IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA148/02
BETWEENJ P LIVINGSTON
Appellant
ANDINSTITUTE OF ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE AND RESEARCH LIMITED
First RespondentANDA R GAINSFORD
Second Respondent
CA156/02
AND BETWEEN S L TUIAVII
Appellant
ANDINSTITUTE OF ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE AND RESEARCH LIMITED
Respondent
Hearing:5 May 2003
Coram:Gault P
Keith J
Blanchard J
Anderson J
Glazebrook JAppearances: W M Johnson and E A Hall for Appellant Livingston
M L Wotherspoon for Appellant Tuiavii
R B Squire QC and N J Russell for Respondents
J C Pike for Attorney-General
Judgment:19 June 2003
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY GLAZEBROOK J
Introduction
[1] Mr Livingston and Mr Tuiavii face charges of driving with excess breath alcohol. The machine used to administer the relevant evidential breath test to Mr Livingston was a Seres Ethylometre 679T machine and gave a result of 833 micrograms per litre of breath. In Mr Tuiavii’s case the machine used was a Lion Intoxilyzer 5000 machine (model 6600) and gave a result of 948 micrograms of alcohol per litre of breath. The legal limit is 400 micrograms per litre of breath. Both Mr Livingston and Mr Tuiavii wish to dispute the reliability of their evidential breath tests on the basis of the evidence of an electronics expert, Mr Churchill. Mr Churchill has identified what he considers are faults in the particular devices used, which he believes raise doubt as to the accuracy of the results obtained. He, however, deposes that he needs access to the manufacturer’s technical manual in order to provide a full analysis.
[2] The background to these appeals is the decision of this Court in Attorney-General v Otahuhu District Court and Brown [2001] 3 NZLR 740. In that case Mr Brown, who was in a similar position to the appellants in this case, sought discovery from the police of the manufacturer’s manual for the Intoxilyzer device used to administer his evidential breath test. This Court held that, as the manual was held by the Institute of Environmental Science and Research Ltd (ESR), an independent legal entity, it was not within the power or control of the police as prosecuting authority. Therefore the police could not be compelled to discover it. In addition, it was held that there is no statutory authority or implied power to make pre-trial rulings on discoverability of documents held by third parties in a summary case. Neither does the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (Bill of Rights) require such a pre-trial criminal discovery process. The Court held that the appropriate procedure, if the defence wishes to have a document admitted in evidence, is to issue a summons under s20 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957.
[3] This course was followed by Mr Tuiavii and Mr Livingston. Mr Tuiavii issued a summons to the ESR and Mr Livingston to Dr Gainsford, a consultant to ESR, to give evidence concerning the evidential breath test devices and in particular to produce the manufacturers’ manuals in respect of the devices. The ESR and Dr…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read J P Livingston v Environmental Science and Research and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] NZCA 115
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal considered the legal issues, including whether there was a defence based on possible malfunction of an individual device, if so, whether the instrument manual was relevant to such a defence, whether the witness summonses were issued for an improper purpose, whether the summonses should have been set aside on the basis of s35 of the Evidence Amendment Act (No 2) 1980 (EAA), and whether the decision as to admissibility should have been left to the District Court. The Court of Appeal held that there was a defence based on possible malfunction of a particular device, but it was a very narrow one indeed. The instrument manuals were irrelevant to the appellants’ cases, and the witness summonses were not issued for a proper purpose. The Court of Appeal did not consider it necessary to address s35 of the EAA, as the witness summonses were properly set aside. The appeals of Mr Tuiavii and Mr Livingston were dismissed.
The Court of Appeal did not make any specific final orders in relation to costs, but the parties were given leave to file memoranda if there was any question of costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Tuiavii and Mr Livingston issued summonses to the ESR and Dr Gainsford to give evidence concerning the breath test devices and to produce the manufacturers' manuals. The ESR and Dr Gainsford applied to the High Court to set aside the witness summonses. By judgment of 28 June 2002, Justice Williams granted these applications. Mr Tuiavii and Mr Livingston appealed against this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is there a defence based on possible malfunction of an individual device?
2. If so, is the instrument manual relevant to such a defence?
3. Were the witness summonses issued for an improper purpose – i.e. for discovery and inspection?
4. Should the summonses have been set aside on the basis of s35 of the Evidence Amendment Act (No 2) 1980?
5. Should the decision as to admissibility have been left to the District Court?
Held
1. The Court held that there is a narrow defence based on possible malfunction of an individual device on a particular occasion, provided that the defendant lays an adequate evidentiary foundation and convinces the judge that there is a reasonable doubt about the reliability of the device on that occasion.
2. The Court concluded that the instrument manuals were irrelevant to the appellants' cases as they did not provide any information necessary to answer the specific questions raised regarding the possible faults in the devices.
3. The Court held that the witness summonses were issued for an improper purpose as they were used to obtain discovery and inspection of documents held by third parties rather than for the purpose of having the instrument manuals admitted in evidence.
4. The Court found that the summonses should have been set aside, as the manuals were irrelevant to the appellants' cases, and thus it was not necessary to consider s35 of the Evidence Amendment Act (No. 2) 1980.
5. The Court held that the decision as to admissibility should not have been left to the District Court as the manuals were irrelevant and the witness summonses were issued for an improper purpose.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court first addressed the issue of whether there is a defence based on possible malfunction of an individual device. The Court found that such a defence exists, but it is narrow and requires an adequate evidentiary foundation. The Court noted that the legislative scheme suggests that the result of an evidential breath test by an approved device is intended to be assumed to be reliable, but it is not infallible. The Court also found that Parliament recognised the existence of a defence of malfunction in the 2001 amendments to the Land Transport Act 1998. However, the defence is limited to specific complaints about the device's performance on a particular occasion and cannot be a disguised challenge to the reliability of the type of device in general.
Next, the Court examined whether the instrument manuals were relevant to the appellants' cases. The Court concluded that the manuals were irrelevant as they did not provide any information necessary to answer the specific questions raised regarding the possible faults in the devices. The Court found that the defence of malfunction is limited to actual faults that are capable of affecting reliability to the extent required, and access to the manuals could only be for a fishing expedition or to mount a general challenge on the reliability of the device in question.
The Court then considered whether the witness summonses were issued for an improper purpose. The Court held that the summonses were not issued for a proper purpose as the manuals were irrelevant and could not be adduced in evidence. The Court found that the witness summons procedure cannot be used as a means of obtaining discovery of documents held by third parties.
Regarding s35 of the Evidence Amendment Act (No. 2) 1980, the Court noted that while it applies only at trial, it is a relevant consideration in deciding whether to set aside a witness summons. The Court also commented on the balancing exercise that must be conducted when considering a challenge to a witness summons, weighing the importance of the material to a fair trial against other public interest considerations.
Finally, the Court addressed the issue of whether the decision as to admissibility should have been left to the District Court. The Court held that it should not have been left to the District Court, as the manuals were irrelevant and the witness summonses were issued for an improper purpose. The Court found that the lack of relevance of the manuals and the public interest factors discussed above made it unnecessary to leave the decision on the witness summonses to trial.