H Investments Ltd (in liq) v Official Assignee

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

 CA319/2017
 [2018] NZCA 76

BETWEEN

H INVESTMENTS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
Appellant

AND

OFFICIAL ASSIGNEE
Respondent

Hearing:

28 November 2017

Court:

Clifford, Dobson and Collins JJ

Counsel:

M D Branch and S J M Rawcliffe for Appellant
P V Cornegé and G E Slevin for Respondent 

Judgment:

29 March 2018 at 3.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Dobson J)

Contents

Issues on the appeal................................................................................................. [1]

Factual background................................................................................................. [4]

The High Court judgment...................................................................................... [9]

Grounds for the appeal......................................................................................... [15]

Estoppel.................................................................................................................. [16]

The liquidators’ proof of debt.............................................................................. [31]

Standard of proof................................................................................................. [31]
Onus of proof....................................................................................................... [42]
Should the Assignee have accepted the liquidators’ proof?................................ [48]
Cash flow insolvency........................................................................................... [60]
Balance sheet solvency........................................................................................ [67]
Breach of director’s duties................................................................................... [77]

Result...................................................................................................................... [96]

Issues on the appeal

  1. The narrow issue in this appeal is a challenge to the High Court’s confirmation of the Official Assignee’s rejection of a proof of debt claim filed against the estate of a bankrupt by the liquidators of a company of which the bankrupt was the sole director and shareholder.[1]  H Investments Ltd (in liq) is the appellant (the company) and the respondent is the Official Assignee (the Assignee) in his capacity as the trustee in bankruptcy of the director, Mr Nyall Hitchcock.

  1. The liquidators’ proof of debt claim alleged breaches of duty owed by Mr Hitchcock to the company under ss 131, 135, 136 and 137 of the Companies Act 1993 (the CA) during the period he was its alter ego.  The claims were that Mr Hitchcock had failed to act in the best interests of the company, had allowed the company to recklessly trade and incur obligations which he did not believe on reasonable grounds the company could perform, and failed to exercise due care and skill.  The claims subsequently included a claim for failing to maintain accounting records, contrary to s 194 of the CA. 

  2. The appeal also raises somewhat wider issues of the standard required for a creditor to make out a proof of debt claim in bankruptcy, and where the onus of proof lies in dealing with claims of this nature against the estate of a bankrupt.  A further issue, in effect of estoppel, was raised for the first time on appeal. 

Factual background

  1. Mr Hitchcock was declared bankrupt in July 2013.  The Assignee was appointed as his trustee in bankruptcy.  The company was described by the liquidators as providing “contracting and repair services”.  In February 2014, the company was placed in liquidation on a creditor’s petition filed on behalf of Inland Revenue (IRD).  Shortly thereafter, the liquidators filed a proof of debt with the Assignee to claim against Mr Hitchcock’s estate in bankruptcy for the full extent of debts owed by the company at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read H Investments Ltd (in liq) v Official Assignee and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 76
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

H Investments Ltd (in liq) is the liquidator of a company in which the bankrupt, Mr Nyall Hitchcock, was the sole director and shareholder. The liquidators filed a proof of debt claim in Mr Hitchcock’s bankruptcy. The Official Assignee rejected the proof of debt claim, and the liquidators appealed to the High Court. The High Court dismissed the appeal, and the liquidators have appealed to the Court of Appeal. The liquidators’ proof of debt claim alleged that Mr Hitchcock breached his duties under the Companies Act 1993 (the CA) to the company during the period he was its alter ego. The liquidators claimed that Mr Hitchcock had failed to act in the best interests of the company, had allowed the company to recklessly trade and incur obligations which he did not believe on reasonable grounds the company could perform, and failed to exercise due care and skill. The liquidators also claimed that Mr Hitchcock had failed to maintain accounting records, contrary to s 194 of the CA. The liquidators further alleged that Mr Hitchcock’s actions caused losses to creditors of the company.

The appeal concerns the standard of proof required to make out a proof of debt claim, and the onus of proof where a claim is made against the estate of a bankrupt. The appeal also raises an issue of estoppel based on a deed of waiver that was executed by the Assignee, Mr Hitchcock and the Hitchcock interests (the family partnership associated with Mr Hitchcock). The Court found that the liquidators had not made out the requisite standard of proof to establish that Mr Hitchcock breached his duties under the CA. The Court also found that the liquidators had not made out that the company was insolvent on either cash flow or balance sheet approaches. The Court rejected the estoppel argument on the basis that the deed of waiver was not sufficient to establish a representation by the Assignee that he would accept the liquidators’ proof of debt claim. The liquidators’ appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established