Hartono v Ministry for Primary Industries

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2015-409-500 [2015] NZHC 3307

IN THE MATTER

of an appeal against a decision of the

District Court at Christchurch dated 24

July 2015 relating to section 256(1)(c) of the Fisheries Act 1996

BETWEEN

RUDI HARTONO Appellant

25 OTHER foreign fishing crew seeking relief from the effects of forfeiture as listed in Schedule "A" (attached)

AND

THE MINISTRY FOR PRIMARY INDUSTRIES

Respondent

CIV-2015-409-302

IN THE MATTER             of an appeal against a decision of the

District Court at Christchurch

BETWEEN  SAJO OYANG CORPORATION Appellant

ANDTHE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF THE MINISTRY FOR PRIMARY INDUSTRIES

Respondent

Hearing: 8 September 2015

Appearances:

RB Squire QC and KA van Wijngaarden and MS Sullivan for the Appellant (CIV-2015-409-302) and for the Second Respondent (CIV-2015-409-500)

CJ Lange for the First Respondent (CIV-2015-409-302) and
(CIV-2015-409-500)
KK Harding for the Second to Twentyseventh Respondents
(CIV-2015-409-302) and for the (Cross) Appellants (CIV-2015-
409-500)

Judgment:

18 December 2015

HARTONO v THE MINISTRY FOR PRIMARY INDUSTRIES [2015] NZHC 3307 [18 December 2015]

JUDGMENT OF NICHOLAS DAVIDSON J

Introduction

[1]      This case involves the crews of three foreign owned vessels which were fishing in New Zealand waters.

[2]      The foreign owner is Sajo Oyang Corporation (Sajo), incorporated in the

Republic of Korea. It owned three vessels, the Oyang 70, 75 and 77.

[3]      The 26 crew members involved in the appeal and the second (“cross-appeal”) claim for unpaid wages and other entitlements. The appeal and cross-appeal address the legal pathway for the crew’s claim to wages, and whether that includes relief against vessels now forfeit to the Crown. Their right in admiralty to claim against the ships for wages was lost through sinking of one vessel and forfeiture of two vessels.

[4]      On 18 August 2010, the Oyang 70 sank. Six members of her crew perished. On 3 September 2014, Oyang 77 became forfeit to the Crown after convictions were entered in the Christchurch District Court for offences committed by her Master under the Fisheries Act 1996. On 4 November 2014, the Oyang 75 was also forfeit to the Crown, for offences committed by her Master and four officers.

[5]      The crew members in these proceedings all worked for Sajo, on the Oyang

70  or  the  Oyang  77,  but  none  of  them  had  worked  on  the  Oyang  75. All  are Indonesian  nationals. They allege that  they are owed  substantial  sums  by Sajo, arising  from  wage  and  holiday  pay  entitlements.  The  named  appellant  in  the cross-appeal, a Mr Hartono, was a crew member on the Oyang 70.

[6]      Sajo and others applied to the District Court for relief against forfeiture under s 256 of the Fisheries Act 1996 (the Act), set out at para [44] below.  Crew members

claimed an interest for unpaid wages. There were three primary questions for determination:

(i)Whether   the   claim   for   wages   had   to   be   determined   by   the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) or another and different Court, before the crew could claim or be ordered to have an interest in the forfeit…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hartono v Ministry for Primary Industries and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 3307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved an appeal and cross-appeal by the crew of three vessels, which had been forfeited to the Crown, against a decision of the District Court regarding their claims for unpaid wages. The central issues were whether the District Court could determine the crew members' wage claims and whether the crew could claim relief against forfeited vessels they did not work on. The appeal, brought by Sajo Oyang Corporation, argued that the wage claims had to be determined in separate proceedings before the crew could claim an interest in the forfeit vessels. They also contended that the District Court lacked jurisdiction to determine the wage claims as they exceeded the Court's jurisdictional limit. The cross-appeal, brought by the crew members, sought to establish their entitlement to claim relief against all forfeited vessels, not just those on which they worked.

The Court found that wage claims must be determined before an interest in forfeit property can be established, and wage claims over $200,000 could not be determined by the District Court. However, the Court held that the wage claims could be made in the same proceedings as the application for relief from forfeiture, as long as individual claims did not exceed the jurisdictional limit. The Court also held that the crew members could claim relief against all forfeited vessels, not just those on which they worked, based on a broader interpretation of "forfeit property" to include vessels that would have been liable in rem but for forfeiture. This interpretation was seen as necessary to avoid manifest injustice and to align with the legislative intent behind the 2002 Fisheries Amendment Act, which aimed to protect the rights of foreign crew members. The appeal was allowed in part, and the cross-appeal was allowed in full.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.