Hotchin v The Financial Markets Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA832/2011
[2012] NZCA 155

BETWEEN  MARK STEPHEN HOTCHIN
Appellant

AND  THE FINANCIAL MARKETS AUTHORITY
Respondent

Hearing:         13 March 2012

Court:             Randerson, Harrison and Wild JJ

Counsel:         R B Stewart QC, N S Gedye and J A MacGillivray for Appellant
K P McDonald QC and G H Allan for Respondent

Judgment:      20 April 2012 at 10.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant is to pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and the usual disbursements.

COrder under r 7(3) of the Court of Appeal (Access to Court Documents) Rules 2009 that the appeal file (except for the notice of appeal and any amended grounds of appeal) not be accessed without the leave of a Judge.  No restriction on access to the formal Court record as defined by the Rules.  There is no restriction on the publication of this judgment.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Wild J)

Introduction

  1. Mr Hotchin appeals against a judgment of Winkelmann J given in the Auckland High Court on 1 December 2011, following a hearing on 26 September.[1]  The Judge declined Mr Hotchin’s application to rescind interim asset preservation orders the Judge had made on 6 May 2011.[2]  Those orders renewed, in amended terms, orders Winkelmann J had originally made in December 2010.[3] 

    [1]Financial Markets Authority v Hotchin HC Auckland CIV-2010-404-8082, 1 December 2011.

    [3]      Securities Commission v Hotchin HC Auckland CIV-2010-404-8082, 21 December 2010.

  2. The original orders were made on the application of the Securities Commission (the Commission), the predecessor of the Financial Markets Authority (the FMA).  Those orders had the purpose of ensuring that the rights of “aggrieved persons”, as defined in s 60G(3) of the Securities Act 1978, were not frustrated by Mr Hotchin dissipating the assets, leaving them unavailable to meet claims against Mr Hotchin by the aggrieved persons.

  3. The nub of the appeal is that the Judge was wrong not to rescind the orders, and to accept undertakings from Mr Hotchin in their place.

Background

  1. The FMA has been investigating suspected breaches of the Securities Act by Mr Hotchin, in his capacity as a director of companies in the Hanover Finance Group (Hanover).  Hanover failed in mid 2008 causing substantial losses to depositors.

  2. Following Hanover’s collapse, the Commission began investigating potential breaches of the Securities Act by the directors of Hanover in respect of statements made in prospectuses Hanover had issued late in 2007 and in the early part of 2008.  Approximately $32 million had been deposited with Hanover during this period.

  3. On 10 December 2010 Winkelmann J granted an ex parte application by the Commission for interim orders under s 60I of the Securities Act.  The orders were against Mr Hotchin, two corporate trustees of trusts the Commission claimed held assets in which Mr Hotchin had a beneficial interest, and also against Mr Thomas, the sole director…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hotchin v The Financial Markets Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZCA 155
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal brought by Mark Stephen Hotchin against the Financial Markets Authority (FMA). The central issue was whether the High Court judge had erred in maintaining interim asset preservation orders against Mr Hotchin, and in declining to replace them with his undertakings. The Court found that the judge had not erred in her decision. The preservation orders, which were initially made to prevent Mr Hotchin from dissipating his assets, remained necessary because they covered all of his assets, both existing and future. The undertakings offered by Mr Hotchin did not cover all assets and did not address his significant liabilities. Additionally, the Court found that the preservation orders provided stronger sanctions and more effective supervision compared to the proposed undertakings. The Court also noted that any stigma arising from the preservation orders would be present regardless, due to the substantive proceeding the FMA planned to bring against Mr Hotchin. The appeal was dismissed, and Mr Hotchin was ordered to pay the respondent's costs for the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) had been investigating suspected breaches of the Securities Act by Mark Stephen Hotchin, in his capacity as a director of companies in the Hanover Finance Group. Hanover's collapse resulted in substantial losses to depositors. Following the collapse, the Securities Commission (predecessor of the FMA) began investigating potential breaches by Hanover directors regarding statements made in prospectuses issued in late 2007 and early 2008. Approximately $32 million was deposited with Hanover during this period. On 10 December 2010, Winkelmann J granted interim asset preservation orders against Hotchin, two corporate trustees of trusts, and Thomas, the sole director and shareholder of those trustees. These orders prohibited Hotchin and the trustees from dealing with specified assets to prevent dissipation. The orders were varied and amended on several occasions, including on 6 May 2011, to specify certain assets and facilitate payment of debts by Hotchin. Hotchin appealed against the High Court's refusal to rescind the interim asset preservation orders and replace them with undertakings.

The case originated in the Auckland High Court where Hotchin's appeal against the interim asset preservation orders was dismissed on 1 December 2011. Hotchin appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeal was heard on 13 March 2012 by Randerson, Harrison, and Wild JJ. Hotchin was represented by R B Stewart QC, N S Gedye, and J A MacGillivray, while the FMA was represented by K P McDonald QC and G H Allan. The Court of Appeal delivered its judgment on 20 April 2012, dismissing the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. In light of Hotchin’s asset position, did the Judge err in holding that it was necessary to continue the preservation orders?
2. Did the Judge err in holding that the undertakings would not provide satisfactory protection?
3. Did the Judge err in her assessment of the effect of the orders on Hotchin’s ability to earn a living?
4. Did the Judge err in finding that the possibility of future assets or income justified continuation of the orders?

Held
1. The Court held that the Judge did not err in holding that it was necessary to continue the preservation orders in light of Hotchin’s asset position.
2. The Court held that the Judge did not err in holding that the undertakings would not provide satisfactory protection.
3. The Court held that the Judge did not err in her assessment of the effect of the orders on Hotchin’s ability to earn a living.
4. The Court held that the Judge did not err in finding that the possibility of future assets or income justified continuation of the orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal brought by Mark Stephen Hotchin against the decision of the High Court to maintain the interim asset preservation orders against him. The Court of Appeal found no error in the High Court’s decision to maintain the orders, which were intended to prevent Hotchin from dissipating his assets, which could potentially be used to satisfy claims by aggrieved persons. The Court of Appeal found that the orders were necessary because they covered all of Hotchin’s assets, existing and future, and whether or not they had been disclosed by him. The undertakings offered by Hotchin to the High Court did not cover all of his assets, nor did they cover assets that he might acquire in the future. The Court of Appeal also found that the Judge did not err in holding that the undertakings would not provide satisfactory protection. The Court of Appeal found that the sanctions for breach of the preservation orders were considerably more powerful than would be available in the event of a breach of a personal undertaking. The Court of Appeal also found that the Judge did not err in her assessment of the effect of the orders on Hotchin’s ability to earn a living. The Court of Appeal found that the Judge was correct in her assessment that it was difficult to see how the substitution of undertakings in terms identical to the existing orders would improve Hotchin’s situation. Finally, the Court of Appeal found that the Judge did not err in finding that the possibility of future assets or income justified continuation of the orders. The Court of Appeal found that the orders caught any assets that came into Hotchin’s control in the future, whether they derived from his own efforts or from distributions from family controlled entities. The Court of Appeal found that there was no evidence before the High Court of any specific future assets or income which Hotchin expected or was entitled to receive or acquire. However, the Court of Appeal found that the orders were clearly enough expressed to extend to income and other assets of Hotchin which were situated in New Zealand, whether acquired before or after the making of the orders.