Harvey v Gateshead Investments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-5909 [2014] NZHC 464

BETWEEN            CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL HARVEY First Plaintiff/First Counterclaim Defendant

AND  RACHEL SUSAN HARVEY

Second Plaintiff/ Second Counterclaim Defendant

ANDRICHARD JAMES PARKER Third Plaintiff

ANDGATESHEAD INVESTMENTS LIMITED First Defendant/First Counterclaim Plaintiff

AND  PARANUI PROPERTIES LIMITED

Second Defendant/Second Counterclaim Plaintiff

ANDBETA PACIFIC CORPORATION LIMITED Third Defendant

Hearing:                   On the papers

Counsel:                  J Toebes for Counterclaim Plaintiffs

L A B Kemp for Counterclaim Defendant

Judgment:                13 March 2014

JUDGMENT OF KATZ J (Costs)

This judgment was delivered by me on 13 March 2014 at 3:30 pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:               J Toebes, JT Law, Wellington

L Kemp, Kemp Barristers & Solicitors, Auckland

HARVEY  & ORS v GATESHEAD INVESTMENTS LIMITED & ORS [2014] NZHC 464 [13 March 2014]

Introduction

[1]      The first and second defendants (together “the judgment creditors”) filed a counterclaim  against  the  first  plaintiff  (“the  executor”)  and  the  second  plaintiff (“Mrs Harvey”) that was partially successful.  The executor and Mrs Harvey submit that the judgment creditors should meet their costs of defending the counterclaim. The judgment creditors on the other hand submit that, if anyone is entitled to costs, it is them. They are, however, willing for costs to lie where they fall.

Background

[2]      Mrs Rachel Harvey, the second plaintiff, is a nurse.  She had interests in three rest home businesses and personally guaranteed the debts of those businesses.  She was unable to meet her obligations under the relevant guarantees and was eventually bankrupted.

[3]      With  creditors  demanding  payment,  Mrs  Harvey  and  her  late  husband Mr Michael Harvey attempted to remove their matrimonial home in Coatesville from the reach of Mrs Harvey’s creditors.  They owned the property as joint tenants. They entered into an agreement under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 (“PRA”), pursuant to which Mrs Harvey agreed to transfer her interest in the property to Mr Harvey as his separate property.  In exchange Mr Harvey gave up any interest in the rest home businesses.

[4]      Mr Harvey subsequently died and a dispute arose between the executor of his will   and   Mrs   Harvey’s   creditors   regarding   the   Coatesville   property.   The counterclaim plaintiffs sought orders:

a)  declaring    the    relationship    property    agreement    between    Mr    and

Mrs Harvey to be void;

b)  removing the notice of claim under the PRA from the title to the property;

and

c)  vesting the Coatesville property in Mrs Harvey by survivorship (in which event it would have formed part of her bankrupt estate, for distribution to her creditors).

[5]      The judgment creditors sought summary judgment on their counterclaim. That application was heard by Associate Judge Faire.   His Honour held that the relationship property agreement was entered into with the intention of, and in any case having the effect of, defeating creditors in terms of s 47 of the PRA.1   It was therefore void as against creditors.  His honour accordingly made the orders set out at [4](a) and (b) above.  He found, however, that there were arguable defences to the claim that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harvey v Gateshead Investments Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 464
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand in Auckland heard a case involving multiple parties: Christopher Michael Harvey, Rachel Susan Harvey, Richard James Parker, Gateshead Investments Limited, Paranui Properties Limited, and Beta Pacific Corporation Limited. The first and second defendants, referred to as the judgment creditors, filed a counterclaim against the first plaintiff (the executor of Mr Harvey's estate) and the second plaintiff (Mrs Harvey). The counterclaim aimed to declare a relationship property agreement void, remove a notice of claim from the property title, and vest the Coatesville property in Mrs Harvey by survivorship. The executor and Mrs Harvey argued that the judgment creditors should bear the costs of defending the counterclaim, while the judgment creditors contended that if any party was entitled to costs, it should be them, but they were willing for costs to lie where they fell.

The court had to determine the appropriate allocation of costs given that both parties had achieved some success in the proceedings. The judgment creditors successfully obtained two of the three orders sought in the counterclaim, including a declaration that the relationship property agreement was void and an order removing the notice of claim from the property title. However, they failed to secure the third order, which would have vested the entire Coatesville property in Mrs Harvey by survivorship. The court concluded that both parties had roughly equal success in the proceedings and thus declined to grant an award of costs in favour of either party. Instead, costs were to lie where they fell.

This decision highlights the principle that costs follow the event, meaning the party that fails in a proceeding should pay costs to the party that succeeds. However, in cases where both sides have had some success, the court must endeavour to do justice to both sides by considering various factors, including the outcome of the proceedings and the relative success of each party. In this case, the court found that both the executor and the judgment creditors had achieved meaningful results, leading to the conclusion that costs should lie where they fell.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.