| IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI MANA NUI |
| SC 86/2021 [2021] NZSC 135 |
| BETWEEN | IKON BUILDING CO-OPERATION LIMITED |
| AND | POURUSHASP ROHINTON DUMASIA |
| Court: | William Young, Glazebrook and O’Regan JJ |
Counsel: | M J W Lenihan and D A Cowan for Applicant |
Judgment: | 13 October 2021 |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe application for leave to appeal is dismissed.
BThe applicant must pay the respondents one set of costs of $2,500.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS
The respondents, Pourushasp Dumasia and David Hilliam, guaranteed advances made by New Zealand Mortgages and Securities Ltd (NZMS) to SKKY Holdings 2015 Ltd (SKKY). These advances were made pursuant to a funding agreement in relation to a residential property development involving SKKY. Messrs Dumasia and Hilliam were directors of SKKY. The principal contractor involved in the development abandoned the contract in what appears to have been April 2017. This resulted in a discussion between Messrs Dumasia and Hilliam and a director of NZMS on 1 May 2017 and subsequent correspondence. While there is dispute as to what, if anything, was agreed, NZMS did not treat SKKY as being in default and it agreed to certain remedial work being carried out.
On 13 June 2017, NZMS assigned the loan to Bolter Management Group Ltd (Bolter), which was acting as trustee for the applicant, Ikon Building Co-operation Ltd (Ikon). On 14 June 2017, NZMS notified Mr Dumasia of the assignment. It explained the transfer on the basis that SKKY was in default and that this had the potential to affect its own banking arrangements.
On 19 June 2017, Bolter served notices of default on SKKY and Messrs Dumasia and Hilliam. Bolter later sold the property under its power of sale. Ikon, having taken an assignment of the rights of Bolter, obtained summary judgment against Messrs Dumasia and Hilliam for the deficiency between the amount outstanding on the advance and what was realised on sale.[1] Messrs Dumasia and Hilliam were successful in their appeal to the Court of Appeal in respect of this judgment,[2] and Ikon now seeks leave to appeal to this Court.
[1]Ikon Building Co-operation Ltdv Dumasia [2020] NZHC 223 (Lang J).
[2]Dumasia v Ikon Building Co-operation Ltd [2021] NZCA 292 (Cooper, Mallon and Wylie JJ).
In allowing the appeal, the Court of Appeal concluded that in light of what had happened in May 2017 between NZMS on the one hand and SKKY and Messrs Dumasia and Hilliam on the other, it was reasonably arguable that:
(a)the default notice served on 19 June 2017 was premature;[3]
(b)the default notice was a repudiatory breach of the funding agreement as indicating that funding required under the funding agreement would not be provided;[4]
(c)the default notice resulted in the funding and progress of the development stopping;[5] and
(d)a no set‑off clause in the funding agreement was ineffective to shield Ikon from the consequences of a breach by Bolter.[6]
[3]At [48].
[4]At [48]–[49].
[5]We see…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ikon Building Co-Operation Limited v Dumasia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NZSC 135
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court were whether the Court of Appeal erred in law in allowing the appeal, and whether the application for leave to appeal involved a question of general or public importance. The Court held that the appeal to the Court of Appeal was well-founded as there was an arguable case that the notice of default was premature and amounted to a repudiatory breach of the funding agreement. However, the Court found that Ikon's arguments in support of the application for leave to appeal did not engage with the substance of the Court of Appeal's reasoning. The Court held that the arguable entitlement of the respondents to damages against Ikon for the repudiatory breach and to set off such damages against their liability to Ikon was not obviously affected by the subsequent attempts by the respondents to come to an arrangement with Ikon. The Court also found that the case did not involve any question of general or public importance.
