IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA131/2009
[2009] NZCA 576BETWEENSHARON ROBYN HORNBY
Appellant
ANDTHE ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION
Respondent
Hearing:16 September 2009
Court:O'Regan, Arnold and Ellen France JJ
Counsel:A C Beck for Appellant
B A Corkill QC and M M Ahern for Respondent
Judgment:9 December 2009 at 2.30 pm
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe appeal is dismissed.
BWe answer the first of the questions on which leave was granted in the negative. No answer is necessary on the second question.
CNo order as to costs.
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Ellen France J)
Table of Contents
Para No.
Introduction [1]
Factual background [4]
The statutory definition [23]
The District Court decision [24]
The decision in the High Court [28]
Arguments on appeal [32]
Discussion [34]
Costs [40]Introduction
[1] On 10 March 2000 the appellant broke her left arm while getting out of a car. Her recovery did not proceed well. That was because the fracture did not heal well meaning further surgery was required. She also suffered pain from a pinched nerve in the area of the break. The appellant received accident compensation cover in relation to her physical injuries. In January 2004, she sought cover for mental injury arising from the break. Her claim was declined on the basis that her mental injury was not because of the physical injuries.
[2] Both the appellant’s review and her appeal to the District Court against the decision declining cover were unsuccessful. She obtained leave to appeal to the High Court but, in a decision delivered on 10 September 2008, Dobson J dismissed the appeal: HC WN CIV 2008-485-763. Dobson J having refused leave to appeal, this Court granted leave to appeal on two questions ((2009) 19 PRNZ 236):
(a)Did the High Court adopt the wrong test to determine whether mental injuries are suffered “because of physical injuries” pursuant to s 26 of the Injury Prevention, Rehabilitation, and Compensation Act 2001 (the Act)? and
(b)If so, on the correct test, is the appellant entitled to cover?
[3] The issue raised by these questions relates to the impact of the appellant’s pre-existing mental condition (anxiety and depression) on her entitlement to cover for mental injury.
Factual background
[4] As we have indicated, the appellant continued to suffer from pain in her left arm and elbow after the break. Between 2000 and 2003, she was seen by a number of specialists and her general practitioner, Dr Don Mackenzie.
[5] In 2002, the appellant underwent a comprehensive pain assessment at the community rehabilitation centre. An extensive report was provided following this assessment on 24 May 2002. The report included a psychological assessment which disclosed a history of depression and panic attacks prior to the accident in March 2000. We interpolate here that the material before the Court indicates that the appellant was seen by various psychological services over the period from May 1993 to March 1998. She had undergone counselling and had been prescribed medication for her difficulties. It appears that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hornby v Accident Compensation Corporation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NZCA 576
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the High Court applied the appropriate legal test, requiring a "degree of connection" showing the mental injury resulted from the physical injury. The court rejected Hornby's argument that the common law "but for" test should apply, stating that the statutory language required a direct and substantial link between the injury and mental health issues. The court concluded that Hornby's depression predated the physical injury and was not caused by it, even if the physical injury exacerbated her symptoms. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed, and no order for costs was made.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.