| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA353/2022 [2022] NZCA 534 |
| BETWEEN | HEBEI HUANENG INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT CO LIMITED |
| AND | DEMING SHI |
| Court: | French and Collins JJ |
Counsel: | K H Morrison and A Manuson for Applicant |
Judgment: | 10 November 2022 at 3 pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe application for leave to appeal is declined.
BThe applicant must pay the respondent costs for a standard application on a band A basis with usual disbursements.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by French J)
Introduction
The applicant wishes to appeal a decision of Associate Judge Sussock declining to grant its summary judgment application to enforce a judgment issued by a court in the People’s Republic of China.[1]
[1]Hebei Huaneng Industrial Development Co Ltd v Shi [2021] NZHC 2687 [High Court judgment].
In order to bring its appeal, the applicant must first obtain leave.[2] Leave to appeal was declined by the Associate Judge[3] and so leave is now sought from this Court under s 56(5) of the Senior Courts Act 2016. Mr Shi the respondent opposes leave being granted.
Background
[2]Senior Courts Act 2016, ss 27 and 56(3).
The applicant is a subsidiary of a state-owned enterprise managed by the central Chinese government. It entered into certain contractual arrangements with a company associated with Mr Shi called Qinhuangdao Boen Trading Co Ltd (Boen China).
Under the contract, the applicant agreed to pay Boen China to source and distribute coal to various electricity providers throughout China. Each electricity provider would then pay the applicant who after retaining an agreed margin paid the balance to Boen China. In order to ensure coal supply, the applicant made an advance payment to Boen China in the sum of RMB 103,426,379.28 (approximately NZD 23 million). It was agreed that in the event the contract between the applicant and Boen China was terminated Boen China would repay the advance.
Mr Shi personally guaranteed Boen China’s obligation to repay the advance as did an entity called Tangshan Seaport Detai New Material Technic Co Ltd (Detai).
In late 2015, the applicant decided not to renew its contract with Boen China and sought repayment of the advance. Boen China failed to pay.
On 3 June 2019 the Shijiazhuang Intermediate People’s Court of Hebei Province found Boen China was liable under the coal contracts to repay the advance as was Detai under its guarantee but not Mr Shi.
This decision in favour of Mr Shi was however subsequently overturned on appeal to the Higher People’s Court of Hebei Province. Mr Shi was held to be liable on the guarantee as well as Detai (Higher People’s Court judgment).
The applicant sought to enforce the Higher People’s Court judgment in China but claimed neither Mr Shi nor Detai had any assets in that country. It then became aware that Mr Shi…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hebei Huaneng Industrial Development Co Limited v Shi and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NZCA 534
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues involved whether the Higher People’s Court judgment met the common law prerequisites for recognition in New Zealand, specifically whether the court was of competent jurisdiction, the judgment was final and conclusive, and it was for a definite sum of money. The Associate Judge found it arguable that the Higher People’s Court lacked independence and impartiality and that under Chinese law, the applicant should have pursued rights against another guarantor before enforcing against Mr Shi.
The Court of Appeal assessed the application for leave to appeal under the principles that a high threshold exists, the applicant must identify an arguable error of law or fact, the alleged error should be of general or public importance, the circumstances must warrant incurring further delay, and the ultimate question is whether the interests of justice are served by granting leave. The applicant identified several alleged errors in the High Court judgment. However, the Court of Appeal concluded that the issues raised were of general or public importance but that a full hearing was required to properly explore the disputed issues of both law and fact. The Court considered the delay and prejudice to Mr Shi if an appeal were allowed, finding that the prejudice to him far outweighed any prejudice to the applicant if leave were declined.
The Court of Appeal declined the application for leave to appeal and ordered that the applicant pay the respondent’s costs for a standard application on a band A basis with usual disbursements.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case began when Hebei Huaneng Industrial Development Co Limited filed proceedings in the High Court of New Zealand seeking recognition of a judgment issued by the Higher People’s Court of Hebei Province in China. The High Court declined the applicant’s summary judgment application to enforce the foreign judgment, finding it was arguable that the Higher People’s Court did not meet the common law prerequisites for recognition. The applicant sought leave to appeal this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The Court of Appeal declined the application for leave to appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Associate Judge erred in applying the common law test for recognition of a foreign judgment by importing a requirement of independence and impartiality.
2. Whether the Associate Judge erred in finding an arguable defence of natural justice when that had not been raised by Mr. Shi.
3. Whether the Associate Judge erred in finding the Higher People’s Court judgment was arguably not final or conclusive.
4. Whether cause of action and/or issue estoppel applied in the context of enforcement of a foreign judgment.
Held
1. The application for leave to appeal is declined.
2. The applicant must pay the respondent costs for a standard application on a band A basis with usual disbursements.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal considered the application for leave to appeal by Hebei Huaneng Industrial Development Co Limited against the decision of the Associate Judge declining to grant summary judgment for the enforcement of a judgment issued by the Higher People's Court of Hebei Province. The Court found that although the appeal raised issues of general or public importance, the interests of justice were best served by declining leave to appeal. The Court emphasised the high threshold for leave to appeal and noted that a full hearing was necessary to fully ventilate and explore the disputed issues of both law and fact. Additionally, the Court highlighted the significant delay and prejudice to the respondent if leave were granted, particularly in relation to the respondent's assets which had been subject to freezing orders since June 2020.
The Court of Appeal examined the Associate Judge's application of the common law test for recognition of a foreign judgment, finding it arguable that the Higher People's Court may have lacked the necessary independence and impartiality required to be considered a foreign court of competent jurisdiction. The Court also noted the arguable defence of natural justice arising from the involvement of judicial committees in the Chinese legal system. The Court of Appeal found that the Associate Judge's conclusion that the Higher People's Court judgment was arguably not final and conclusive was also a matter worthy of further exploration. Finally, the Court considered that the issue of cause of action and/or issue estoppel in the context of enforcement of a foreign judgment was an argument that should be submitted to this Court.
In reaching its decision, the Court of Appeal distinguished the present case from the Supreme Court decision in Minister of Justice v Kim, finding that the concerns about the role of judicial committees in the Chinese legal system did not directly address the common law test of recognition and the question of whether that test requires a foreign court to act judicially. The Court noted the paucity of authority on the specific issue of the common law test for recognition of a foreign judgment in the context of Chinese judgments. The Court also took into account the different view expressed by Associate Judge Bell in the decision regarding the protest to jurisdiction in this case.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Court of Appeal will decline leave to appeal where the issues raised are of general or public importance, but where a full hearing is necessary to fully ventilate and explore the disputed issues of both law and fact, and where the delay and prejudice to the respondent outweigh the prejudice caused to the applicant if leave is declined.