The Court held that the arguments presented by Ikon in support of the application for leave to appeal did not engage with the substance of the Court of Appeal's reasoning. The Court found that the primary point made by the Court of Appeal was that it was arguable that the effect of the notice of default was an assertion by Ikon that the funding obligations of NZMS would not be honoured. The Court held that the arguable entitlement of the respondents to damages against Ikon for that refusal and to set off such damages against their liability to Ikon was not obviously affected by the subsequent attempts by the respondents to come to an arrangement with Ikon. The Court found that there was no appearance of a miscarriage of justice and that the application for leave to appeal was accordingly dismissed.
The Supreme Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal and ordered Ikon to pay the respondents' costs of $2,500. The Court held that the arguments presented by Ikon in support of the application for leave to appeal did not engage with the substance of the Court of Appeal's reasoning, and that there was no indication that the case involved any question of general or public importance. The Court found that the appeal to the Court of Appeal was well-founded, but that the application for leave to appeal was accordingly dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Dumasia and Hilliam appealed the summary judgment obtained by Ikon, which was successful in the Court of Appeal. Ikon then sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of New Zealand. The Court of Appeal had concluded that it was reasonably arguable that the default notice served on 19 June 2017 was premature, constituted a repudiatory breach of the funding agreement, resulted in the funding and progress of the development stopping, and that a no set-off clause in the funding agreement was ineffective to shield Ikon from the consequences of a breach by Bolter. Ikon argued that assuming the notice of default was a repudiatory breach, SKKY and the guarantors subsequently affirmed the contract after the notice was issued. The Supreme Court dismissed Ikon's application for leave to appeal and ordered Ikon to pay Dumasia and Hilliam one set of costs of $2,500.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the application for leave to appeal should be granted.
2. Whether the default notice served on 19 June 2017 was premature.
3. Whether the default notice was a repudiatory breach of the funding agreement.
4. Whether the default notice resulted in the funding and progress of the development stopping.
5. Whether a no set-off clause in the funding agreement was ineffective to shield Ikon from the consequences of a breach by Bolter.
6. Whether SKKY and the guarantors affirmed the contract after the notice was issued.
Held
1. The application for leave to appeal is dismissed.
2. The court did not rule on whether the default notice served on 19 June 2017 was premature.
3. The court did not rule on whether the default notice was a repudiatory breach of the funding agreement.
4. The court did not rule on whether the default notice resulted in the funding and progress of the development stopping.
5. The court did not rule on whether a no set-off clause in the funding agreement was ineffective to shield Ikon from the consequences of a breach by Bolter.
6. The court did not rule on whether SKKY and the guarantors affirmed the contract after the notice was issued.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Supreme Court of New Zealand dismissed the application for leave to appeal by Ikon Building Co-operation Limited against the decision of the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal had allowed the appeal by Pourushasp Rohinton Dumasia and David Hilliam, who were guarantors of advances made by New Zealand Mortgages and Securities Ltd (NZMS) to SKKY Holdings 2015 Ltd (SKKY). The Court of Appeal had concluded that it was reasonably arguable that the default notice served by Bolter Management Group Ltd (Bolter) on 19 June 2017 was premature, that it was a repudiatory breach of the funding agreement, that it resulted in the funding and progress of the development stopping, and that a no set-off clause in the funding agreement was ineffective to shield Ikon from the consequences of a breach by Bolter. The Supreme Court noted that Ikon's arguments for leave to appeal did not engage with the substance of the Court of Appeal's reasoning and did not suggest any question of general or public importance. The Court found no appearance of a miscarriage of justice, and the application for leave to appeal was dismissed. Ikon was ordered to pay Dumasia and Hilliam one set of costs of $2,500.
The Supreme Court emphasised that it did not rule on the merits of the arguments regarding the prematurity of the default notice, the repudiatory breach, the effect on the development's funding and progress, the effectiveness of the no set-off clause, or the alleged affirmation of the contract by SKKY and the guarantors. The Court focused on whether the application for leave to appeal met the criteria under section 74(2) of the Senior Courts Act 2016. It concluded that the application did not demonstrate a miscarriage of justice or a question of general or public importance, and therefore, leave to appeal was denied.