Huata v Prebble

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA34/04

BETWEENDONNA AWATERE HUATA


Appellant

ANDRICHARD WILLIAM PREBBLE


First Respondent

ANDKEN SHIRLEY


Second Respondent

Hearing:1 April 2004

Coram:McGrath J
Glazebrook J
Hammond J
William Young J
O'Regan J

Appearances:  P J K Spring and A J Lloyd for Appellant


J E Hodder and B A Davies for Respondents

Judgment:16 July 2004 

JUDGMENTS OF THE COURT

Judgments
Para No
McGrath, Glazebrook and O’Regan JJ [1] to [143]
Hammond J [144] to [155]
William Young J [156] to [171]

MCGRATH, GLAZEBROOK AND O’REGAN JJ

(DELIVERED BY MCGRATH J)

Table of Contents

Paragraph Number

Introduction.................................................................................. [1]

The statutory regime.................................................................... [4]

The facts........................................................................................ [8]

High Court Judgment.................................................................. [30]

Parliamentary privilege

Introduction.............................................................................. [40]
     Composition of the House........................................................ [41]
     Internal proceedings................................................................. [44]
     Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1688.......................................... [68]
Scope of judicial review............................................................... [71]

Did the appellant distort proportionality

Distortion of Proportionality under s55D(a)........................... [73]

Submissions.............................................................................. [75]

Ordinary meaning.................................................................... [77]

Legislative history..................................................................... [82]

Constitutional context............................................................... [91]

NZ Bill of Rights Act 1990....................................................... [96]

Conclusion on distorting proportionality................................. [97]

What acts can distort proportionality....................................... [99]

Applying the law to the facts.................................................... [107]

Predetermination by the caucus................................................. [124]

Summary and conclusion............................................................. [139]

Introduction

[1]       The appellant, Mrs Donna Awatere Huata MP, was re-elected as a member of the House of Representatives in 2002, as a list member of the ACT party.  She appeals against a judgment of the High Court dismissing her application for judicial review of actions taken in relation to her seat in the House by the parliamentary leader of the ACT party and members of the ACT caucus.  The respondents are Hon Richard Prebble MP and Hon Ken Shirley MP who at the relevant times were respectively the parliamentary leader and the acting parliamentary leader of the ACT party.  The effect of their actions was to put in train a statutory process which, if it is carried through to completion, would result in the termination of the appellant’s membership of the House of Representatives.  The process is prescribed by ss55A to 55E of the Electoral Act 1993, which were enacted in the Electoral (Integrity) Amendment Act 2001. 

[2]       For two reasons this appeal raises questions of constitutional importance.  First, although it was accepted by their counsel in this Court that the actions of the respondents are justiciable, the matters in issue do touch on the functioning of Parliament. The Court itself must be satisfied that their nature is not such that the Court should refuse to address them because of parliamentary privilege, and in particular the traditional respect of the courts for the need for the legislative assembly to be able to regulate its internal processes without impediment.  Secondly, the appellant is claiming a right to continue to act as an elected member of the House of Representatives, a claim that raises issues that concern both her rights as an elected member of the legislative assembly and those of the electorate to be represented by her in a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Huata v Prebble and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NZCA 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Huata v Prebble involved an appeal by Donna Awatere Huata, a Member of Parliament (MP) elected as a list member of the ACT party, against a decision of the High Court dismissing her application for judicial review of actions taken in relation to her seat in the House of Representatives by the parliamentary leader of the ACT party and members of the ACT caucus. The respondents, Hon Richard Prebble MP and Hon Ken Shirley MP, were the parliamentary leader and acting parliamentary leader of the ACT party, respectively. The actions of the respondents initiated a statutory process under sections 55A to 55E of the Electoral Act 1993, which, if completed, would result in the termination of the appellant's membership of the House of Representatives. The appeal raised questions of constitutional importance, touching on the functioning of Parliament and the rights of the appellant as an elected member of the House of Representatives and those of her electorate to be represented in a representative democracy. The primary legal issue in the appeal was whether the actions of the respondents were protected by parliamentary privilege and, if not, whether the parliamentary leader's belief that the appellant had distorted the proportionality of the ACT party's representation in Parliament was reasonable. The Court held that the actions of the respondents were not protected by parliamentary privilege, as the statutory regime established by the 2001 amendment to the Electoral Act was intended to be reviewable by the courts. The Court also found that the parliamentary leader's belief that the appellant had distorted the proportionality of the ACT party's representation in Parliament was reasonable, as the appellant's conduct, including lying, defending lying, and failing to maintain her party membership, had cumulatively amounted to her constructive departure from the parliamentary party. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, upholding the decision of the High Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.