JAG Media Limited v Magna Systems Engineering (NZ) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

ORDER PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF NAMES OR IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF THE PARTIES UNTIL 5PM, MONDAY 23 APRIL 2012.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-001965 [2012] NZHC 733

BETWEEN  JAG MEDIA LIMITED First Plaintiff

ANDBROADCAST INC LIMITED Second Plaintiff

ANDMAGNA SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (NZ) LIMITED

First Defendant

ANDCOUNTRY 99 TV LIMITED Second Defendant

Hearing:         17 April 2012

Counsel:         DB Hickson for Plaintiffs

Judgment:      17 April 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASHER J

Solicitors/Counsel:

Castle Brown, PO Box 9670, Newmarket, Auckland. Email:  lawyers@castlebrown.co.nz and dhickson@ihug.co.nz

JAG MEDIA LIMITED V MAGNA SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (NZ) LIMITED HC AK CIV-2012-404-

001965 [17 April 2012]

[1]      Jag Media Ltd and Broadcast Inc Ltd have issued proceedings in this Court seeking damages from Magna Systems Engineering (NZ) Ltd and Country 99 TV Ltd for unlawful use of a database provided to those companies by Broadcast Inc. The proceedings have not yet been served.   However, the two plaintiffs seek a without notice order permitting inspection of computer systems held at the premises of Magna Systems Engineering (NZ) in Newmarket, Auckland.  The purpose of the inspection is to identify information relevant to the proceeding.  The plaintiffs seek to take samples by way of forensic images of databases, computer registry files and a computer operating system.  An order is sought that the samples are delivered up to the Registrar.   It is proposed that the plaintiffs’ forensic expert Mr Spence be the person who carries out this task.

[2]      This application was first considered by Heath J on 16 April 2012.   He considered the orders sought were closely comparable to search orders under Part 33 of the High Court Rules, but lacked the protection required to address the invasive nature of the search.  He indicated that he would be prepared to hear counsel on that issue or on any amended application it might wish to make. An amended application has been filed, but the applicant still relies on r 9.34 and not on Part 33.

[3]      Rule 9.34 provides:

9.34  Order for inspection, etc

(1)   The court may, for the purpose of enabling the proper determination of any matter in question in a proceeding, make orders, on terms, for—

(a)   the inspection of any property:

(b)   the taking of samples of any property: (c)   the observation of any property:

(d)   the measuring, weighing, or photographing of any property: (e)   the conduct of an experiment on or with any property:

(f)   the observation of a process.

(2)   An order may authorise a person to enter any land or do anything else for the purpose of getting access to the property.

(3)   In this rule, property includes any land and any document or other chattel, whether in the control of a party or not.

[4]      There must be a question as to whether there is jurisdiction under r 9.34 to grant the order.   This is because the orders are for the purpose of “enabling the proper determination of any matter in question in a proceeding”.  At the present time there is only a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JAG Media Limited v Magna Systems Engineering (NZ) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 733
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of JAG Media Limited v Magna Systems Engineering (NZ) Limited, the plaintiffs sought an order to inspect computer systems held at the premises of Magna Systems Engineering (NZ) in Newmarket, Auckland, to identify information relevant to their claim for unlawful use of a database. The plaintiffs sought to take forensic images of databases, computer registry files, and a computer operating system, and deliver these samples to the Registrar. The matter was initially heard by Heath J, who found that the orders sought were comparable to search orders under Part 33 of the High Court Rules but lacked the necessary protections due to the invasive nature of the search. The plaintiffs subsequently filed an amended application, but still relied on r 9.34 of the High Court Rules rather than Part 33. The court was required to determine whether the orders sought were appropriate under r 9.34, and if not, whether the plaintiffs could apply for a search order under Part 33.
The court found that the orders sought were not appropriate under r 9.34 because the plaintiffs had not identified any specific matters in question that required the inspection of the defendants' computer systems. Furthermore, the court found that the orders sought were invasive and could cause distress or damage to the defendants, and that the Part 33 requirements for search orders had not been addressed. The court noted that the Part 33 requirements were necessary to protect defendants who had not been served, and that the plaintiffs would need to file an amended application under r 33.2 and address the Part 33 requirements in a detailed memorandum. The court adjourned the application to give the plaintiffs an opportunity to file an amended application and any further affidavit evidence they considered necessary. If no such application was made before 5pm on Friday, 20 April 2012, the present application would stand dismissed. If an application was made, it would be dealt with on the papers or, if appropriate, by way of a further telephone conference.
The court held that the orders sought were not appropriate under r 9.34 of the High Court Rules because the plaintiffs had not identified any specific matters in question that required the inspection of the defendants' computer systems. The court found that the orders sought were invasive and could cause distress or damage to the defendants, and that the Part 33 requirements for search orders had not been addressed. The court adjourned the application to give the plaintiffs an opportunity to file an amended application under r 33.2 and address the Part 33 requirements in a detailed memorandum. If no such application was made before 5pm on Friday, 20 April 2012, the present application would stand dismissed. If an application was made, it would be dealt with on the papers or, if appropriate, by way of a further telephone conference.