Heenan v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI-2014-404-000451 [2015] NZHC 56

BETWEEN

MELANIE HEENAN

Appellant

AND

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT Respondent

Hearing: 3 February 2015

Appearances:

S Perese for Appellant
S O'Connor and J Burns for Respondent

Judgment:

3 February 2015

JUDGMENT OF WOOLFORD J

Counsel/Solicitors:

S I Perese, Barrister, PO Box 2407, Shortland Street, Auckland

S O’Connor, Solicitor, Meredith Connell, Auckland

J Burns, Solicitor, Ministry of Social Development, Auckland

MELANIE HEENAN v MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT [2015] NZHC 56 [3 February 2015]

Introduction

[1]      On 12 December 2014, the appellant was sentenced to eight months home detention on social welfare fraud charges.   The charges covered a four and a half year  period  from  1 April  2008  to  17  December  2012.    They  included  five  of dishonestly using a document, three of obtaining by deception and one of using a forged document.  The total amount obtained by the appellant to which she was not entitled was $69,817.14.  She repaid $12,500 prior to sentencing, which included a lump sum payment of $10,500.   The debt at the time of sentencing was therefore

$57,317.14.   No order for reparation was made when she was sentenced to home detention.  She now appeals against sentence on the basis that a lesser sentence of community  detention  should  have  been  imposed  or,  in  the  alternative,  home detention for a lesser period was appropriate.

Approach on appeal

[2]      The appellant appeals against sentence under s 244 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011.   In accordance with s 250(2), the High Court must allow the appeal if satisfied that for any reason there is an error in the sentence imposed on conviction and a different sentence should be imposed.  The Court of Appeal has confirmed that s 250(2) was not intended to change the approach taken to sentence appeals under the now repealed s 385(3) of the Crimes Act 1961 and s 121(3) of the Summary

Proceedings Act 1957.1   The appellant must accordingly demonstrate some error on

the part of the District Court.2    An appeal is also “not generally a second shot at

sentencing”.3

District Court sentencing

[3]      After setting out the charges and the overpayment, Judge Thorburn noted that in memoranda filed for sentencing there was an assertion that during the period of the offending the appellant was in an abusive relationship with her husband of whom

she was “a puppet”.   Judge Thorburn said that this assertion was not advanced at

1      Tutakangahau v R [2014] NZCA 279, [2014] 3 NZLR 482 at [26].

2      R v Shipton [2007] 2 NZLR 218 (CA) at [138].

3      Polyanszky v R [2011] NZCA 4 at [17] – [18] per Chambers J.

sentencing, but was, in any event, not a matter he would put a great deal of weight on.

[4]      The relevance for Judge Thorburn was that the appellant’s husband was also charged with social welfare fraud totalling in  excess of $100,000  for which he received a sentence of eight months home detention after having made a repayment of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Heenan v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Melanie Heenan, the appellant, contested the sentence imposed by the District Court, arguing that it was disproportionately harsher than the sentence given to her husband, who was also convicted of social welfare fraud. The case was heard on February 3, 2015, and the judgment was delivered on the same day. The legal issues included whether the sentence imposed was disproportionate to the appellant's husband's sentence, whether the appellant's reduced culpability due to her abusive relationship with her husband should have been considered, and whether her personal circumstances were inadequately accounted for during sentencing.

The court examined the proportionality of the sentences by comparing the length of time over which the offending took place and the amount of the overpayment. While the appellant's husband was charged over double the period of time and the amount overpaid to him was approximately 50% more than that of the appellant, this did not necessarily indicate disproportionality. The court also noted the appellant's previous history of dishonesty and her previous overpayments, which indicated a knowing dishonesty on her part. Additionally, the court highlighted that the appellant's husband had repaid $20,000 and was ordered to pay reparation, which resulted in a reduced sentence. The court concluded that the appellant's personal circumstances, including her living situation and educational pursuits, were not compelling enough to warrant a different sentence.

The court ultimately dismissed the appeal, finding no error in the approach taken by the District Court judge and no justification for imposing a different sentence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established