IZRAEL IZIAH MITCHELL HUATA AND THE KING

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA316/2024
 [2024] NZCA 521

BETWEEN

IZRAEL IZIAH MITCHELL HUATA
Appellant

AND

THE KING
Respondent

Hearing:

4 September 2024

Court:

Cooke, Collins and Grice JJ

Counsel:

W R Hawkins for Appellant
M J R Blaschke for Respondent

Judgment:

16 October 2024 at 10.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for an extension of time to bring an appeal against conviction is granted.

BThe appeal against conviction is allowed.  The conviction for aggravated burglary (CRN: 23019001583) is set aside and a conviction for burglary is entered.

CThe appeal against sentence is allowed in part.  The sentence of two years and two months’ imprisonment for aggravated burglary (CRN: 23019001583) is set aside and a sentence of two years and two months’ imprisonment to be served cumulatively on the other sentences imposed by the District Court on 24 April 2024 is imposed for the substituted charge of burglary.

DThe four-year minimum period of imprisonment is set aside.  A minimum period of imprisonment of two years is imposed on the sentence for aggravated burglary (CRN: 23019001578), and a minimum period of imprisonment of one year is imposed on the sentence for burglary.  The minimum periods of imprisonment are to be served cumulatively.

EThe appeal against sentence is otherwise dismissed.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Grice J)

Introduction

  1. Mr Huata was sentenced in the Napier District Court on 23 April 2024 to nine years and two months’ imprisonment, with a minimum period of imprisonment (MPI) of four years, after being convicted on a number of charges.[1]  He appeals against his sentence in relation to the following Crown charges: aggravated robbery,  assault with intent to injure (representative), burglary, aggravated burglary, assault with a weapon, unlawful possession of a firearm, and common assault.  At the same time, Mr Huata was sentenced on a number of Police charges.  No appeal has been filed in respect of the Police charges.

    [1]R v Huata [2024] NZDC 9190 [Sentencing notes].

  2. Mr Huata says that the Judge erred in his approach by taking into account the aggravating features of the offending and the offender at the end of the sentencing exercise, effectively nullifying the totality principle and resulting in an end sentence that was manifestly excessive.  The Crown submits that there was no error in the sentencing methodology, and that in any event, it is the end sentence that is critical, not the manner in which it was reached.  The Crown nevertheless identifies two “technical” errors in the sentence which it invites the Court to correct on appeal.

Background

  1. The Crown offending relates to three separate incidents in November 2022, December 2022, and January 2023 respectively.[2]  The Police charges, which are not under appeal, were dealt with by the Judge as a discrete fourth group of offences.[3]

    [2]Sentencing notes, above n 1, at [1]–[4].  We have relied on the Judge’s sentencing notes in setting out the factual background to the offending.

    [3]At [49].

  2. Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IZRAEL IZIAH MITCHELL HUATA AND THE KING and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZCA 521
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Izreal Iziah Mitchell Huata, was convicted in the District Court of various serious criminal offences and sentenced to a total of nine years and two months’ imprisonment with a four-year minimum period of imprisonment (MPI). He appealed both his conviction and sentence. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal against conviction and sentence in part. The conviction for aggravated burglary was set aside, and a conviction for burglary was entered in its place. The sentence of two years and two months’ imprisonment for aggravated burglary was set aside and a sentence of two years and two months’ imprisonment to be served cumulatively on the other sentences imposed by the District Court was imposed for the substituted charge of burglary. The four-year MPI was set aside, and a two-year MPI was imposed on the sentence for aggravated burglary, and a one-year MPI was imposed on the sentence for burglary. The appeal against sentence was otherwise dismissed.

The appellant was convicted of three sets of Crown charges relating to incidents in November 2022, December 2022, and January 2023, and a number of Police charges. He appealed the sentence imposed on the Crown charges. The Crown submitted that there was no error in the sentencing methodology, and that the end sentence was appropriate.

