H&M Remuera Limited v Rentmax Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2024-404-2198

[2025] NZHC 369

IN THE MATTER

of the Companies Act 1993 and in the matter of an application putting a company into

liquidation

BETWEEN

H&M REMUERA LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

RENTMAX LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 25 February 2025 (by AVL)

Appearances:

R J Latton for Plaintiff

J R Duckworth for Defendant

Judgment:

3 March 2025


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE LESTER


This judgment was delivered by me on 3 March 2025 at 4.30pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

………………………………………..

H&M REMUERA LIMITED v RENTMAX LIMITED [2025] NZHC 369 [3 March 2025]

[1]                 H&M Remuera Limited (H&M) applies to liquidate Rentmax Limited (Rentmax), relying on an unpaid statutory demand totalling $18,227.49.

[2]                 H&M’s statutory demand relies on three invoices issued to Rentmax pursuant to a Heads of Agreement between H&M and Rentmax dated 29 September 2021 (Heads of Agreement). A total of six invoices were issued pursuant to the Heads of Agreement. It is noteworthy that Rentmax does not take any issue with the services provided as recorded in any of the invoices, indeed it paid the first three.

[3]                 This proceeding is the second proceeding concerning amounts charged pursuant to the Heads of Agreement. The first was a liquidation proceeding brought against Rentmax by a company called Prosec Group Limited (Prosec) which is related to H&M. Prosec sought the liquidation of Rentmax, having issued a statutory demand for the same sums claimed in the invoices in issue in this proceeding having issued invoices in its name as creditor. That application was dismissed in a decision of Associate Judge Gardiner dated 11 December 2023, essentially on the basis Prosec was not a party to the Heads of Agreement.1

[4]                 Mr and   Mrs   Talbot   are   the   directors   of    H&M    and    of    Prosec. Mr and Mrs Thompson are the directors of Rentmax. Mrs Talbot is a member of the Vietnamese community.

[5]                 The intention of the Heads of Agreement was that Mrs Talbot would refer members of the Vietnamese community who owned rental properties to Rentmax to manage. H&M would be paid a fee (on the basis which I discuss below) and it is that fee that makes up the invoices for which H&M issued its statutory demand.

[6]                 How is it then that an earlier liquidation proceeding concerning the same sums came to be issued in the name of Prosec? Shortly after the Heads of Agreement was signed, it was realised that H&M was no longer registered for GST. In the proceeding before Associate Judge Gardiner, Mr Talbot said it was agreed with Mrs Thompson that H&M would invoice through another company (Prosec) but this was denied by Rentmax. Prosec is named as the creditor in the first three invoices which were paid


1      Prosec Group Ltd v Rentmax Ltd [2023] NZHC 3612.

by Rentmax without any dispute. Associate Judge Gardiner recorded that it was common ground that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read H&M Remuera Limited v Rentmax Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 369
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

H&M Remuera Limited (H&M) applied to liquidate Rentmax Limited (Rentmax) relying on an unpaid statutory demand for $18,227.49. H&M's demand was based on three unpaid invoices issued pursuant to a Heads of Agreement between H&M and Rentmax dated 29 September 2021. Notably, Rentmax did not dispute the services provided as recorded in any of the invoices, having paid the first three invoices. This proceeding is the second liquidation proceeding concerning amounts charged pursuant to the Heads of Agreement. A previous proceeding brought by a related company, Prosec Group Limited (Prosec), was dismissed on the basis Prosec was not a party to the Heads of Agreement.

The primary legal issues were whether H&M was entitled to seek liquidation of Rentmax, and whether Rentmax had a valid counterclaim against H&M. The court first examined whether H&M was entitled to seek liquidation of Rentmax. H&M argued that it had addressed the irregularity with its earlier invoices issued in Prosec’s name, as Rentmax only ever dealt with H&M. The court found that H&M was entitled to designate Prosec as its agent to receive payments, as there was nothing in the Heads of Agreement that prescribed where payment had to be made or how. Therefore, payment to Prosec discharged the debt.

The court then considered Rentmax's counterclaims. First, Rentmax sought repayment of the first three invoices it had paid to Prosec. The court found that H&M could reissue invoices to replace those paid to Prosec, and no limitation issue arose as Rentmax had not disputed its obligation to pay for the services reflected in the first three invoices. Therefore, the first three invoices did not give rise to a defence to this liquidation proceeding. Second, Rentmax claimed substantial damages for what it said was H&M’s breach of the Heads of Agreement. The court found that Rentmax had not demonstrated a reasonably arguable basis for quantifying its alleged loss. The Heads of Agreement provided a formula for the fee to be paid by Rentmax to H&M, and Rentmax had not applied this formula to identify the properties it claimed were lost and calculate the refund it was arguably entitled to. Therefore, Rentmax’s counterclaim for damages failed.

The court found that H&M was entitled to seek an order liquidating Rentmax. The proceeding was adjourned to enable the debt to be paid, and if it was not paid by that time, an order for liquidation would be made. The court ordered that costs should follow the event on a 2B basis plus disbursements as fixed by the Registrar.