Hibernian Catholic Benefit Society v Hagai

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2013-485-8328 [2014] NZHC 24

BETWEEN  THE HIBERNIAN CATHOLIC BENEFIT SOCIETY

Plaintiff

ANDSUSAN TERRI HAGAI Defendant

Hearing:                   9 December 2013

Appearances:           J R Sumner for Plaintiff

Judgment:                30 January 2014

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BELL

This judgment was delivered by me on   30 January 2014 at 10:00 am

pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

...................................

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Ford Sumner, Wellington, for Plaintiff

THE HIBERNIAN CATHOLIC BENEFIT SOCIETY v HAGAI [2014] NZHC 24 [30 January 2014]

[1]      The Hibernian Catholic Benefit Society sues Susan Hagai for $574,000 that she stole while she worked for the society between May 2007 and June 2010 as an administration  and  accounting  officer.     Its  case  is  that  in  the  course  of  her employment she used her knowledge and control of the accounting systems and funds of the society to divert funds into bank accounts of her husband and herself. Mrs Hagai admitted the thefts, was prosecuted and on conviction was sent to prison. The sentencing court did not order reparation.  The society seeks compensation in this proceeding.  It has applied for summary judgment.  Mrs Hagai has not opposed.

[2]      When the application was called on 9 December 2013 I queried whether the proceeding was within the jurisdiction of this court because of the exclusive jurisdiction provisions of the Employment Relations Act 2000.  The society has filed submissions.   I held in Aztec Packaging Ltd v Malevris that a claim for monetary relief for employee embezzlement was within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Employment Relations Authority.1   The society relies on later decisions, PropertyIQ NZ Ltd v Vicelich and RPD Produce Holdings Ltd v Miller, to say that the matter is outside the authority’s jurisdiction.2    As it is more on point, I will deal only with RPD Produce Holdings Ltd v Miller.

[3]      The jurisdiction question needs to be answered before the court can address the substantive merits of the society’s claim.3   All the same, if this court does have jurisdiction, in the absence of any opposition from Mrs Hagai I am satisfied that she has no defence to it.  I would enter judgment against her.

Jurisdiction of the Employment Relations Authority

[4]      The High Court has a general jurisdiction to hear civil cases, whether those cases  would  historically have been  heard in  common  law,  chancery,  probate or

1      Aztec Packaging Ltd v Malevris [2012] NZHC 243, (2012) 10 NZELC 79,003.

2      PropertyIQ NZ Ltd v Vicelich [2012] NZHC 2016; RPD Produce Holdings Ltd v Miller [2013] NZHC 705.

3      Advanced Cardiovascular Systems Inc v Universal Specialties Ltd [1997] 1 NZLR 186 (CA).

admiralty courts in England.4    It can hear claims for any amounts.  Its general civil jurisdiction may be reduced under statutes giving exclusive jurisdiction to other courts or tribunals.  One of those tribunals is the Employment Relations Authority.

[5]      The Employment Relations Authority was established under s 156 of the

Employment Relations Act.  Section 157 states the role of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hibernian Catholic Benefit Society v Hagai and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Hibernian Catholic Benefit Society sues Susan Hagai for $574,000 that she stole while she worked for the society between May 2007 and June 2010 as an administration and accounting officer. Hagai admitted the thefts, was prosecuted and on conviction was sent to prison. The sentencing court did not order reparation. The society seeks compensation in this proceeding. It has applied for summary judgment. Hagai has not opposed. The court must first determine whether it has jurisdiction over the claim. Associate Judge Bell queries whether the proceeding is within the jurisdiction of this court because of the exclusive jurisdiction provisions of the Employment Relations Act 2000. The society argues that its claim can be heard in this court because it is founded in equity, namely in Hagai’s breach of fiduciary duty. Equitable claims are excluded under s 161(1)(r) and equity must prevail over the common law. Associate Judge Bell disagrees, finding that the society’s argument that the authority does not have any jurisdiction in equity is curious. He finds that the authority can apply equity in hearing an application to rectify a written employment agreement or to set aside an employment agreement as an unconscionable bargain or for undue influence. Simply because an employment relationship problem raises a question of equity does not take the problem outside the authority’s jurisdiction. For the above reasons, the court finds that it does not have jurisdiction to hear the society’s claim. It dismisses the application for summary judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established