Hu v Immigration and Protection Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2016-404-528 [2017] NZHC 41

BETWEEN

JINGQING HU

First Applicant

GUIFENG LI Second Applicant

XINGZHI HU Third Applicant

XINZHI FAITH HU Fourth Applicant

SHUNZHI TIMOTHY HU Fifth Applicant

AND

IMMIGRATION AND PROTECTION TRIBUNAL

First Respondent

MINISTER OF IMMIGRATION Second Respondent

Hearing: 10 October 2016

Appearances:

R P Singh and H T Choudhury for Applicants
M J Hodge and M J Mortimer for Respondents

Judgment:

27 January 2017

JUDGMENT OF PALMER J

This judgment is delivered by me on 27 January 2017 at 10.00 am pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

..................................................... Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Legal Associates, Auckland

Meredith Connell, Auckland

HU v IMMIGRATION AND PROTECTION TRIBUNAL [2017] NZHC 41 [27 January 2017]

Summary

[1]      Mr Jingquing Hu and Ms Guifeng Li face deportation to China.  They have four children, three of whom are Chinese citizens and one who is a New Zealand citizen.   The Immigration and Protection Tribunal decided that deportation of the eldest  child  to  China,  in  her  last  year  of  secondary  school  in  New  Zealand, constituted an exceptional circumstance of a humanitarian nature that would make it unjust  and  unduly harsh  for  her  and  her  family to  be  deported.    The Tribunal considered this justified a temporary visa to allow the oldest child to complete her secondary education but did not justify further relief from deportation after that. Heath  J  granted  leave  to  Mr  Hu,  Ms  Li  and  their  Chinese  citizen  children  to challenge the decision on the ground it is unreasonable because of elements of inconsistency in the reasons given.

[2]      The law of judicial review is bedevilled by whether and how “unreasonable” public decisions are allowed to be.   I consider the Supreme Court’s established reformulation of the Edwards v Bairstow test of when a finding of fact constitutes an error of law offers a better account of unreasonableness in judicial review than the tautologous words used in Wednesbury.   Where a decision is so insupportable or untenable that proper application of the law requires a different answer, it is unlawful because it is unreasonable.   That may involve the adequacy of the evidential foundation of a decision or the chain of logical reasoning in the application of the law to the facts.  Unremarkably, unreasonableness, also termed irrationality, is to be found in the reasoning supporting a public decision.

[3]      But, whatever test of unreasonableness is used, the Tribunal’s conclusion here is supported by evidence and there is no defect in the chain of logical reasoning from the Tribunal’s factual findings or legal propositions to its conclusion.  I decline the application.

Mr Hu, Ms Li and their children

[4]      Mr  Hu  and  Ms  Li  are  citizens  of  the  People’s  Republic  of  China  from Guangzhou who married there in 1997.  Mr Hu’s parents and five siblings, and Ms Li’s mother and three siblings, still live in China.   Their eldest child was born in

China in November 1998.  Mr Hu was a general manager of a department store…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hu v Immigration and Protection Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Hu v Immigration and Protection Tribunal, Mr Jingqing Hu and Ms Guifeng Li, citizens of China, sought judicial review of a decision by the Immigration and Protection Tribunal (Tribunal) to grant them and their children temporary visas to remain in New Zealand. The Tribunal had concluded that it was unjust and unduly harsh for the family to be deported while their eldest daughter completed her secondary education in New Zealand, but that this did not justify further relief from deportation after that. The applicants argued the Tribunal's decision was unreasonable because of elements of inconsistency in its reasons. Palmer J dismissed the application for judicial review. The Court considered the established reformulation of the Edwards v Bairstow test of when a finding of fact constitutes an error of law offers a better account of unreasonableness in judicial review than the tautologous words used in Wednesbury. Where a decision is so insupportable or untenable that proper application of the law requires a different answer, it is unlawful because it is unreasonable. The Court concluded the Tribunal's conclusion was supported by evidence and there was no defect in the chain of logical reasoning from the Tribunal's factual findings or legal propositions to its conclusion. The Tribunal had found the family's deportation would be unjust and unduly harsh while their eldest daughter completed her secondary education in New Zealand, but that this did not justify further relief from deportation after that. The Court did not consider the Tribunal's decision to be unreasonable.