motor vehicle must not be operated on a road unless the motor vehicle—
(a) is registered and licensed in accordance with this Part; and
(b) has affixed to it and displayed in the manner prescribed by regulations made under this Part—
(i) the registration plates issued for it; and
(ii) a current licence issued for it and appropriate for its use under section 244.
(2) The person registered in respect of a motor vehicle in accordance with this Part must—
(a) keep the motor vehicle licensed at all times in accordance with this Part; and
(b) ensure that the prescribed fees and accident insurance levies are paid for the time that the motor vehicle is required to be licensed (whether or not it…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Jones v Wellington City Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NZCA 261
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court considered the relevant provisions of the 2011 Regulations, the 2012 Regulations, and the definition of "stationary vehicle offence" in the Land Transport Act 1998. The Court noted that Regulation 7 of the 2012 Regulations required an infringement notice for a stationary vehicle offence to be in the form set out in Schedule 4, while Regulation 95 of the 2011 Regulations prescribed the form of an infringement notice for an infringement offence under the 2011 Regulations to be in the form set out in Schedule 1 of the 1998 Regulations. The Court concluded that the definition of "stationary vehicle offence" in the Act was broad enough to encompass the circumstances of the applicants' contraventions, and therefore, the notices issued by the Council were valid under the 2012 Regulations. The Court found that the applicants' argument that the notices should have been in the form specified in Schedule 1 of the 1998 Regulations was not supported by the legislation, and accordingly, the notices were valid.
The Court dismissed the applications brought by the applicants. The Court found that the notices issued by the Council were in the correct form as prescribed by the relevant legislation and regulations, and therefore, the applicants' claims for judicial review were without merit. The Court did not make any orders as to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Regulation 77 of the Land Transport (Motor Vehicle Registration and Licensing) Regulations 2011 (the 2011 Regulations) creates offences of operating a motor vehicle in contravention of s 242(1) of the Act. It deals separately with driving and using a vehicle on a road[2] and causing or permitting a vehicle to be on a road.[3] The regulation relevantly provides as follows:[2]Land Transport (Motor Vehicle Registration and Licensing) Regulations 2011, reg 77(1).[3]Regulation 77(2).77 Operation of unregistered or unlicensed motor vehicle(1) A person commits an offence if the person operates a motor vehicle in contravention of section 242(1) of the Act by driving or using it on a road if the motor vehicle—(a) is not registered and licensed in accordance with Part 17 of the Act; or(b) does not have affixed to it and displayed in the manner prescribed by these regulations—(i) the registration plates issued for it; and(ii) a current licence issued for it and appropriate for its use.(2) A person commits a stationary vehicle offence if the person operates a motor vehicle in contravention of section 242(1) of the Act by causing or permitting it to be on a road or driven on a road if the motor vehicle—(a) is not registered and licensed in accordance with Part 17 of the Act; or(b) does not have affixed to it and displayed in the manner prescribed by these regulations—(i) the registration plates issued for it; and(ii) a current licence issued for it and appropriate for its use. It is relevant also to note the definition of “stationary vehicle offence” in s 2 of the Act:stationary vehicle offence means—(a) parking in any portion of a road in breach of—(i) any Act or regulation; or(ii) any bylaw made under section 22AB(1)(m) to (o):(b) any offence specified as a stationary vehicle offence in regulations made under this Act. The notices were in the form specified in sch 4 of the Land Transport (Infringement and Reminder Notices) Regulations 2012 (the 2012 Regulations). Regulation 7 of the 2012 Regulations provides that an infringement notice for a stationary vehicle offence must be in the form set out in sch 4. Consistently with that, reg 3 of the 2012 Regulations provides:3 Infringement offencesAn infringement notice in respect of an infringement offence, other than a moving vehicle offence, a special vehicle lane offence, an overloading offence, a toll offence, or a stationary vehicle offence, must be in the form set out in Schedule 1. However, the applicants contend that the notices should have been in the form specified in sch 1. The argument is founded on reg 95 of the 2011 Regulations, which provides:95 Form of infringement noticeFor the purposes of section 139 of the Act,[[4]] an infringement notice for an infringement offence against a provision of these regulations and a reminder notice in respect of an infringement notice must be in the form prescribed in Schedule 1 of the Land Transport (Infringement and Reminder Notices) Regulations 1998.(Footnote added.)[4]Section 139 of the Land Transport Act 1998 provides for infringement notices to be issued by enforcement officers who have reasonable cause to believe an infringement offence is being or has been committed by a person. Its provisions are not directly relevant to the issues raised by these applications.