Hobbs v Gilbert HC Nelson CIV 1999 442 2

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CIV 1999 442 002

BETWEEN  DAVID JOHN HOBBS

Plaintiff

AND  MICHAEL JOHN GILBERT

Defendant

Hearing:         20 April 2005

Further submissions: 27 April 2005

Appearances: J O Upton QC for the Defendant in support

P J Bellamy and M Scally for the Plaintiff to oppose A J D Bamford for Mr J M Fitchett, also to oppose

Judgment:      12 May 2005


JUDGMENT OF WILD J AS TO COSTS


The application

[1]                  By amended application filed on 18 February, the defendant, Mr Gilbert, seeks the following costs orders:

a)Indemnity costs (or if such cannot be had, then increased costs) jointly and severally against the plaintiff and Mr J M Fitchett.

b)The costs of his amended application.

Mr Fitchett was counsel for the plaintiff, Mr Hobbs, in this proceeding at all material times.

HOBBS V GILBERT HC NEL CIV 1999 442 002 [12 May 2005]

[2]The application, as directed against Mr Hobbs, is upon the grounds:

a)Of the complexity and significance of the proceeding to Mr Gilbert (r47(b)).

b)That Mr Hobbs acted improperly or unnecessarily in commencing and continuing the proceeding (r48C(4)(a)).

c)Mr Hobbs failed without reasonable justification to accept a settlement offer made by Mr Gilbert (r 48C(3)(v)).

d)Mr Hobbs attacked Mr Gilbert’s reputation without good cause.

e)Mr Hobbs unduly and without good cause extended the length of the hearing, including the various steps taken by Mr Hobbs subsequent to the hearing.

f)Mr Hobbs alleged perjury on Mr Gilbert’s part without good cause and in ways never specified.

[3]                  The application against Mr Fitchett was based on grounds d), e) and f) above, and upon the additional ground that Mr Fitchett bankrolled or carried Mr Hobbs’ case in circumstances where he had denied on oath that he had done so.

[4]The applications invoke rr 47 and 48C and the Court’s inherent jurisdiction.

The background

[5]                  I gave a judgment on 21 September 2004 deciding three questions which Master Venning had, on 19 October 2000, ordered be determined before trial. In the entitulement to, and in paragraphs [3] to [5] of, my judgment, I set out the unfortunate procedural history of this proceeding. Although it is relevant to this application, I need not repeat that history here.

[6]                  My judgment also, of course, detailed what this proceeding was all about. Again, I need not repeat all that detail here. Very briefly, in this proceeding, Mr Hobbs sought to set aside, on the grounds of duress, a settlement agreement he had entered into with Mr Gilbert in Brisbane, Australia on 4 February 1999. One of the terms of that agreement required Mr Hobbs to discontinue a proceeding which he had brought against Mr Gilbert in this Court. The duress alleged by Mr Hobbs was a threat to him of physical violence if he did not settle, which Mr Hobbs claimed had been made to him by a Mr Finlayson, in the presence and hearing of Mr Gilbert and his wife, Mrs Gilbert, shortly before the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hobbs v Gilbert HC Nelson CIV 1999 442 2 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NZHC 1706
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a costs application brought by the defendant, Michael John Gilbert, against the plaintiff, David John Hobbs, and Hobbs' solicitor, Mr J M Fitchett. The application was heard before Wild J in the High Court of New Zealand, Nelson Registry. Gilbert seeks indemnity or increased costs against Hobbs, and indemnity costs against Fitchett, on several grounds including the complexity and significance of the proceeding, Hobbs' conduct in commencing and continuing the proceeding, and Hobbs' attack on Gilbert's reputation. Hobbs and Fitchett oppose the application. After considering the submissions and evidence, Wild J dismisses Gilbert's application against Fitchett, finding that Fitchett acted within the permissible limits in challenging Gilbert's credibility. However, Wild J grants Gilbert's application against Hobbs, ordering Hobbs to pay 85% of Gilbert's costs, amounting to $149,670, as the proceeding never had a realistic prospect of success and Hobbs should bear the costs consequences of that failure. Gilbert's application for Fitchett to personally pay his costs is dismissed, with Gilbert ordered to pay Fitchett's costs on a 2B basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.