IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND INVERCARGILL REGISTRY
CIV-2009-425-000137 [2013] NZHC 905
BETWEEN HERITAGE HEIGHTS LIMITED Plaintiff
ANDSINCLAIR BROS BUILDING LIMITED First Defendant
ANDG J SINCLAIR Second Defendant
ANDS L SINCLAIR Third Defendant
AND INVERCARGILL ENGINEERING CO.
LIMITED
First Third Party
ANDD T ERSKINE Second Third Party
Hearing: 30 April 2012
Appearances: J G French for Plaintiff, First Third Party and Second Third Party
No appearance for First, Second and Third Defendants
Judgment: 16 April 2013
JUDGMENT OF FOGARTY J
Solicitors:
French Burt Partners, PO Box 358, Invercargill
Copy to:
Ward Adams Bryan-Lamb, PO Box 32, Invercargill
HERITAGE HEIGHTS LIMITED V SINCLAIR BROS BUILDING LIMITED & Ors HC INV CIV-2009-425-
000137 [16 April 2013]
[1] When this case was called there were no appearances by the first, second or third defendants. This did not come as a surprise to the Court. These defendants had previously advised that they would not be participating in this hearing.
[2] The hearing then proceeded by way of formal proof. This dispute arises out of the construction of residential units on a property situated at Anderson Heights in Queenstown. The property was owned by the plaintiff, Heritage Heights Ltd. The shareholders in the plaintiff were Mr Donald Erskine and his sister, Mrs Janice MacLeod, as to 50 per cent and Messrs Graham and Stephen Sinclair as to the other
50 per cent.
[3] Heritage Heights Ltd was a company formed for the purposes of the development. It entered into a contract with the first defendant, Sinclair Bros Building Ltd, for the construction of two rows of residential units. The units were to be built on a steep sloping section. The first defendant was an established “master builder” business in Queenstown and a member of the Master Builders’ Association. The second and third defendants were the two sole directors and equal shareholders in the company.
[4] Mr Erskine and Mrs MacLeod were and are the shareholders in Invercargill Engineering Co Ltd, the first third party, and Mr Erskine is also the managing director of the first third party.
[5] It was agreed between the plaintiff and the first defendant that Mr Graham Sinclair was to be the project manager. An additional amount “at a specified rate per unit” was to be paid over and above the contract price for construction by the plaintiff in respect of project management. Mr Stephen Sinclair was the on-site foreman.
[6] There was no problem with the construction of the first row of units. There was defective work in the construction of the second row. The local Council refused the code compliance certificate in respect of the top row and then, after further investigation, brought prosecutions against the plaintiff and the first, second and third defendants.
[7] The evidence received by the Court detail a considerable number of defects. It is sufficient for the purposes of the formal proof to highlight the most significant. They are:
(a) A significant retaining wall behind the top row was defectively constructed.
(b) The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Heritage Heights Limited v Sinclair Bros Building Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NZHC 905
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court also found that the defendants were personally liable for the defective construction, as they had significant control over the building operations and failed to meet their duties of care. The court held that the directors, Graham and Stephen Sinclair, owed a duty of care to the purchasers of the flats due to their personal involvement in the construction process. The court awarded the plaintiff damages for bank interest, which was deemed foreseeable due to the defendants' knowledge of the project and the potential for delayed sales and ongoing banking accommodation.
In addition to the damages for defective construction, the court found that the defendants were liable for unauthorized drawings from the plaintiff's accounts and unauthorized purchases billed to the plaintiff's credit card. The court awarded the plaintiff damages for these unauthorized expenses, with specific amounts attributed to each defendant.
Finally, the court dismissed the counterclaim and third party proceedings as the defendants did not appear to pursue these claims. The plaintiff and third parties were awarded costs on a 2B basis against the defendants.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.