IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE
CIV-2021-009-1087
[2022] NZHC 400
BETWEEN IDEAL INVESTMENTS LIMITED
Plaintiff
AND
THE EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION
Defendant
Hearing: 21 February 2022 (by AVL) Appearances:
G Shand for Plaintiff
C Curran and N Walker for Defendant
Judgment:
9 March 2022
JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE LESTER
IDEAL INVESTMENTS LIMITED v THE EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION [2022] NZHC 400 [9 March 2022]
[1] On 18 May 2021, Ideal Investments Limited (Ideal) issued this claim asserting the Earthquake Commission (EQC) breached s 29(4) of the Earthquake Commission Act 1993 (the Act) in relation to Ideal’s claim arising from the Canterbury earthquakes in 2010 and 2011.
[2]Section 29(4) provides:
(4)Subject to any regulations made under this Act and without limiting the liability of the Commission under this Act, any payments or expenditure for which the Commission may be liable under this section shall be made as soon as reasonably practicable, and in any event not later than 1 year after the amount of the damage has been duly determined (which determination shall be made as soon as reasonably practicable).
[3] Ideal’s claim concerns two of its investment properties. In respect of one property, EQC’s initial assessment resulted in a payment of $837.34 to Ideal on 3 August 2015. In respect of this property EQC eventually made the following additional payments set out below. A total of $105,902.45 was paid.
(i) $64,302.22 on 5 July 2016
(ii) $ 3,564.01 on 22 September 2016 (iii) $37,198.88 on 23 March 2018.
[4] A similar pattern of an initial assessment and payment made in June 2015 followed by further substantial payments in May 2016 occurred with Ideal’s second property.
[5] The claim in respect of each property is essentially the same; that as a result of EQC’s “erroneous” assessment of its claims, Ideal received its full entitlement in respect of each property later than would have been the case had EQC conducted a reasonable and prudent assessment in the first place.
[6] Ideal says as a result of delays in receiving its full entitlement, it incurred mortgage interest it would not have otherwise incurred. For each property, the claim is for damages calculated at the interest rate payable by Ideal under its mortgages from the date of the initial payment through to the date of each subsequent payment. Interest is sought on such damages under the Interest on Money Claims Act 2016.
[7] The value of Ideal’s claim in respect of one property is $10,179 together with almost $2,000 in interest. In respect of the other property, a claim of $8,590 and interest on that sum of $1,711.
[8] As the size of those claims suggest, Ideal initially issued its proceedings in the District Court. On 3 June 2021, Ideal filed an application under r 4.24 of the District Court Rules seeking leave to sue as a representative plaintiff.
[9] The class definition that accompanied that application has been subsequently amended,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ideal Investments Ltd v Earthquake Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NZHC 400
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that the common issue, as proposed by Ideal, was inherently specific to the individual circumstances of each property, and individual claimants would still need to prove that EQC’s handling of their claim breached s 29(4) of the Earthquake Commission Act 1993. The court also held that the proposed class was not appropriate as it included those who had suffered a loss of investment opportunity as well as those who had incurred unnecessary interest, and Ideal did not assert a loss of investment opportunity in its statement of claim. The court concluded that Ideal's application should be declined on the basis that the common issue as advanced raised factual issues personal to each homeowner.
The court also addressed EQC's submission that including assignees in the class would be to confer upon them an ability to claim they could not establish in a separate proceeding. The court held that the ability to sue on an assigned cause of action does not depend on the assignee being able to show any personal loss in respect of that cause of action, and the assignee seeks to recover a loss suffered by another person, their assignor. The court held that including assignees in the class is not the step that confers upon them the claim they would not otherwise have, and an assignee can sue on their assigned claim whether they are included in the class or not.
Costs were ordered to follow the event on a 2B basis in favour of EQC plus disbursements as fixed by the Registrar.