Heeg v Heeg HC Nelson CIV-2011-442-000129

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CIV-2011-442-000129

UNDER  the Land Transfer Act 1952 section 145A

IN THE MATTER OF     an Originating Application to Sustain a

Caveat

BETWEEN  ULRIKE GABRIELLE HEEG Plaintiff/Applicant

AND  CHRISTIAN OTTO ALFRED HEEG Defendant/Respondent

Hearing:         26 August 2011 (by telephone) (Heard at Christchurch)

(Heard at Christchurch)

Appearances: P C Maciaszek for Plaintiff

D J Ballantyne for Defendant

Judgment:      29 August 2011

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

as to application for stay of execution

The application

[1]      Ulrike Heeg and Christian Heeg are mother and son.   By judgment in this proceeding dated 19 August 2011, Associate Judge Matthews directed that a caveat registered by Ulrike against a Brightwater property owned by Christian be removed.

[2]      Ulrike makes application for an order staying the enforcement of the 19

August 2011 judgment.

[3]      Immediately following the judgment of 19 August 2011, Ulrike filed the application.     The  first  ground  of  application  was  that  an  appeal  would  be

immediately made to the Court of Appeal against the judgment.   That appeal was

HEEG V HEEG HC NEL CIV-2011-442-000129 29 August 2011

promptly filed ahead of the hearing of this application.  Mr Maciaszek informed me that the Court of Appeal has hearing time available for such an appeal in November.

Ulrike’s substantive claim

[4]      In her caveat, Ulrike claimed:

an estate by way of constructive trust whereby the registered proprietor, Christian Otto Alfred Heeg, holds the property on trust for the caveator pursuant to certain payments made by the caveator in 2001 by way of loan advances for the benefit of the registered proprietor which funds have in whole or in part been applied by the registered proprietor in 2005 for the purchase of the above property following the sale of two earlier properties at Princes Drive, Nelson.

[5]      A more detailed history of the allegations and counter-allegations is contained in the Associate Judge’s judgment of 19 August 2011.  Ulrike’s husband (Christian’s father) died in Germany in 1998.   Ulrike was declared his sole heir but under German  law  both  Christian  and  two  other  children  had  statutory  and  legal entitlements in relation to the estate.  By 2000 Ulrike and Christian were considering permanent residence in New Zealand. Two adjoining Nelson properties were purchased by Ulrike and Christian as joint tenants in 2001.  In 2003 the properties were transferred to Christian alone. Shortly afterwards he sold them both and purchased the Brightwater property over which the caveat was lodged.  The dealings between the parties were added to in the meantime by sales of German properties made by Christian to Ulrike.  In their evidence they disagreed as to whether some of their property dealings involved Christian’s surrendering of claims he had in relation to his father’s estate.

[6]      Associate  Judge  Matthews  reviewed  the  conflicting  evidence  and  found Ulrike’s claim of a constructive trust to be inconsistent with the dealings and some of the records of the parties.   Ulrike was found not to have an arguable case of an interest under a constructive trust stemming…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Heeg v Heeg HC Nelson CIV-2011-442-000129 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1025
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ulrike Heeg applied to stay the execution of a judgment removing a caveat she had lodged against property owned by her son Christian Heeg. The application was dismissed. Ulrike had been refused an order sustaining her caveat in a previous proceeding. The caveat was registered in February 2011. The property is Brightwater. Christian has been unable to sell the property while the caveat is registered. He intends to sell the property to enable him to purchase a new property from which to run his business. He also intends to purchase new machinery for his business. Christian has a mortgage debt and a secured finance debt. He is the principal breadwinner for his family. Ulrike’s appeal against the removal of the caveat might be rendered nugatory if Christian sells the property before the appeal is heard. However, Ulrike has filed a statement of claim in a separate proceeding asserting a constructive trust and a contract of debt. The application for a stay was dismissed. The appeal against the removal of the caveat might be rendered nugatory by the sale of the property but Ulrike’s substantive claim would not be rendered nugatory. The balance of convenience favoured Christian. He would be injured by the lack of a stay. Ulrike’s prospects of success on appeal were not strong. The Court ordered that Ulrike pay costs of the application on a 2B basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established