Hunt v Macartney HC Auckland CIV 2010-404-1881

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2010-404-001881

BETWEEN  PAUL HUNT AND AMY HUNT Plaintiffs/Respondents

AND  PETER MACARTNEY

First Defendant/First Applicant

AND  VERNE MACARTNEY

Second Defendant/Second Applicant

ANDDOROTHY MACARTNEY Third Defendant/Third Applicant

ANDROSS MELVILLE Fourth Defendant

Hearing:         18 August 2010

Appearances: E Orlov and T Shah for Plaintiffs/Respondents

C T Patterson for First to Third Defendants/Applicants
No appearance for Fourth Defendant

Judgment:      25 August 2010 at 2:30pm

(RESERVED) JUDGMENT OF ANDREWS J [Defendants’ application to strike out cause of action]

This judgment is delivered by me on 25 August 2010 at 2:30pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

..................................................... Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:           Botany Law, DX EP84008 (Plaintiffs)

Jones Young, P O Box 189, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140 (Defendants)

Equity Law Limited, DX CX10246 (Plaintiffs) E Orlov

Counsel:            C T Patterson, P O Box 2886, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140 (Defendants)

HUNT & HUNT V MACARTNEY AND ORS HC AK CIV 2010-404-001881  25 August 2010

Introduction

[1]      The plaintiffs (“Mr and Mrs Hunt” or “the Hunts”) issued proceedings on 24

March 2010 alleging breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract and breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986 (“the Act”) against the first to third defendants (collectively “the Macartneys”).   The Macartneys have applied to strike out the Hunts’ claim under the Act.

[2]      The issue for determination is whether the Court can be certain that the claim under the Act cannot succeed, or that the claim is so certainly or clearly bad that it should be precluded from going forward.[1]

Background

[1] See Couch v Attorney-General [2008] NZSC 45, [2008] 3 NZLR 725 at [33], per Elias CJ

and Anderson J.

[3]      The second defendant, Verne Macartney, was the Managing Director of Performance Hosiery Limited (“PHL”).  He and his wife (the third defendant, Mrs Dorothy Macartney) had founded PHL, the shares in which were held by family trusts.   The first defendant, Mr Peter Macartney, is the son of Verne and Dorothy Macartney.

[4]      Mr Paul Hunt first started working part-time for PHL when he was about 14 years old.  When he left school in 1994 aged 16, Mr Hunt started working full time for PHL as a junior mechanic.  He remained at PHL until 2000, by which time he was head mechanic.

[5]      The Hunts decided to move to Australia, and moved to Melbourne in 2000. However, they returned to New Zealand, and Mr Hunt returned to work for PHL, early in 2001.

[6]      In 2005 the possibility of Mr Hunt’s purchasing a fifty per cent shareholding in PHL was raised.  The Hunts and the Macartneys dispute the manner in which this occurred and what Mr Hunt was told in respect of interest from other parties in

acquiring the company, and the implications of such an acquisition for the employment of Mr Peter Macartney and Mr Hunt.

[7]      During  the  period  from  July  to  October  2006  agreement  was  reached whereby the Hunts bought fifty per cent of the shares in PHL.   The Hunts…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hunt v Macartney HC Auckland CIV 2010-404-1881 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 1700
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Macartneys applied to strike out the Hunts’ claim under the Fair Trading Act 1986. The Hunts alleged that the Macartneys breached the Act by engaging in misleading or deceptive conduct during the sale of shares in Performance Hosiery Limited to the Hunts. The Macartneys argued that the claim under the Act was statute-barred and that the Hunts could not succeed in their allegation that the Macartneys were “in trade” within the meaning of the Act. The court considered the principles applicable to an application to strike out a pleading, which are well settled. The court concluded that the claim under the Act was not statute-barred, and the date of the discovery of the loss or damage was a question of fact that could not be determined at that stage. The court also concluded that whether the Macartneys were “in trade” was a question of fact to be determined in the facts and circumstances of the particular case, and therefore, the claim should not be struck out on this ground. The court dismissed the application to strike out the claim under the Act but ordered the Macartneys to pay costs to the Hunts on a 2B basis, together with any disbursements as certified by the registrar.

The Macartneys applied to strike out the Hunts’ claim under the Fair Trading Act 1986. The court considered the principles applicable to an application to strike out a pleading, which are well settled. The court concluded that the claim under the Act was not statute-barred, and the date of the discovery of the loss or damage was a question of fact that could not be determined at that stage. The court also concluded that whether the Macartneys were “in trade” was a question of fact to be determined in the facts and circumstances of the particular case, and therefore, the claim should not be struck out on this ground. The court dismissed the application to strike out the claim under the Act but ordered the Macartneys to pay costs to the Hunts on a 2B basis, together with any disbursements as certified by the registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established