The Court considered the methodology applied by the sentencing Judge in calculating the sentence. The Judge adopted a two-step approach as prescribed in Moses v R, which was consistent with the sentencing principles under the Sentencing Act 2002. The Court found that the Judge’s application of the two-step approach was generally sound, but that he had erred by applying a 15 per cent discount for personal factors to a term of imprisonment that had already been discounted for the guilty pleas. The Court also found that the Judge had erred in the manner in which he imposed the MPI, which should have been apportioned over the individual sentences.

The Court found that the final sentence of nine years and two months’ imprisonment was not manifestly excessive. The Court accepted that the sentence was appropriate in light of the gravity of the offending as a whole. The Court also found that the four-year MPI imposed by the Judge was not appropriate, as it was calculated by reference to the total sum of a number of cumulative sentences rather than a particular determinative sentence of more than two years imprisonment. The Court considered that an MPI was necessary to denounce and deter the offending, and provide extra protection for the community, and imposed a two-year MPI on the sentence for aggravated burglary and a one-year MPI on the sentence for burglary.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr. Izreal Iziah Mitchell Huata was convicted and sentenced by the Napier District Court on 24 April 2024. He was found guilty of multiple charges including aggravated robbery, assault with intent to injure, burglary, aggravated burglary, assault with a weapon, unlawful possession of a firearm, and common assault. Additionally, he was convicted on several Police charges including driving while disqualified, breach of bail, and breach of an intensive supervision sentence. The offences span from November 2022 to January 2023 and involved significant violence, use of weapons, and gang activity. The court imposed a sentence of nine years and two months’ imprisonment with a four-year minimum period of imprisonment.

Mr. Huata appealed against his conviction and sentence. The appeal was heard by the Court of Appeal of New Zealand on 4 September 2024, with judgment delivered on 16 October 2024. The appeal addressed both the conviction for aggravated burglary and the overall sentence imposed. The Court allowed the appeal in part, setting aside the conviction for aggravated burglary and substituting it with a conviction for burglary. The Court also modified the sentence by setting aside the four-year minimum period of imprisonment and imposing new minimum periods of imprisonment on the sentences for aggravated burglary and burglary.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the application for an extension of time to bring an appeal against conviction should be granted.
2. Whether the appeal against the conviction for aggravated burglary should be allowed.
3. Whether the appeal against the sentence should be allowed in part or in whole.
4. Whether the four-year minimum period of imprisonment should be set aside and new minimum periods imposed.
5. Whether the manner in which the final sentence was apportioned was correct.

Held
1. The application for an extension of time to bring an appeal against conviction is granted.
2. The appeal against conviction is allowed. The conviction for aggravated burglary (CRN: 23019001583) is set aside and a conviction for burglary is entered.
3. The appeal against sentence is allowed in part. The sentence of two years and two months’ imprisonment for aggravated burglary (CRN: 23019001583) is set aside and a sentence of two years and two months’ imprisonment to be served cumulatively on the other sentences imposed by the District Court on 24 April 2024 is imposed for the substituted charge of burglary.
4. The four-year minimum period of imprisonment is set aside. A minimum period of imprisonment of two years is imposed on the sentence for aggravated burglary (CRN: 23019001578), and a minimum period of imprisonment of one year is imposed on the sentence for burglary. The minimum periods of imprisonment are to be served cumulatively.
5. The appeal against sentence is otherwise dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal addressed several issues in the appeal of Izrael Iziah Mitchell Huata, focusing on the correctness of the sentencing process and the appropriateness of the imposed sentence. The appeal was allowed in part, and the Court set aside the conviction for aggravated burglary, substituting it with a conviction for burglary. It also adjusted the sentence and the minimum period of imprisonment. The reasoning of the Court was grounded in the principles established in Moses v R, which provides a two-step approach to sentencing. The Court found that while the Judge's methodology had some discrepancies, the final sentence was not manifestly excessive, thus it did not merit a complete overturning of the sentence. The Court also addressed the imposition of the minimum period of imprisonment, correcting the manner in which it was applied across the various sentences. The Court concluded that the final sentence, despite the procedural errors, was appropriate given the gravity of the offending and the need to protect the community and deter future offending.