Harriman v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA463/2013
[2014] NZCA 544

BETWEEN

ALLEN LOUIS HARRIMAN
Appellant

AND

ATTORNEY-GENERAL
First Respondent

NEW ZEALAND PAROLE BOARD
Second Respondent

Hearing:

29 July 2014

Court:

O’Regan P, Lang and Clifford JJ

Counsel:

Appellant in person
C A Griffin and L M Inverarity for First Respondent
K L Clark QC and V J Owen for Second Respondent

Judgment:

12 November 2014 at 12 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant must pay the respondents costs of $11,760, being the amount of security for costs held by the Registrar of the Court.  That amount is to be divided evenly between the respondents unless they agree otherwise.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by O’Regan P)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1]
Issues  [2]
Facts  [7]

Did the Department cause the parole hearing to miscarry?  [30]

Was the Board’s policy in relation to attended hearings lawful?

Mr Harriman’s submission  [44]

High Court decision  [50]

Statutory scheme  [52]

Board’s submission   [69]

Our analysis  [70]

Was the January 2012 hearing tainted by unlawfulness or unfairness?      [75]

Was the hearing an unattended hearing?  [76]

Was Mr Harriman entitled to an unattended hearing?   [83]

Did the Board apply the wrong test?  [89]

Was the Board’s decision inevitable?  [93]

Was the decision unlawful?  [95]

Parole Amendment Bill  [96]

Impact of subsequent developments  [98]

Is Mr Harriman arbitrarily detained?  [103]

Summary  [104]

Result   [112]

Costs  [113]

Postscript  [114]

Introduction

  1. The appellant, Mr Harriman, is a serving prisoner.  He appeals against a decision of Goddard J in which she dismissed his application for judicial review of certain actions by the first respondent, the Department of Corrections (the Department)[1] and the second respondent, the New Zealand Parole Board (the Board) arising from the disposition of his application for parole on 17 January 2012.[2]  Other aspects of Mr Harriman’s claims against the Department and the Board, including claims for damages for misfeasance in public office and breach of statutory duty and for compensation for breaches of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (Bill of Rights), have been severed from the judicial review claims and will be dealt with later.[3]

Issues

[1]The Attorney-General is sued in respect of the Department.

  1. Goddard J distilled Mr Harriman’s judicial review claims into three essential issues, which she defined as follows:[4]

    (a)the Department caused his first parole hearing to miscarry, by providing inaccurate and incomplete information to the Board;

    (b)the Board’s decision was unlawful, unreasonable and procedurally unfair, because the Board failed to properly determine his application for an unattended hearing and went on to make erroneous findings in its decision; and

    (c)as a result his detention is now arbitrary and unlawful, in breach of [the Bill of Rights] and [the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights].

    [4]High Court decision, above n 2, at [3].

  2. Goddard J found that none of the claims was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harriman v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 544
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Harriman, a serving prisoner, appealed against a decision of Goddard J in the High Court dismissing his application for judicial review of actions by the Department of Corrections (the Department) and the New Zealand Parole Board (the Board) arising from the disposition of his application for parole on 17 January 2012. The appeal raised three main issues: (1) whether the Department caused the parole hearing to miscarry by providing inaccurate or incomplete information to the Board; (2) whether the Board’s policy in relation to attended hearings was lawful; and (3) whether the 17 January 2012 hearing was tainted by unlawfulness or unfairness. The Court concluded that the Department did not cause the parole hearing to miscarry, the Board’s policy in relation to attended hearings was unlawful, and the 17 January 2012 hearing was not tainted by unlawfulness or unfairness. The appeal was dismissed. The appellant must pay the respondents costs of $11,760, being the amount of security for costs held by the Registrar of the Court. That amount is to be divided evenly between the respondents unless they agree otherwise.

