Harriman v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA463/2013
[2013] NZCA 674

BETWEEN

ALLEN LOUIS HARRIMAN
Appellant

AND

ATTORNEY-GENERAL
First Respondent

NEW ZEALAND PAROLE BOARD
Second Respondent
Counsel:

Appellant in person
C A Griffin and L M Inverarity for First Respondent
F M R Cooke QC for Second Respondent

Judgment:

(On the papers)

19 December 2013 at 10.30 am

JUDGMENT OF FRENCH J
(Review of Registrar’s Decision
Re Dispensing with Payment of Security for Costs)

The application for review of the Registrar’s decision refusing to dispense with the payment of security for costs is dismissed.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Introduction

  1. Mr Harriman has filed an appeal against a decision of Goddard J.[1]  In the decision, Goddard J dismissed Mr Harriman’s application for judicial review of the actions of the Department of Corrections and the New Zealand Parole Board.

  2. On 30 July 2013 security for costs on the appeal was set at $11,760.

  3. Mr Harriman then applied for security to be dispensed with under r 35(6)(c) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.  The Registrar held that there was nothing in the appeal of public importance or significance and that the circumstances of the appeal could not be considered exceptional.  She accordingly decided it was not an appropriate case for dispensation and advised Mr Harriman accordingly in a letter dated 20 September 2013.

  4. Dissatisfied with that outcome, Mr Harriman sought a review of the Registrar’s decision under r 7(2).  He has subsequently paid the full amount of the security, but on the basis that he still seeks review and a refund should the review be successful.  The Attorney-General opposes dispensation being granted.  The Parole Board abides the decision of the Court.

Grounds for review

  1. Mr Harriman contends the Registrar was wrong to find the appeal is not exceptional and lacks public importance.  He submits the appeal is exceptional because of factual and procedural errors that have occurred on the part of the Department of Corrections, the Parole Board and the High Court.  He further submits the appeal raises important issues of statutory interpretation and important constitutional issues and is arguable.  Reliance is also placed on impecuniosity.

Discussion

  1. Mr Harriman is a serving prisoner.  He has been considered for parole by the Parole Board on three occasions.  Parole was refused on each occasion, the relevant dates being 17 January 2012, 7 August 2012 and 17 July 2013.

  2. The High Court decision that Mr Harriman is seeking to impugn on appeal relates only to the January 2012 decision.  The key findings made by Goddard J were essentially case specific and not of any general importance.  Further, the findings also concur with findings made by Judge Mahoney in an earlier unsuccessful review of the same decision brought by Mr Harriman under s 67 of the Parole Act 2002.  In terms of the merits of the appeal, Mr Harriman faces the further difficulties of there having been two subsequent Parole Board decisions also denying him parole[2] as well…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harriman v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZCA 674
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand heard an appeal from Allen Louis Harriman against the Attorney-General and the New Zealand Parole Board. Harriman sought judicial review of decisions made by the Department of Corrections and the Parole Board concerning his parole applications. The appeal was dismissed by Goddard J in the High Court, and Harriman now appealed against the dismissal and the requirement to pay security for costs. Harriman sought a review of the Registrar's decision that refused to dispense with the payment of security for costs, arguing that the appeal had public importance and was exceptional. The Attorney-General opposed the application, and the Parole Board abided by the court's decision.

The primary legal issue was whether the Registrar's decision was correct in refusing to dispense with the payment of security for costs. Harriman argued that the appeal was exceptional due to factual and procedural errors by the Department of Corrections, the Parole Board, and the High Court. He also submitted that the appeal raised significant issues of statutory interpretation and constitutional importance and was arguable. Harriman further relied on his impecuniosity as a reason for dispensation. The court needed to determine whether the appeal had public importance or significance and whether the circumstances were exceptional enough to warrant dispensing with the payment of security for costs.

The court found that the appeal was not exceptional and lacked public importance. The High Court's findings were case-specific and not of general importance, and they concurred with previous findings in a similar case. The appeal's merits were weak, given that Harriman had faced two subsequent parole denials and lacked a release plan. The court emphasised that judicial review is unlikely in the parole context where alleged errors are overtaken by subsequent decisions. While impecuniosity is an important consideration, it is not determinative. The principle that a respondent should not face the risk of a hopeless appeal without security provision was also considered. Since Harriman had already paid the security, the court upheld the Registrar's decision, dismissing the application for review of the decision on dispensing with the payment of security for costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Allen Louis Harriman, a serving prisoner, has been denied parole by the New Zealand Parole Board on three occasions, with the most recent refusal occurring on 17 July 2013. His first application for judicial review, brought under section 67 of the Parole Act 2002, was dismissed by Judge Mahoney. Mr Harriman subsequently filed an appeal against the decision of Goddard J, who dismissed his application for judicial review of the January 2012 parole decision. The appeal is limited to the findings of Goddard J, which were essentially case-specific and concurred with those of Judge Mahoney. Mr Harriman also faces difficulties as there have been two subsequent Parole Board decisions denying him parole, and there is no ongoing release plan. Mr Harriman has paid the required security for costs but seeks a review of the Registrar's decision to refuse dispensation from paying the security.

The matter originated in the High Court, where Goddard J dismissed Mr Harriman's application for judicial review. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Mr Harriman filed an appeal to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeal is being heard on the papers, and the Court has been asked to review the Registrar's decision to deny dispensation from the payment of security for costs. The Registrar had ruled that the appeal did not have public importance or significance and could not be considered exceptional. Mr Harriman sought a review of the Registrar's decision, and the Attorney-General opposes the granting of dispensation. The New Zealand Parole Board abides by the Court's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appeal has public importance or is exceptional, justifying dispensation from the payment of security for costs.
2. Whether the appeal raises important issues of statutory interpretation and constitutional issues that warrant the granting of dispensation.
3. Whether Mr Harriman's impecuniosity is a sufficient reason to dispense with the payment of security for costs.

Held
1. The court held that the appeal does not have public importance or is exceptional, thus justifying dispensation from the payment of security for costs is not warranted.
2. The court held that the appeal does not raise important issues of statutory interpretation and constitutional issues that warrant the granting of dispensation.
3. The court held that Mr Harriman's impecuniosity is not a sufficient reason to dispense with the payment of security for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court reviewed Mr Harriman's application for dispensation from the payment of security for costs, which was denied by the Registrar. The court examined three key grounds put forth by Mr Harriman: the appeal's public importance, the appeal's raising important issues of statutory interpretation and constitutional issues, and Mr Harriman's impecuniosity. The court found that the appeal was not exceptional or of public importance, as the findings of the High Court were case-specific and in line with previous decisions. Additionally, the court held that the appeal did not raise significant issues of statutory interpretation or constitutional matters. While the court acknowledged the importance of access to justice, it emphasized that impecuniosity is not determinative and that the principle of protecting respondents from the risk of a hopeless appeal without provision for security also applies. The court ultimately upheld the Registrar's decision, dismissing the application for review of the decision to refuse dispensation from the payment of security for costs. The ratio decidendi of this case is that an appellant must pay security for costs unless the appeal has exceptional circumstances or is of significant public importance.