Hugh Green Limited v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2016-404-3209

[2019] NZHC 660

UNDER the Judicature Amendment Act 1972

BETWEEN

HUGH GREEN LIMITED

First Plaintiff

GREERTON HOLDINGS LIMITED
Second Plaintiff

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL

Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Counsel:

ME Casey QC and AJ Casey for plaintiffs NMH Whittington and RJ Wilson for defendant

Judgment:

2 April 2019


JUDGMENT OF FITZGERALD J

[As to costs]


This judgment was delivered by me on 2 April 2019 at 4 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:           Kemps Weir, Auckland (S Weir)

Meredith Connell, Wellington

Hugh Green Limited v Auckland Council [2019] NZHC 660 [2 April 2019]

Introduction

[1]    Hugh Green Ltd (HGL) sought judicial review of Auckland Council’s (the Council’s) decision not to acquire certain land from HGL. HGL’s primary claim was breach of substantive legitimate expectation, by which it sought an order directing the Council to purchase the land in question. I dismissed that cause of action.1 HGL also pleaded more traditional grounds for judicial review, as well as an action in breach of contract. I dismissed most of the grounds of HGL’s judicial review cause of action, but did find that the Council had failed to take into account mandatory relevant considerations (being certain provisions of the underlying District Plan). I dismissed the breach of contract claim.

[2]    In terms of relief, I quashed the Council’s decision not to acquire HGL’s land and directed it to reconsider its decision.

[3]    I encouraged the parties to agree costs. They have not been able to do so. This judgment accordingly determines the competing positions on costs.

Background

[4]    The factual background to HGL’s claims is set out in some detail in the substantive judgment.2 It is not repeated here. Relevant to the costs arguments, however, there is no doubt HGL’s primary claim was its claim of substantive legitimate expectation. It was based on alleged representations or promises made by Council officers to HGL that the Council would acquire the land in question. As noted, I dismissed that cause of action.

[5]    The remaining judicial review causes of action can be broadly categorised as a failure to take into account (or give sufficient weight to) various relevant considerations, taking into account an irrelevant consideration, Wednesbury unreasonableness and breach of natural justice. As also noted above, HGL was successful on its argument that the Council failed to take into account certain


1      Hugh Green Ltd v Auckland Council [2018] NZHC 2916 [Judgment].

2      At [6]–[43].

mandatory relevant considerations and its decision was quashed as a result. The remainder of its claims failed.

[6]    The proceeding occupied five sitting days. Viva voce evidence was given by witnesses for both parties, and there was substantial cross-examination. The evidence and cross-examination related mainly to the lengthy engagement between the Council and HGL over some seven years, on which HGL relied in support of its claim of substantive legitimate expectation.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hugh Green Limited v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 660
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hugh Green Limited and Greerton Holdings Limited (collectively, HGL) sought judicial review of the Auckland Council's decision not to acquire certain land from HGL. The primary claim was breach of substantive legitimate expectation, by which HGL sought an order directing the Council to purchase the land in question. HGL also pleaded more traditional grounds for judicial review, as well as an action in breach of contract. The Council opposed the claims. The High Court found HGL was successful overall, as it was successful in having the Council’s decision quashed and directed the Council to reconsider its decision. However, the court found that the Council’s costs were significantly increased due to HGL's unsuccessful arguments, which required additional discovery and cross-examination. The court considered a reduction of 60 percent to the costs award to be appropriate, reflecting the additional time and cost incurred by the Council in meeting HGL’s unsuccessful claims. The court also found it appropriate to certify for second counsel in this case, as the matters in issue did warrant second counsel (for both parties). The court awarded HGL costs of $43,153.69, inclusive of disbursements, after applying the reduction.

The legal issues before the court were whether HGL was the successful party overall, and if so, what reduction (if any) should be made to the costs award to reflect the unsuccessful aspects of HGL’s claim. The court considered the Court of Appeal’s recent decisions in Water Guard NZ Ltd v Midgen Enterprises Ltd and Weaver v Auckland Council, which provided guidance on the assessment of costs in a case where the successful party has failed on arguments or causes of action which substantially increased the costs of the losing party. The court found that HGL was the successful party overall, but a reduction should be made to the costs award to reflect that HGL failed on significant aspects of its claim, which undoubtedly had the effect of significantly increasing the Council’s costs. The court assessed a 60 percent reduction to the costs award to be appropriate, and did not consider it appropriate to “slice and dice” matters such as hearing fees and copying and binding costs. The court also found it appropriate to certify for second counsel in this case. The court accordingly awarded HGL costs of $43,153.69, inclusive of disbursements, after applying the reduction.

The final orders of the court were that HGL was awarded costs of $43,153.69, inclusive of disbursements, after applying a 60 percent reduction. The court certified for second counsel in this case. The court also found it appropriate to apply the 60 percent reduction to the witness fees charged by Mr Baikie, HGL’s external planning consultant, as a not insignificant proportion of his evidence addressed the substantive legitimate expectation cause of action. The court did not accept the Council’s submission that no disbursement costs should be awarded in relation to Mr Baikie’s fees. The court also did not consider there was a principled basis upon which certain steps in the proceedings should be categorised as band C for time allocation purposes. The court found that to the extent that discovery, preparation of evidence and preparation for the hearing were more than what might have been expected, this was largely driven by the claims on which HGL was unsuccessful. The court emphasised that the 60 percent reduction reflected the additional time and cost incurred by the Council in meeting HGL’s unsuccessful claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established