Haast Energy Trading Limited v The Electricity Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read
NOTE: REDACTIONS MADE TO PARAGRAPHS [31] AND [61] PURSUANT TO CONFIDENTIALITY ORDERS

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2022-485-381

[2024] NZHC 195

UNDER The Electricity Industry Act 2010

IN THE MATTER OF

Appeals pursuant to section 64

BETWEEN

HAAST ENERGY TRADING LIMITED and ELECTRIC KIWI LIMITED

Appellants

AND

THE ELECTRICITY AUTHORITY

Respondent

AND

NOVA ENERGY LIMITED and MERIDIAN ENERGY LIMITED

Interested Parties

Hearing: 28 February 2023

Appearances:

R Butler, S Jeffs and T Refoy-Butler for Appellants R May and T Bain for Respondent

T Smith, J Tocher and J Raffills for Nova Energy as Interested Party

J Every-Palmer KC and J Woolley for Meridian, as Non-Party K Massey and J Upson for NZX, as Non-Party

Judgment:

16 February 2024

Reissued:

26 February 2024


JUDGMENT OF CULL J


HAAST ENERGY TRADING LIMITED and ELECTRIC KIWI LIMITED v THE ELECTRICITY AUTHORITY [2024] NZHC 195 [16 February 2024]

TABLE OF CONTENTS\

Para No.

Background context of the electricity market....................................................... [6]

The national electricity system.................................................................................. [7]

Pricing Manager’s statutory functions..................................................................... [14]
What happened on 9 August 2021?......................................................................... [22]

The grid emergency........................................................................................ [22]

The ISS Notice............................................................................................... [27]

Approach on appeal............................................................................................... [32]

The issues................................................................................................................ [35]

Preliminary applications....................................................................................... [37]

Special leave........................................................................................................ [38]

Fresh evidence on appeal - the Ruling Panel material........................................ [45]
Further evidence on appeal................................................................................. [53]

THE PRICING DECISIONS............................................................................... [57]

What is a pricing error?...................................................................................... [58]
The first pricing decision..................................................................................... [61]
The second pricing decision................................................................................ [67]
The circumstances surrounding the ISS Notice................................................... [75]

The ISS Notice issued in breach of the Code................................................. [81]

The basis of the pricing decisions........................................................................ [88]

Was there a pricing error?................................................................................... [99]
Conclusion.............................................................................................................. [38]

THE UTS DECISION......................................................................................... [112]

Observation........................................................................................................ [121]

Result.................................................................................................................... [123]
Costs...................................................................................................................... [125]

[1]                  On 9 August 2021, one of the coldest nights of the year, more than 34,000 households had their power turned off, when peak electricity demand reached its highest record in New Zealand. As a result of a grid emergency, scarcity pricing of wholesale electricity was imposed for four 30 minute trading periods, increasing the price of wholesale electricity for those trading periods by $130 million.

[2]                  Haast Energy Trading Limited1 and Electric Kiwi Limited (both referred to as Haast) appeal against three decisions of the Electricity Authority (the Authority), which found the imposition of scarcity pricing was not a pricing error or did not amount to an undesirable trading situation (an UTS).2 Haast appeals the decisions


1      Haast Energy Ltd is a sister company of the Energy Collective Ltd, both of which have 65% common shareholding and are commonly controlled. The Energy Collective is an energy retailer and technology business which owns electricity retailer Electric Kiwi Ltd.

2      Electricity Authority, Pricing Error Decision, 7 September 2021 [the First Pricing Error Decision]; Electricity Authority, Pricing Error Decision, 1 February 2022 [the Second Pricing Error

under s 64 of the Electricity Industry Act 2010, contending that the Authority erred as a matter…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Haast Energy Trading Limited v The Electricity Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 195
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Haast Energy Trading Limited v The Electricity Authority, the High Court of New Zealand considered appeals by Haast Energy Trading Limited and Electric Kiwi Limited against decisions of the Electricity Authority (the Authority) that found the imposition of scarcity pricing on 9 August 2021 was not a pricing error or an undesirable trading situation (UTS). The Authority found that the grid emergency on 9 August 2021, where peak electricity demand reached its highest level on record, did not trigger the conditions for scarcity pricing as defined in the Electricity Industry Participation Code 2010 (the Code). Transpower, the system operator, had issued a grid emergency notice (GEN) but not an island shortage situation (ISS) notice as required for scarcity pricing. However, Transpower had issued the ISS notice in error, which led to the imposition of scarcity pricing. The Authority declined Haast's pricing error claims and UTS claim, finding that the pricing error claim was outside the definition of a pricing error and the UTS claim did not threaten confidence in, or the integrity of, the wholesale market. The court found that the Authority erred in law in declining the pricing error claims, as the issuance of the ISS notice in breach of the Code led to a pricing error. The court upheld the appeals against the pricing error decisions but dismissed the appeal against the UTS decision, as the error could be resolved through the pricing calculation mechanism under the Code. The court ordered that costs follow the event.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established