International Roofing Limited v Global Roofing Solutions Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CIV-2013-470-497 [2014] NZHC 2913

BETWEEN

INTERNATIONAL ROOFING LIMITED

First Plaintiff

PEARCE TOOL & MANUFACTURING LIMITED

Second Plaintiff

APEX TILE MANUFACTURING LIMITED

Third Plaintiffs

AND

GLOBAL ROOFING SOLUTIONS LIMITED

First Defendant

PHOENIX BUISNESS SLUTIONS (PBS) LIMITED

Second Defendant

LANCE ALFRED EAGLE Third Defendant

SOLUTION SERVICES NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Fourth Defendant

ANTHONY JOHN RODGER Fifth Defendant

CHRISTOPHER SUKKEL Sixth Defendant

Hearing: 13 November 2014

Appearances:

P D M Johns for Plaintiffs
J Mangal for Defendants

Judgment:

13 November 2014

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BELL

INTERNATIONAL ROOFING LIMITED v GLOBAL ROOFING SOLUTIONS LIMITED [2014] NZHC 2913 [13 November 2014]

[1]      Mr Chris Sukkel has made non-party discovery under r 8.21 of the High Court Rules.   He is entitled to his actual and reasonable expenses in making discovery.  The question is how much?  He claims $26,338.50.  The plaintiffs say that that is too much.

[2]      This is intellectual property litigation.   The plaintiffs carry on business in Katikati, manufacturing metal roof tiles and machines that produce metal roof tiles. The defendants also carry on business in Katikati, manufacturing and distributing metal roof tiles.  The plaintiffs sue the defendants for breach of contract, breach of confidence, infringement of copyright, and breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986.

[3]      Mr Sukkel is a designer in Katikati.  He once worked for the plaintiffs.  Later, he supplied drawings and designs to the defendants.  The plaintiffs sought discovery of his documents.   On 3 April 2014  I made an order by consent for non-party discovery against Mr Sukkel and his company, CJ CAD Services Ltd.  That order required him to swear an affidavit listing:

(a)       CAD-CAM  files  obtained  by  him  from  his  employment  with  the plaintiffs;

(b)CAD-CAM files produced or designed by Mr Sukkel or CJ CAD Services Ltd for any of the defendants; and

(c)       correspondence  relating  to  the  plaintiffs’  designs  with  any of  the

defendants or companies or individuals connected with them.

[4]      He was required to file and swear the affidavit by 5 May 2014.  Inspection of documents was to be completed by 31 May 2014.  The plaintiffs were required to pay his reasonable costs in providing discovery and inspection of his discoverable documents.

[5]      He swore an affidavit of documents on 12 May 2014.  It is nine pages long and lists 162 documents.  In June the plaintiffs complained that Mr Sukkel’s affidavit was insufficient.   On 31 July 2014 they filed an application to enforce the discovery

order against Mr Sukkel and CJ CAD Services Ltd.  The plaintiffs wanted the court to declare that  Mr Sukkel was  in contempt of court.   In  a minute following a conference on 26 August 2014 I directed that all outstanding affidavits of documents were to be filed and served by 30 September 2014.  That included further discovery by Mr Sukkel.

[6]      Mr Sukkel swore a fresh affidavit of documents on 26 September 2014.  It is

198 pages long.   It lists 4,636 documents. For both affidavits of documents, the lawyers Mr Sukkel went…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read International Roofing Limited v Global Roofing Solutions Lim... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2913
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of International Roofing Limited v Global Roofing Solutions Limited, the plaintiffs, a group of companies involved in the manufacture and distribution of metal roof tiles, sought discovery of documents from Mr Chris Sukkel, a former employee who later supplied designs to the defendants. Mr Sukkel was ordered to provide a list of documents and pay for their inspection, and he sought reimbursement for his costs in complying with the order. The plaintiffs challenged the reasonableness of Mr Sukkel's claimed costs, arguing they were excessive and not necessary for compliance with the discovery order. The court examined the nature of the documents, the difficulty of the task, and the reasonableness of the fees charged by Mr Sukkel's lawyers. The court concluded that the claimed costs were excessive and did not accurately reflect the work required to comply with the discovery order. The court assessed the reasonable costs that a competent lawyer would charge and fixed the costs at $16,225 for legal fees and $6,975 for secretarial work, totaling $23,175. Additionally, the court allowed Mr Sukkel $2,141.55 for his own time and expenses, bringing the total to $25,316.55. However, the court made a deduction of $2,000 for the plaintiffs' additional costs due to the delay in Mr Sukkel's compliance with the discovery order, resulting in a final award of $23,316.55. The court did not make an order for costs on the costs application, as both parties had mixed success in their claims.