ICL Construction (2016) Limited v Ian Roebuck Crane Hire Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA66/2023
 [2023] NZCA 364

BETWEEN

ICL CONSTRUCTION (2016) LIMITED
Applicant

AND

IAN ROEBUCK CRANE HIRE LIMITED
Respondent

Court:

Courtney and Mallon JJ

Counsel:

G R Grant and T J Rainey for Applicant
I D Matheson for Respondent

Judgment:
(On the papers)

14 August 2023 at 11 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A      The application for leave to appeal is declined.

BThe applicant must pay costs to the respondent for a standard application on a band A basis with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Mallon J)

Background

  1. The applicant (ICL) is a construction company.  The respondent (Roebuck) is a crane hiring company.  ICL and Roebuck entered into an agreement in 2017 under which Roebuck provided its services for a construction project ICL was undertaking.  At some point ICL stopped paying regular invoices for the use of Roebuck’s cranes and a dispute arose over what had been agreed about the price ICL would pay.

  2. Roebuck issued proceedings seeking judgment for $64,098 plus interest and costs.  Roebuck’s position was that the agreement was that ICL would have a 100 t crane on site, be charged only for the hours it was used and at the rate applicable for the size of the crane needed for the job, and with a ten per cent discount.  ICL contended there was a maximum price or estimate for the job of $215,000 and no hourly rates were discussed or agreed.  Roebuck’s proceeding claimed the difference between the total invoiced to ICL and the claimed maximum price of $215,000.

  3. By the agreement of the parties, the claim proceeded to a liability only hearing in the District Court before Judge Greig.  This had followed discussions between them culminating in correspondence shortly before the hearing.  In that correspondence, ICL’s counsel advised Roebuck’s counsel that, once the liability issue was resolved, the actual quantum would become “virtually academic” and to ask the Court to determine quantum “would be hugely uneconomic”.

  4. The Judge found in favour of Roebuck on liability.[1]  ICL subsequently briefed witnesses on quantum to seek to challenge quantum at a further hearing on an invoice by invoice basis of which there were a large number.  The Judge struck out the briefs as they contested quantum on a basis that had not been pleaded and that was contrary to the basis on which ICL had contested liability.[2] 

    [1]Ian Roebuck Crane Hire Ltd v ICL Construction (2016) Ltd [2021] NZDC 16806 [District Court liability decision].

    [2]Ian Roebuck Crane Hire Ltd v ICL Construction (2016) Ltd [2022] NZDC 1576 [District Court evidence decision].

  5. The Judge also considered it would be prejudicial to Roebuck to allow ICL to proceed with this challenge to quantum.[3]  That was because Roebuck would have difficulties in locating the crane operator and asking him to recall details of each and every time the crane was used over four years ago.[4]  Further, if quantum was to have been challenged,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ICL Construction (2016) Limited v Ian Roebuck Crane Hire Lim... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZCA 364
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, ICL Construction (2016) Limited, a construction company, appealed against a decision of the High Court, which declined to grant leave to appeal the District Court's decision in a dispute with Ian Roebuck Crane Hire Limited, a crane hiring company. The dispute centred around an agreement under which Roebuck provided services for a construction project undertaken by ICL. The core issue was whether the District Court was correct in striking out ICL's briefs of evidence which contested the quantum of damages on a basis that had not been pleaded and was contrary to the basis on which ICL had contested liability. Additionally, ICL challenged the District Court's order for an interim payment of $60,000 to Roebuck. The Court of Appeal found that the District Court was correct in striking out ICL's briefs of evidence, as it was necessary to secure the just, speedy, and inexpensive determination of the proceeding. The Court of Appeal also found that the award of $60,000 was a consequence of the striking out of the briefs of evidence and was not challenged except to the extent that it would be set aside if ICL succeeded on an appeal concerning the rule 1.8 issue.

The Court of Appeal held that the District Court was within its rights to strike out ICL's briefs of evidence, as it was necessary to ensure a just, speedy, and inexpensive determination of the proceeding. The Court considered that ICL's simple denial of the pleaded quantum did not provide Roebuck with fair notice of ICL's intention to contest quantum on the basis of alleged errors in the invoices. This was particularly so given the correspondence between counsel, which indicated that any quantum issues would be minor and likely to be resolved informally. The Court found that there was no question of law or fact capable of bona fide and serious argument, as even if there were, there was no public interest and the limited private interest in granting leave was not of sufficient importance to outweigh the cost and delay of a further appeal.

As a result, the Court of Appeal declined the application for leave to appeal and ordered that ICL must pay costs to Roebuck for a standard application on a band A basis with usual disbursements. This decision reinforces the importance of adhering to the procedural rules and providing fair notice to the opposing party when contesting the quantum of damages in a legal proceeding. The Court's decision also highlights the need to weigh the public and private interests in granting leave to appeal against the cost and delay of a further appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established