IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA1/06
[2008] NZCA 302BETWEENLINDA CLARE JOHNSON
Appellant
ANDJOHN LEWIS MANSFIELD
Respondent
Counsel:S L Abdale for Appellant
D A Wood for Respondent
Judgment:13 August 2008 at 4.00 pm
JUDGMENT OF O’REGAN J
A I award to the respondent costs of $500.
B I make no award of costs in relation to the present application for costs.
CI direct the Registrar to disburse the $4,300 held as security for costs as follows:
(i)$500 to be paid to the appellant’s solicitors in payment of the costs award;
(ii)$3,800 to be refunded to the respondent’s solicitors.
REASONS
[1] On 23 December 2005, the appellant filed a notice of appeal seeking to challenge a High Court decision to the effect that her claim against the respondent was time-barred. On 3 December 2007 she filed a notice of abandonment of her appeal. At the same time she requested that the Registrar return to her solicitors the sum of $4,300 held by the Registrar as security for costs. It may well be that the appeal would have been treated as having been abandoned under r 43 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005 (the Civil Rules) before the notice of abandonment was filed, but nothing turns on this.
[2] Subsequently the respondent claimed costs of $1,770. The appellant challenges the respondent’s entitlement to any costs and the matter has been referred to me by the Registrar for decision, exercising the power given to individual Judges of this Court under r 7(1)(a) of the Civil Rules.
[3] The respondent claims costs of $1,770, made up as follows:
Receiving notice of appeal $100.00
Considering the law, considering notice
of appeal $500.00Correspondences to and from the Court and copy
to counsel over security for costs and other
associated matters:
Letters out (5) $150.00
Letters in (8) $220.00Receiving notification security paid $ 50.00
Receiving application for fixture $ 50.00
Receiving application for extension of time $150.00
Receiving draft case on appeal $300.00
Receiving confirmation of abandonment of appeal $150.00
Correspondence to and from the Court and copying
to respondent about release of security for costs $150.00Total (GST inclusive) $1770.00
[4] The appellant argues that the appeal was abandoned before the respondent had taken any steps and was withdrawn after the release of a decision of the Supreme Court which was inauspicious from the appellant’s point of view. She therefore submits that no costs should be awarded.
[5] The appellant points out that the appeal raised a legal issue in respect of which there were conflicting High Court decisions, and could not be classified as unmeritorious at the time it was filed. It was only after the Supreme Court decision was made that it became apparent that it would be unlikely to succeed. She contrasts the present case with the situation in Peters v Television New Zealand (2005) 18 PRNZ 149, where costs were awarded because the respondent had had to take a number of steps including preparing and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Johnson v Mansfield and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] NZCA 302
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether Mansfield was entitled to any costs, given that the appeal had been abandoned. Rule 44(3) of the Civil Rules made it clear that the abandonment of an appeal did not affect the Court's power to award costs, which was governed by rules 53 to 53J. The court had to consider whether the steps taken by Mansfield's counsel were sufficient to justify the claimed costs. The court also had to consider whether any costs should be awarded for the correspondence and submissions related to the costs application itself.
The court found that Mansfield had not taken any of the steps outlined in Schedule 2 to the Civil Rules, but some of the steps taken by counsel could be classified as preparation work for which costs could have been awarded if the appeal had been heard. The court accepted that there was very little work required of Mansfield in relation to the proposed appeal itself, mainly consisting of correspondence with the Court over the provision of security for costs and some preliminary research. The court determined that an allowance for 0.3 days of work at a daily recovery rate of $1,600 was appropriate, leading to a figure of $500. The court directed the Registrar to deduct the $500 from the $4,300 held as security for costs and pay it to Mansfield's counsel. The remaining $3,800 of the amount held as security for costs should be returned to Johnson's solicitors. The court made no award of costs in relation to the present costs application, as each side had had a measure of success.
The court ordered that $500 be paid to Mansfield's solicitors in payment of the costs award, and the remaining $3,800 to be refunded to Johnson's solicitors. No award of costs was made in relation to the present costs application.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi