Hardegger v Southland Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND INVERCARGILL REGISTRY

CRI-2016-425-000038

CRI-2016-425-000039 [2017] NZHC 469

BETWEEN

ADOLF PUIS HARDEGGER

HARDEGGER TRUSTEES LIMITED Appellants

AND

SOUTHLAND REGIONAL COUNCIL Respondent

Hearing: 3 February 2017

Appearances:

R T Chapman & H J Copland for the Appellants
J L S Shaw for the Respondent

Judgment:

16 March 2017

JUDGMENT OF NATION J

[1]      Over about five months to November 2015, a contractor carried out extensive laning and subdivision work on a property in Southland, developing it as a dairy run- off block.  He constructed a gravel bund on the bed of the Oreti River.  It diverted the river away from the true right bank of the Oreti River, protecting farmland to its west.  At the time the channel downstream from the wall was dry.  The bund was washed away in a later fresh.

[2]      Around the same time, a shipping container had been placed in the bed of Starvation Creek to provide a crossing for stock and vehicles.  Starvation Creek was a small waterway that flowed through an adjacent property leased from the Department of Conservation.

[3]      The contractor also straightened Starvation Creek by removing an ox-bow bend in the creek.

HARDEGGER v SOUTHLAND REGIONAL COUNCIL [2017] NZHC 469 [16 March 2017]

[4]      The land in question is beneficially owned by two Hardegger family trusts of which Hardegger Trustees Limited (Hardegger Trustees) is the sole trustee.

[5]      Both  Mr  Hardegger,  as  the  person  ultimately responsible  for  the  actions giving rise to the offending, and Hardegger Trustees, as the registered proprietor of the  land,  pleaded  guilty  to  charges  under  the  Resource  Management Act  1991 (RMA).   These were for excavating or otherwise disturbing the bed of the Oreti River, placing a culvert on the bed of Starvation Creek and disturbing the bed of Starvation Creek when not expressly allowed to do so by a rule in a regional plan or a resource consent.   Mr Hardegger and Hardegger Trustees thus each faced three charges.

[6]      On 28 October 2016, on each charge, Judge Dwyer fined them $11,900, a total of $35,700 each.   He also ordered them to pay Court costs of $130 on each charge plus solicitors costs in accordance with the costs in Criminal Cases Regulations 1987. They appeal against those sentences.

Principles on appeal

[7]      This appeal is a general appeal from the District Court regarding sentence.

[8]      Appeals against sentence are brought under s 244 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 and must be determined in accordance with s 250 of that Act.  Specifically, this Court may only allow an appeal against sentence if it is satisfied that there has been an error in the imposition of the sentence and that, in the event, a different

sentence should be imposed.1

[9]      If the sentence under appeal may be properly justified having regard to the relevant sentencing principles, it is not the place of this Court to intervene and substitute its own views for those of the sentencing Judge.  It is only if the sentence is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hardegger v Southland Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 469
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellants, Adolf Puis Hardegger and Hardegger Trustees Limited, appealed against the penalties imposed by the District Court for charges under the Resource Management Act 1991. Hardegger Trustees is the sole trustee of two Hardegger family trusts which beneficially own the land in question. The charges related to excavating and disturbing the bed of the Oreti River, placing a culvert on the bed of Starvation Creek, and disturbing the bed of Starvation Creek when not expressly allowed by a rule in a regional plan or a resource consent. The Judge fined both appellants $11,900 on each charge, a total of $35,700 each, and ordered them to pay Court costs and solicitors costs. The Judge had taken a global approach to the sentence for each defendant, with one overall penalty starting point for the three offences. He arrived at a starting point for the offending, taking into account the nature of the environment affected, the extent of damage inflicted, the deliberateness of the offending, the attitude of the offender and the extent of their attempts to comply, the position of the offender and remorse/good character. The Judge then considered how that resulting penalty should be imposed, whether on each defendant separately or divided between them. He concluded it was not appropriate to take a global assessment and then apportion culpability between defendants. He could not distinguish the comparative culpability, each having a responsibility to ensure that works undertaken were done legally and each having failed to do so. The Judge adopted a starting point of $50,000 in each case, allowed a five per cent reduction to reflect past good character and a further 25 per cent reduction for prompt guilty pleas. The High Court found there were errors in the approach the Judge took in assessing the inter-relationship between the company and Mr Hardegger. A company is also a separate legal entity and it has been accepted by the High Court and by Environment Court Judges in the District Court that, in assessing culpability and to avoid double-penalising the people closely associated with a small family-based farming company, it is appropriate to lift the corporate veil in identifying who was responsible for the offending and how the penalties for that offending will be borne. The sentences imposed in the District Court were quashed. The High Court imposed a penalty of $8,312 on Mr Hardegger on each charge and a penalty of $3,562.50 on Hardegger Trustees Ltd on each charge. Both appellants will pay Court costs for the proceedings in the District Court of $130 on each charge plus solicitor costs. The enforcement order made against both appellants remains in effect. All parties will bear their own costs in relation to this appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.