IAG New Zealand Limited v Dewes

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2021-409-260

[2022] NZHC 3555

UNDER THE CANTERBURY EARTHQUAKES INSURANCE TRIBUNAL ACT 2019

BETWEEN

IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Appellant

AND

CATHERINE FRANCES DEWES, ROBERT DENTON GREEN AND DIANA ROSEMARY SHAND (AS TRUSTEES OF THE DEWES GREEN FAMILY TRUST)

Respondents

Hearing: 23 November 2021

Appearances:

C F Finlayson KC, S D McIntyre (in Person) and O V Collette- Moxon (by way of VMR) for Appellant

T C Weston KC with A J Prebble as Counsel Assisting No Appearance for Respondents

Judgment:

20 December 2022


JUDGMENT OF EATON J


This judgment was delivered by me on 20 December 2022 at 11 am pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

IAG NEW ZEALAND LTD v DEWES [2022] NZHC 3555 [20 December 2022]

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction [1]
The appeal [5]
Factual background [6]
How the Tribunal operates and its costs jurisdiction [16]
Leave to appeal granted [29]
The Tribunal’s costs decision [30]
The decision regarding “without substantial merit” [36]
Factors relied on by Family Trust in seeking costs [39]
Bad faith [43]

Tribunal’s factual findings relating to “bad faith” and “substantial

merit”

[47]
The issues raised in this appeal [61]
Approach on appeal [62]
Consideration of scale costs regime in the context of a s 47 application [64]
Conclusion on alleged error – commonality of costs regime [67]
Analysis [67]
Bad faith [68]
IAG’s submissions – test for “bad faith” [68]
Family Trust’s arguments – test for “bad faith” [77]
Analysis – what is “bad faith” [83]
Application of “bad faith” on the facts [97]
Admissibility challenge [99]
Conclusion – admissibility challenge – bad faith [106]
Uncompromising approach by IAG [113]

Errors by experts and a party’s obligation to foster agreement between

experts

[120]
Analysis [120]
Expert evidence on structural issues [124]
Conclusion – structural issues [133]
Steel windows [134]
Conclusion – steel windows [147]
Roof [150]
Narrowing real issues as to bathroom [151]
The Tribunal on the defective design/workmanship hypothesis [154]
The Tribunal on the leak in the plumbing hypothesis [156]
Decision – bathroom – bad faith [163]
Substantial merit [166]
IAG’s submissions – what is “without substantial merit”? [166]
Family Trust’s submissions – what is “without substantial merit”? [169]
What is “without substantial merit”? [170]
Without substantial merit – application on the facts [183]
Reliance on expert evidence [184]
Dislevelment [187]
Analysis [194]
Bathroom floor [195]
Steel windows [196]
Roof [203]
Argument for IAG – roof [213]
Analysis [214]
Result [227]
Adjustment to costs award under appeal [228]
Costs [230]

Introduction

[1]                IAG New Zealand Ltd (IAG) appeals a costs determination by the Canterbury Earthquakes Insurance Tribunal (the Tribunal).1

[2]                The Dewes Green Family Trust (Family Trust) had issued proceedings in the High Court at Christchurch against IAG following an insurance dispute over damage said to have occurred to the property owned by the Family Trust at 35 Rata Street, Christchurch in the Canterbury earthquakes. The High Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IAG New Zealand Limited v Dewes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 3555
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns a costs decision made by the Canterbury Earthquakes Insurance Tribunal (the Tribunal) against IAG New Zealand Limited (IAG). The Tribunal had determined that IAG had acted in bad faith and made allegations without substantial merit in relation to insurance claims made by the Dewes Green Family Trust (Family Trust) for earthquake damage to their property. The Tribunal awarded costs to the Family Trust. IAG appealed the costs decision. The appeal focused on the definitions of “bad faith” and “without substantial merit” under s 47 of the Canterbury Earthquakes Insurance Tribunal Act 2019 (the Act). The appeal also challenged specific factual findings made by the Tribunal in relation to IAG’s conduct. IAG contended that the Tribunal erroneously presumed commonality between the scale costs regime and s 47 of the Act. IAG also argued that the Tribunal erred in finding commonality between “good faith” and “bad faith”. The Family Trust argued that the Tribunal had correctly defined “bad faith” and applied it to the facts of this case. The Family Trust also argued that the Tribunal’s findings regarding IAG’s conduct were justified. The Court found that the Tribunal was correct in upholding its jurisdiction to award costs under s 47 of the Act. The Court found the Tribunal’s definition of “bad faith” was not erroneous. The Court found that the Tribunal had correctly applied the definition of “bad faith” to the facts of the case. The Court found that the Tribunal’s conclusions that IAG had acted in bad faith in relation to certain issues were incorrect. The Court found that IAG’s arguments were not without substantial merit. The Court allowed the appeal in part and quashed the Tribunal’s findings that IAG acted in bad faith. The Court upheld the Tribunal’s findings that IAG acted without substantial merit. The Court did not adjust the costs award of $13,160 made in favour of the Family Trust. The Court did not award costs on the appeal.