Hunter Valley Station Limited at Timaru v Attorney General

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA38/05

BETWEENHUNTER VALLEY STATION LIMITED AT TIMARU


Appellant

ANDTHE ATTORNEY-GENERAL


Respondent

Hearing:7 March 2006

Court:William Young  P, Robertson and Allan JJ

Counsel:N R W Davidson QC for Appellant


M T Parker for Respondent

Judgment:26 May 2006 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.  The order for specific performance made in the High Court is set aside and the claim for summary judgment by the Attorney-General is dismissed. 

B        Costs in the High Court are to be fixed in that Court.

CIn this Court HVSL is awarded costs of $6,000 together with usual disbursements.

REASONS

(Given by William Young P)

Introduction

[1]       This appeal arises out of the sale of a pastoral lease in 1975.  The sale was approved by the Land Settlement Board on a conditional basis but the transaction was settled prior to the conditions being satisfied.  Indeed, even now, at least one of the conditions remains unsatisfied.  The dispute as to this led, in the end, to the Attorney-General (suing on behalf of the Commissioner of Crown Lands) issuing proceedings seeking orders requiring the purchaser to comply with an outstanding condition requiring surrender of some land from the pastoral lease. In the High Court it was held that the purchaser, the present appellant, was contractually committed to satisfying the consent conditions, a conclusion which was not challenged before us.  An order for specific performance was made requiring compliance with the condition as to surrender of land.

[2]       The purchaser now appeals.

[3]       The conditions are expressed in vague and non specific language.  This would probably not have been a problem if the Commissioner (as lessor) had insisted upon compliance with them before the transaction was finalised.  One of the difficulties which the case now presents is that the conditions were not drafted with the precision which is customary for contractual terms dealing with interests in land and they are not easily susceptible to enforcement on a contractual basis.  The other primary difficulty is the lapse of time which has occurred since the transaction was entered into. 

Factual background

[4]       This case concerns Hunter Valley Station, which is situated on the western shores of Lake Hawea and up the western bank of the Hunter River.  It is approximately 96 kilometres in length and in parts up to 32 kilometres in width.

[5]       The station is subject to pastoral lease 179 (under s 66 of the Land Act 1948) which was entered into in February 1958.  The original lessee was Mr Murdoch Drake.  He transferred the lease to Mr James Gillespie in May 1963 and in 1975 Mr Gillespie entered into an agreement to sell the property on to Messrs Donald and Hamish Cochrane.  Hunter Valley Station Ltd (HVSL) was formed to complete the transaction.

[6]       HVSL was owned by Donald and Hamish Cochrane and their father, Mr Clifford Cochrane.  Donald and Hamish Cochrane were both in their 20s in 1975 and they were in effect being financed into the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hunter Valley Station Limited at Timaru v Attorney General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NZCA 104
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hunter Valley Station Limited at Timaru appealed against a High Court decision requiring them to comply with a condition of their pastoral lease requiring them to surrender land to the Mount Aspiring National Park. The appeal was heard by William Young P, Robertson and Allan JJ in the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The main issue was whether the appellants were contractually obliged to surrender land to the park as per the condition in their lease. The court found that while the appellants had accepted the conditions of consent, there were arguable defences that the Commissioner had not been ready, willing and able to comply with the contractual obligations which were the quid pro quo of the surrender obligation. The appeal was allowed, the order for specific performance made in the High Court was set aside, and the claim for summary judgment by the Attorney-General was dismissed. Hunter Valley Station Limited at Timaru was awarded costs of $6,000 together with usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established