Joden Finance Limited v Dorairaj

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2012-404-001985 [2012] NZHC 1228

IN THE MATTER OF     an appeal from the District Court at

Auckland

BETWEEN  JODEN FINANCE LIMITED Appellant

ANDSTEPHEN DORAIRAJ Respondent

Hearing:         28 May 2012

Appearances: A Palmer as McKenzie Friend for the Appellant

S E McCabe for the Respondent

Judgment:      5 June 2012

[COSTS] JUDGMENT OF WYLIE J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Wylie

On 5 June 2012 at 11.00 am

Pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:

Distribution:

Joden Finance Ltd: johnmurphy@woosh.co.nz

SE McCabe: sheila@sheilamccabe.co.nz

JODEN FINANCE LIMITED V DORAIRAJ HC AK CIV 2012-404-001985 [5 June 2012]

[1]      On 16 April 2012, Joden Finance Limited filed a notice of appeal in respect of a costs decision given by Judge Mathers in the District Court at Auckland on

3 April 2012.[1]

[1] Joden Finance Ltd v Stephen Dorairaj DC Auckland CIV 2009-004-002364, 3 April 2012.

[2]      On 22  May 2012,  Joden  Finance  Limited  discontinued  the appeal.   The respondent,  Dr Dorairaj,  seeks  costs,  on  an  indemnity  basis,  consequent  on  the discontinuance.

Background

[3]      Dr Dorairaj   purchased   a   second-hand   Mercedes   motor   vehicle   from Joden Finance Limited in March 2009.  The cost of the vehicle was $79,995.  There were a number of problems with the vehicle, and Dr Dorairaj brought a claim against Joden Finance Limited in the Motor Vehicle Disputes Tribunal.   That claim was heard  over  two  days  in  September  2009.    Judgment  was  entered  in  favour  of Dr Dorairaj for $30,580.

[4]      Joden Finance Limited appealed the decision of the Motor Vehicle Disputes

Tribunal to the District Court.

[5]      The appeal was heard by Judge Cadenhead on 3 February 2010.   Judge Cadenhead dismissed the appeal in respect of liability, but allowed it in respect of quantum.  He remitted the matter back to the Motor Vehicle Disputes Tribunal.

[6]      The quantum issue was reconsidered by the Motor Vehicle Disputes Tribunal on 7 April 2010. The Tribunal confirmed the original quantum figure of $30,580 in a further decision released on 12 April 2010.

[7]      Joden Finance Limited then filed a second appeal against the new quantum decision  in  the  District Court  on  21  April  2010.     At  much  the  same  time, Joden Finance Limited filed an application for judicial review in this Court.   A hearing was scheduled in the District Court to hear Joden Finance Limited’s appeal.

Given  the  review  proceedings,  that  hearing  was  adjourned.    On  5 April  2011,

Whata J heard the judicial review proceedings.   Judgment was given in favour of Joden Finance Limited on 6 May 2011.[2]   Judge Cadenhead’s decision was set aside and the matter was referred back to the District Court.  No order for costs was made as between Joden Finance Limited and Dr Dorairaj.   The second appeal was then discontinued.

[2] Murphy and Joden Finance Ltd v The District Court at Auckland & Ors HC Auckland CIV

2010-404-002015, 6 May 2011.

[8]      The District Court then reheard the matter.   After three separate hearings, Judge   Mathers   delivered   a   decision   confirming   the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Joden Finance Limited v Dorairaj and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 1228
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Joden Finance Limited v Dorairaj, the High Court was required to decide a costs application brought by the respondent, Dr Dorairaj, against the appellant, Joden Finance Limited, following the discontinuance of an appeal by Joden Finance Limited. The court had to determine whether the discontinuance of the appeal entitled Dr Dorairaj to costs on an indemnity basis, and if so, the appropriate amount of such costs.

The court found that Joden Finance Limited was entitled to appeal the District Court's costs decision, but that the appeal was vexatious as it was filed despite the clear statutory provisions indicating that the District Court's decision was final. However, the court declined to award indemnity costs as it found that Joden Finance Limited's actions were not in bad faith, but rather a result of an error in judgment. Instead, the court assessed the costs on a normal basis, applying a 2B cost categorisation, and allowed for an increase in costs due to the unreasonable filing of the appeal. The total costs awarded to Dr Dorairaj were $5,479.70, including reasonable disbursements.

In summary, the court awarded costs to Dr Dorairaj following the discontinuance of the appeal by Joden Finance Limited, but declined to award indemnity costs. Instead, the court assessed costs on a normal basis and allowed for an increase in costs due to the unreasonable filing of the appeal by Joden Finance Limited. The total costs awarded were $5,479.70, including reasonable disbursements.