Huikau Charitable Trust v Donovan Enterprises Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA WHANGĀREI-TERENGA-PARĀOA ROHE

CIV 2023-488-43

[2024] NZHC 1032

BETWEEN

HUIKAU CHARITABLE TRUST

Appellant

AND

DONOVAN ENTERPRISES LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing:

Further submissions:

30 October 2023

10 November 2023

Appearances:

J A Browne for the appellant

D M Grindle for the respondent

Judgment:

1 May 2024


JUDGMENT OF CAMPBELL J


This judgment was delivered by me on 1 May 2024 at 11.00 am pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

HUIKAU CHARITABLE TRUST v DONOVAN ENTERPRISES LIMITED [2024] NZHC 1032 [1 May 2024]

[1]    The appellant, the Huikau Charitable Trust (the Trust), is an incorporated charitable trust. It owns a property at 984 Whananaki South Road, Whananaki. The property fronts the Whananaki estuary. In late 2017, the Trust contracted the respondent, Donovan Enterprises Ltd (Donovans), to carry out work at the property. The work included building a seawall where the property fronts the estuary and preparing a site for a new dwelling.

[2]    Disputes arose between the parties as to whether Donovans had completed the work in accordance with the contract. The Trust refused to pay some of Donovans’ invoices. Donovans sued the Trust in the Whāngarei District Court for payment. The Trust responded with a counterclaim seeking damages for what it alleged was defective work by Donovans.

[3]    In a judgment dated 17 April 2023,1 Judge D J McDonald allowed Donovans’ claim for $5,663.75 for additional earthworks in preparing the site and rejected the Trust’s claim that Donovans had not built the seawall in accordance with the requirements of the contract. The Trust appeals from those two decisions.

Factual outline

[4]    Denise Hart is the driving force behind the Trust. Ms Hart previously owned the Whananaki property. In 2016, Ms Hart set up the Trust and transferred the property to it.

[5]    The aim of the Trust is to provide a safe holiday location with free accommodation for special needs and  underprivileged  children  and  their  carers. To meet that aim, the Trust wished to develop the property. This included the construction of a seawall and estuary access ramp and preparing a site for a new dwelling.

[6]    Before settling the Trust, Ms Hart engaged a company now called RS Engineering Ltd (RS Eng) to prepare reports and building plans for the proposed work


1      Donovan Enterprises Ltd v Hart [2023] NZDC 7175. In the District Court, the trustees of the Trust were named as defendants. In this Court, it was recognised that the Trust, as a separate legal entity, was the correct appellant.

at the property. RS Eng produced two reports. One was a Proposed Seawall Report. This included plans for the proposed seawall. The other was a Suitability Report. This included plans for the site of the proposed dwelling and the approximate extent of soil to be removed from that site.

[7]    The Trust sought quotes from two Whangārei contractors. One was Donovans. The principal of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Huikau Charitable Trust v Donovan Enterprises Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 1032
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerns a contractual dispute between the Huikau Charitable Trust and Donovan Enterprises Limited over the construction of a seawall and site preparation at a property owned by the Trust. The Trust, established to provide a holiday location for special needs and underprivileged children, contracted Donovans to carry out the work. Disputes arose over whether Donovans had completed the work in accordance with the contract, leading to the Trust refusing to pay some of Donovans’ invoices. Donovans sued the Trust in the Whāngarei District Court, which found in Donovans' favor for additional earthworks and rejected the Trust's claim regarding the seawall.

The High Court was asked to determine whether the District Court correctly found that the removal of a one-metre rise was not part of the original contract, that the seawall had been built in accordance with the plans, and that Donovans had not breached the contract. The Trust argued that the removal of the rise was part of the original contract, that the seawall had not been built in accordance with the plans in two respects, and that Donovans had breached the contract. The Trust also sought damages for the cost of reconstructing the seawall.

The Court found that the Judge correctly determined the removal of the one-metre rise was not part of the original contract. However, the Court held that the Judge erred in failing to find that the rock toe of the seawall had not been built in accordance with the plans and that the contract had been varied to allow a slope on the seawall greater than 2:1. The Court further found that the Judge erred in concluding that Donovans had not breached the contract in respect of the seawall. The Trust was not entitled to damages for the cost of rebuilding the seawall as it had not shown an intention to rebuild, but was awarded nominal damages of $10 for the breach.

The Court allowed the appeal in part, setting aside the District Court’s decision that Donovans had not breached the contract in building the seawall and awarding the Trust nominal damages of $10. The appeal was otherwise dismissed. The costs of the appeal were to lie where they fell.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established