Hartnell v New Zealand Meat Producers Board

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA5/05

BETWEENJOHN WILLIAM HARTNELL


Appellant

ANDTHE NEW ZEALAND MEAT PRODUCERS BOARD


Respondent

Hearing:1 December 2005

Court:O'Regan, Robertson and R Hansen JJ

Counsel:R B Squire QC and D J Boldt for Appellant


D J White QC and S B Hill for Respondent

Judgment:14 February 2006 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A         The appeal is dismissed.

BThe respondent is entitled to costs of $6,000 together with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

(Given by Robertson J)

Introduction

[1]        The appellant (Mr Hartnell) mounted a claim in the High Court against the New Zealand Meat Producers Board (the Board) alleging misfeasance in public office and intimidation.  Following a five day hearing in the High Court at Wellington, in a reserved decision of 3 December 2004, Miller J found that Mr Hartnell had failed to establish liability on either of the causes of action pursued at trial.  Judgment was entered for the Board.

[2]        The two issues raised in the points of appeal arise out of r 288 of the High Court Rules.  The first is whether a party should be permitted to lead evidence at trial which is in conflict with a sworn answer to an interrogatory, and secondly, whether, because this did occur, the appellant had a fair trial. 

[3]        In the course of the hearing, Mr Squire QC sought leave to amend the grounds of appeal to include the additional ground that the trial Judge misstated the test of recklessness which he applied in [35] of his judgment when he said:

[35]     It is important to be clear as to what is meant by recklessness.  The tort rests on abuse of power accompanied by subjective bad faith: Three Rivers District Council v Bank of England [2003] 3 All ER 1, 8-9, per Lord Steyn. Recklessness suffices because it connotes a lack of honesty, something less than an honest attempt to perform the duty. An element of bad faith is essential. Misfeasance in public office is an exception to the general rule that if conduct is presumptively unlawful, a good motive will not exonerate the defendant: Borough of Bradford v Pickles [1895] AC 587.

[4]        There had been some reference to this point in submissions and the Court allowed the amendment.  Accordingly, the third issue for determination is whether the above test correctly states the law.  Mr White QC was provided with an opportunity to file additional written submissions on behalf of the Board on the point by 7 December 2005 and Mr Squire QC to respond by 12 December.

Background

[5]        The substantive litigation has a lengthy history which is non-controversially reviewed in the judgment under appeal at [3] to [24].

[6]        The intricate details of the circumstances leading up to the critical point need not be traversed.  Suffice to say that, at the relevant time, the meat industry was self-regulated.  The industry’s approach to export meat marketing was co-ordinated by the Meat Planning Council under an agreement between the Board, the Meat Industry…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hartnell v New Zealand Meat Producers Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NZCA 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal was brought by the appellant, Mr John Hartnell, against the New Zealand Meat Producers Board (the Board) in relation to a claim for misfeasance in public office and intimidation. The appeal arose from a reserved decision in the High Court at Wellington, where the Judge found that Mr Hartnell had failed to establish liability on either of the causes of action pursued at trial. The two issues raised in the points of appeal are firstly, whether a party should be permitted to lead evidence at trial which is in conflict with a sworn answer to an interrogatory, and secondly, whether, because this did occur, the appellant had a fair trial. The third issue for determination is whether the test correctly states the law for the tort of misfeasance in public office.

The Court found that the absolutist position taken by the appellant was unsustainable, as parties to litigation should comply with r 288 in order to correct interrogatories which they subsequently realise have been inaccurately answered. However, a party is not precluded from adducing evidence which is inconsistent with an answer to an interrogatory which has not been corrected. In this case, the Judge must consider and evaluate all available evidence. It will be open to a Judge in the exercise of discretion to refuse to admit evidence which contradicts an answer to an interrogatory, but this would be rare and only where prejudice would be caused to the other party which cannot be alleviated by other means. Costs awards and adjournments are available to respond to possible prejudice in such circumstances. The Court found that the Judge did not err in weighing all the evidence on the question of whether legal advice had been sought. The conclusion he reached was one which was reasonably available to him on the totality of the evidence. The Court found that the second issue, which was closely allied to the first, was the contention that there was unfairness because of the way matters unfolded. The Court concluded that this was not sustainable as no application was made for adjournment and no request was made for the Judge to turn his mind to the position which had developed until the very closing stages of the trial. The Court found that the third issue, relating to the proper definition of recklessness, was unsustainable as the Judge correctly summarised the relevant law. The Court found that there was no evidence of subjective bad faith or dishonesty which would establish reckless indifference.

The appeal was accordingly dismissed. The respondent was entitled to costs of $6,000 together with usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established