Hillary v Todd & ors (McAlister, Todd Phillips Bodkins) and another

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA36/2008
[2008] NZCA 103

BETWEENGAVIN JOHN HILLARY


Applicant

ANDTODD & ORS (MACALISTER, TODD, PHILLIPS BODKINS)


First Respondent

ANDDUNCAN & ORS (CORBAN REVELL)


Second Respondent

Hearing:21 April 2008

Court:Glazebrook, O'Regan and Ellen France JJ

Counsel:G J Hillary in person


M E Parker for First Respondent
M A Gilbert for Second Respondent

Judgment:29 April 2008 at 12.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application for special leave to appeal out of time is dismissed.

BThe applicant must pay costs of $750 plus usual disbursements to each respondent.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by O’Regan J)

Introduction

[1]       Mr Hillary wishes to appeal against a judgment of Venning J in the High Court, Todd v Hillary HC AK CIV 2005-412-000294 15 June 2007.  In that decision, Venning J upheld a claim against Mr Hillary by Macalister Todd for unpaid legal fees, and dismissed Mr Hillary’s counterclaim against Macalister Todd and his claim against Corban Revell. 

[2]       Macalister Todd had acted for Mr Hillary on some aspects of Mr Hillary’s dispute with his former wife over relationship property, and Corban Revell had acted for his former wife.  Mr Hillary claimed damages from both firms for losses he said he had incurred in the course of the execution of a Family Court judgment.  Venning J found that Macalister Todd owed a duty of care to Mr Hillary but had not breached it, and that Corban Revell owed no duty of care to Mr Hillary.  Mr Hillary acted for himself in the High Court, as he has in this Court.

Late filing

[3]       Mr Hillary needed to file his appeal within 20 working days of the High Court judgment (that is, by 13 July 2007): r 29(1) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005 (the Civil Rules), and he also needed to serve a copy of the notice of appeal on Macalister Todd and Corban Revell.  He did neither. 

[4]       Mr Hillary’s account of what occurred is as follows.  He was told on 11 July 2007 that a lawyer he had engaged would not act for him.  He sent a notice of appeal to the Court on 12 July 2007, but had omitted to sign it.  This notice was sent by post from Queenstown.  He emailed the Court of Appeal registry on 13 July 2007 advising that the notice had been sent and requesting confirming of its arrival.  The Court of Appeal registry emailed a response to the effect that the appeal would arrive out of time and that an application for leave to appeal out of time should be filed.  The notice of appeal was received by the Court of Appeal registry on 17 July 2007, two working days after the expiry of the period during which the notice of appeal had to be filed and served.  Mr Hillary had sent the notice of appeal to the Ministry of Justice’s post office box, rather than to the Court of Appeal’s post office box.  He said…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hillary v Todd & ors (McAlister, Todd Phillips Bodkins) and... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZCA 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Gavin John Hillary sought special leave to appeal out of time from the Court of Appeal of New Zealand against a judgment of Venning J in the High Court. The appeal was against a decision which upheld a claim against Mr Hillary by Macalister Todd for unpaid legal fees and dismissed his counterclaim against Macalister Todd and his claim against Corban Revell. Macalister Todd had acted for Mr Hillary on some aspects of Mr Hillary's dispute with his former wife over relationship property, and Corban Revell had acted for his former wife. Mr Hillary claimed damages from both firms for losses he said he had incurred in the course of the execution of a Family Court judgment. Venning J found that Macalister Todd owed a duty of care to Mr Hillary but had not breached it, and that Corban Revell owed no duty of care to Mr Hillary.

The court considered whether Mr Hillary's late filing of his appeal was sufficiently explained, and whether the appeal had merit. Mr Hillary's appeal was filed two days after the deadline, and he did not promptly seek special leave to appeal out of time. The delay of six months in seeking special leave was not sufficiently explained, and the court noted that the late filing of an appeal converts the position of an appellant from that of exercising a right to appeal to that of seeking an indulgence from the court. The court was unable to form a view about the merits of the appeal, but had considerable doubts about the strength of the grounds of the proposed appeal based on the information currently before it. However, the court believed it was inappropriate to grant leave in the present case, in view of the six-month delay in seeking special leave, with no adequate explanation.

The court dismissed the application for special leave to appeal out of time and awarded costs of $750, plus usual disbursements, to each respondent.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Hillary had engaged legal representation in a dispute with his former wife over relationship property, which included issues related to the execution of a Family Court judgment. Macalister Todd acted for Mr Hillary, while Corban Revell acted for his former wife. Mr Hillary subsequently claimed damages against both firms for losses he alleged he incurred. Venning J in the High Court ruled in favour of Macalister Todd on the unpaid legal fees claim and dismissed Mr Hillary's counterclaim against Macalister Todd and his claim against Corban Revell. Mr Hillary needed to file his appeal within 20 working days of the High Court judgment, which was by 13 July 2007. However, he did not file the notice of appeal and serve it on the respondents within the specified timeframe. Mr Hillary's initial notice of appeal, sent on 12 July 2007, was unsigned, and he mistakenly sent it to the Ministry of Justice's post office box instead of the Court of Appeal's. He sent a signed notice of appeal on 13 July 2007, which was also received two working days late. Mr Hillary did not serve the notice of appeal on the respondents in accordance with the Civil Rules, and both firms proceeded on the assumption that no appeal was being pursued.

Mr Hillary sought special leave to appeal out of time after his notice of appeal was rejected by the Court of Appeal due to the late filing. The Court of Appeal registry had informed him in August 2007 of the need to file an application for special leave to appeal out of time, but he did not act on this notification until January 2008. During this period, he did not contact counsel for the respondents, and they were unaware of the application until they were contacted by the Court. The Court of Appeal heard the application for special leave to appeal out of time on 21 April 2008.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether special leave should be granted to allow Mr Hillary to appeal out of time against the High Court judgment.
2. If special leave is granted, whether the appeal has sufficient merit to warrant consideration.
3. What costs, if any, should be awarded to the respondents.

Held
1. The court dismissed the application for special leave to appeal out of time, concluding that the significant delay in seeking special leave was not adequately explained.
2. The court found that the appeal did not have sufficient merit to warrant consideration, even though it was not considered hopeless.
3. The court awarded costs of $750, plus usual disbursements, to each of the respondents.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal in New Zealand reviewed Mr Hillary's application for special leave to appeal out of time against a High Court judgment. Mr Hillary sought to appeal the judgment upholding a claim for unpaid legal fees and dismissing his counterclaims, but his initial notice of appeal was filed two days late, and he did not serve a copy on the respondents as required. The Court of Appeal registry informed Mr Hillary that his notice of appeal was out of time and advised him to apply for special leave. Despite this, Mr Hillary waited six months before filing his application for special leave, during which time the respondents proceeded on the assumption that no appeal was forthcoming. The court noted that while an oversight by counsel could warrant granting special leave, the significant delay in Mr Hillary's application without adequate explanation made it inappropriate to grant leave. The court also found that the proposed appeal did not have sufficient merit based on the information currently before it. Finally, the court awarded costs to each of the respondents, concluding that Mr Hillary's delay and lack of adequate explanation for it warranted this outcome. The court's reasoning highlighted the importance of timely compliance with procedural requirements and the need for applicants to provide satisfactory explanations for delays in seeking special leave. The ratio decidendi of this decision reinforces the principle that substantial delays in seeking special leave to appeal out of time without adequate justification will generally not be condoned by the court.