Hotene (aka Manukonga) v Police

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NEW PLYMOUTH REGISTRY

CRI 2012-443-027 [2012] NZHC 1977

BETWEEN  TINA MAREE HOTENE (AKA MANUKONGA)

Appellant

ANDNEW ZEALAND POLICE Respondent

Hearing:         7 August 2012

Counsel:         A Dallison for appellant

S A Law for respondent

Judgment:      7 August 2012

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[1]      The   appellant   (Ms Hotene)   was   sentenced   in   the   District   Court   at New Plymouth on 8 June 2012 in respect of one charge of driving with excess breath alcohol, being a third or subsequent charge.   She was sentenced to 12 months’ imprisonment with special release conditions to apply for six months from the expiry of her sentence.  Ms Hotene now appeals against that sentence as being manifestly excessive.  She also appeals the Judge’s refusal to transform her sentence into one of home detention.

[2]      On the night of the offending, Ms Hotene had driven a car, on her account a very short distance, before incurring the ire of another person when she ran over a container of wine on or adjacent to the roadway.  A man with an apparent interest in the wine attacked the vehicle Ms Hotene was driving and damaged it, including breaking the windscreen.  Ms Hotene telephoned the Police who attended and, in the course  of  their  inquiries,  breath  tested  Ms Hotene.    She  returned  a  reading  of

841 micrograms of alcohol per litre of breath, was entirely co-operative with the

Police and agreed that she had been driving the vehicle.

HOTENE v NEW ZEALAND POLICE HC NWP CRI 2012-443-027 [7 August 2012]

[3]      The District Court Judge cited Ms Hotene’s seven previous convictions for driving with  excess  breath  alcohol  which  were  entered  between  May 1992  and March 2004.  On the last occasion, she was imprisoned for nine months.  In addition, the Judge noted numerous breaches of periodic detention or community work sentences, together with convictions for driving whilst disqualified, which the Judge treated as showing an inability on her part to restrain herself from conduct that was prohibited  to  her.    The  Judge  also  noted  Ms Hotene’s  long-term  alcohol  abuse, treating her as not realistically able to abide by an electronically monitored sentence that would require self-restraint in complying with a ban on the intake of alcohol. Ms Hotene was five months’ pregnant at the time and the Judge expressed concerns for her unborn child, given her levels of alcohol consumption.

[4]      The Judge considered prospects of rehabilitation to have been exhausted, given  Ms Hotene’s  unsuccessful  participation  in  a  detox  programme,  residential rehabilitation and individual counselling.    The Judge effectively treated imprisonment as necessary to enforce abstinence so as to ensure that the unborn child was not subject to the detrimental effects of her on-going alcohol consumption.

[5]      The  Judge  had  regard  to  a  sentence  of  nine  months’ imprisonment  for Ms Hotene’s last conviction for excess breath alcohol, and in light of that fixed the starting point for this conviction at 10 months’ imprisonment, uplifting it by six months to reflect prior convictions.  That was then reduced for an early…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hotene (aka Manukonga) v Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 1977
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tina Maree Hotene (Ms Hotene) appeals against the 12-month imprisonment sentence imposed by the District Court at New Plymouth for driving with excess breath alcohol, her third or subsequent charge. She also contests the Judge’s refusal to transform her sentence into one of home detention. Ms Hotene contends that the sentence is manifestly excessive and that the Judge failed to adequately consider the relative severity of a sentence of imprisonment on a pregnant woman. Ms Hotene’s counsel submits that the Judge’s concern for the unborn child unduly influenced the sentence, and that the cumulative impact of several components of the Judge’s reasoning resulted in errors that rendered the outcome manifestly excessive. Ms Hotene’s counsel argued that the Judge should not have rejected home detention as a viable alternative, considering Ms Hotene’s support from her six-year-old son’s father and Child, Youth and Family Services.

The Court considered Ms Hotene’s previous convictions, her inability to abstain from alcohol, and the need for deterrence. The Judge started with a 10-month imprisonment sentence, uplifted by six months due to Ms Hotene’s “appalling history,” and then allowed four months’ credit for an early guilty plea, resulting in a 12-month sentence. The Court found that the Judge’s approach was not necessarily warranted, as the relative severity of the overall circumstances of each conviction needed to be taken into account. The Court also found that the Judge did not adequately consider the relative severity of a sentence of imprisonment on a pregnant woman, as Ms Hotene’s pregnancy is a factor to consider together with the predicament of the unborn child.

The Court determined that the end point of 12 months’ imprisonment was manifestly excessive, and an eight-month imprisonment sentence is the appropriate outcome. The Court found that Ms Hotene’s counsel failed to demonstrate that the Judge applied an incorrect principle, gave insufficient or excessive weight to a particular factor, or was plainly wrong in rejecting home detention as an appropriate sentence. Therefore, the appeal is allowed to the extent of substituting a reduced sentence of eight months’ imprisonment, while the Judge’s special release conditions and period of disqualification remain unchanged.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.