Background

Background to the litigation

Allen Louis Harriman is a serving prisoner who appealed a decision of Goddard J in which she dismissed his application for judicial review of certain actions by the first respondent, the Department of Corrections, and the second respondent, the New Zealand Parole Board, arising from the disposition of his application for parole on 17 January 2012. Harriman was sentenced to 12 years’ imprisonment with a minimum period of imprisonment of six and a half years for drug offences, and he became eligible for parole on 23 January 2012. In preparation for the consideration of the possibility of parole, the Board sent Harriman a letter on 1 September 2011, informing him that there would be a parole hearing on or about 16 January 2012. The Department began preparation of a Parole Assessment Report (PAR), which was completed on 23 November 2011 and received by the Board on 30 November 2011. The PAR did not contain any confirmation of the availability or appropriateness of the release address provided by Harriman in his submissions. Harriman sent written submissions to the Board on 9 December 2011, requesting an “unattended hearing” as provided for in s 48 of the Parole Act. On 13 December 2011, an officer of the Department had attended Harriman in his cell and asked him to sign a waiver of attendance at the parole hearing. Harriman explained to the prison officer that he had asked for an unattended hearing under s 48 of the Parole Act and accordingly Harriman refused to sign the waiver form. The Board then went ahead with the hearing and refused parole. Harriman applied for a review of the Board’s decision under s 67 of the Parole Act. The review was conducted by Judge Mahony who upheld aspects of Harriman’s application but concluded that the Board had adopted an approach that was compliant with s 28 of the Parole Act and its decision was lawful. Harriman then commenced the present proceedings.

The appeal came before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand on 29 July 2014. The appellant, Harriman, appeared in person, while the first respondent was represented by C A Griffin and L M Inverarity, and the second respondent was represented by K L Clark QC and V J Owen. The judgment was delivered on 12 November 2014. The appeal was dismissed and Harriman was ordered to pay the respondents costs of $11,760.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Department cause the 17 January 2012 parole hearing to miscarry by providing inaccurate or incomplete information to the Board?
2. Was the Board’s policy in relation to attended hearings lawful?
3. Was the 17 January 2012 hearing tainted by unlawfulness or unfairness?
4. What is the impact of subsequent developments?
5. Is Harriman subject to arbitrary detention?

Held
1. The Court concluded that the Department did not cause the 17 January 2012 parole hearing to miscarry by providing inaccurate or incomplete information to the Board. The appeal in this regard was dismissed.
2. The Court held that the Board’s policy in relation to attended hearings was unlawful because it failed to require Panel Convenors to make a decision in each case as to whether a hearing should be an attended or unattended hearing. However, the failure to follow this policy did not deprive the Board of jurisdiction or render the hearing unlawful in this case.
3. The Court determined that the 17 January 2012 hearing was not tainted by unlawfulness or unfairness. While there was a procedural error in not deciding the type of hearing in advance, the Board reached a conclusion that was legally open to it, and the outcome was inevitable due to the lack of key information.
4. The Court found that the impact of subsequent developments rendered the relief sought by Mr Harriman essentially of historical interest. The quashing of the 17 January 2012 decision would be pointless given the regular reconsiderations of Mr Harriman’s parole status.
5. The Court concluded that Mr Harriman is not subject to arbitrary detention. He is a sentenced prisoner serving a sentence imposed lawfully and must be considered for parole when the minimum period of imprisonment imposed at sentencing expires.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court addressed the key issues raised in the appeal concerning the parole hearing process and the legality of the Board’s decisions. In relation to the Department, the Court found that Mr Harriman’s refusal to cooperate by providing necessary information led to deficiencies in the Parole Assessment Report, but this did not result in a miscarrying of the hearing. The Court emphasized that the Board requires more than a notification from the offender of the proposed address without providing that address to the Department for checking.

Regarding the Board’s policy, the Court held that the policy of having attended hearings as a default option was unlawful because it bypassed the statutory requirement for Panel Convenors to make a decision in each case as to the type of hearing. However, the failure to follow this policy did not deprive the Board of jurisdiction when embarking on an attended hearing in Mr Harriman’s case. The Court found that Mr Harriman was not entitled to an unattended hearing as the statutory scheme does not provide a right to such a hearing.

The Court also found that the Board’s decision to decline parole was inevitable due to the lack of a viable release proposal. Although there were procedural errors, the Board reached a conclusion that was legally open to it. The Court concluded that the relief sought by Mr Harriman would be pointless given the subsequent and regular reconsiderations of his parole status.

Finally, the Court held that Mr Harriman is not subject to arbitrary detention. He remains a sentenced prisoner serving a lawful sentence and must be considered for parole when the minimum period of imprisonment imposed at sentencing expires. The Court urged all parties to break the impasse and deal with Mr Harriman’s parole application on its merits.