Harding v Harding HC Whangarei CIV 2010-488-218

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CIV-2010-488-000218

UNDER  the Property Law Act 2007 s 339 Property

Identifier NA121D/449

BETWEEN  C A HARDING Plaintiff

ANDA R HARDING First Defendant

ANDC J BLAKE Second Defendant

Hearing:         17 May 2010

Appearances: D James for Plaintiff

T Savage for First Defendant
Second Defendant not present

Judgment:      17 May 2010

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BELL

Solicitors:

Palmer Macauley, PO Box 576, Kerikeri

Egan & Kite (J Bunbury), PO Box 146, Whangarei

Urlich McNab Kilpatrick, PO Box 633, Whangarei

Copy e-mailed to:

A R Harding, Second Defendant in person

C A HARDING V A R HARDING AND ANOR HC WHA CIV-2010-488-000218 17 May 2010

[1]      This  proceeding  concerns  a  property  at  36  Tasman  Heights,  Ahipara, Identifier  NA121D/449.    The  certificate  of  title  to  the  property  shows  that  the plaintiff  and  the  second  defendant  are  the  owners  of  the  property and  the  first defendant  is  a  second  mortgagee.    The  first  mortgagee  is  the  National  Bank. However, the rights of the parties to this proceeding are governed by an agreement dated 4 June 2004.  Under this agreement, the plaintiff and the second defendant, a married couple, agreed to sell the first defendant an undivided one-half interest in the land for the price of $260,000, inclusive of GST, if any.

[2]      The agreement provided that the vendors, that is the plaintiff and the second defendant, should remain in occupation, and there was a provision for sale.   The deadline for the property to be sold was four years from the effective date.   The effective date was 1 July 2004.

[3]      Clause 6 of the agreement provided:

The vendors land shall be offered for sale on the open market not earlier than two years but not in any event later than four years from the Effective Date by agreement between the parties as to:

a)        the time at which the property is offered for sale;

b)        the price at which the property is to be offered for sale;

c)        the minimum price at which the property is to be sold;

d)the  means  by  which  the  property  is  to  be  sold,  including  the appointment of an agent, the payment of a commission, advertising costs and other matters relating to the sale process.

[4]      Clause 6 goes on to say how the proceeds of sale are to be applied.   It provides for, firstly, the payment of the real estate agent and appropriate advertising costs;  next, payment of legal expenses incurred on the sale with the balance to be divided equally between the vendors and purchaser with the vendors assuming sole liability for repayment of the National Bank mortgage.

[5]      Clause 10 deals with matters in dispute.  It says:

If any dispute shall arise between the parties concerning this agreement:

a)        the parties shall first meet in the spirit of mutual co-operation to endeavour to resolve that dispute;

b)if the dispute has not been resolved within 14 days, then either party may call for the dispute to be resolved…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harding v Harding HC Whangarei CIV 2010-488-218 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 1292
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the plaintiff, C A Harding, brought a proceeding against A R Harding (the first defendant) and C J Blake (the second defendant) regarding a property located at 36 Tasman Heights, Ahipara. The parties were governed by an agreement dated 4 June 2004, which outlined the sale of an undivided one-half interest in the land to the first defendant for $260,000. The agreement also provided that the plaintiff and the second defendant were to remain in occupation of the property and sell it within four years from the effective date of 1 July 2004. However, the property had not been sold by the deadline, and the parties were in dispute over various matters, including the alleged agreement negotiated in March 2008. The plaintiff sought orders for sale under s 339 of the Property Law Act, while the first defendant opposed the application and sought a stay of the proceedings, arguing that the matter should be referred to arbitration.

The court was required to decide whether the matter should be referred to arbitration or if the parties should be given the opportunity to resolve the matter informally. The court also had to consider the implications of the alleged agreement negotiated in March 2008, which was not recorded in writing as required by the agreement between the parties.

The court found that the arbitration clause was ambiguous, as there was no such body as the Northland District Law Society. The court also noted that arbitration would involve lengthy delays and heavy expenses, and would not provide a ready resolution to the matters in issue. The court acknowledged that, as long as a party seeking a stay showed that there were matters properly in dispute, the court must refer the matter to arbitration. However, the court believed that alternatives to arbitration should be fully explored before that step was taken. The court made a declaration that the property should be sold, but it did not make an order for sale as it was uncertain how the property should be sold. The court directed that the matter should be adjourned until 19 July 2010 to allow the parties to reach an agreement on the manner of sale of the property. The court reserved the parties' rights and arguments regarding the alleged agreement negotiated in March 2008 and the distribution of any sale once a sale does take place.

The court directed that the second defendant be given a copy of the judgment and be served by email. The court also directed that the first defendant arrange representation by other counsel as he would be absent from 18 July 2010 until 16 August 2010. The court reserved costs for the day.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established