Guardian Retail Holdings Ltd v Buddle Findlay

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-404-001448 [2013] NZHC 1582

BETWEEN  GUARDIAN RETAIL HOLDINGS LIMITED

Applicant

ANDBUDDLE FINDLAY First Respondent

BODY CORPORATE 323599
Second Respondent

VANESSA SMITH, SUSAN KERR AND JASON ROBERT BAILEY

Third Respondent

Hearing:                   22 May 2013

Appearances:           D J Chisholm for Applicant

G W Wall for Respondents

Judgment:                27 June 2013

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 27 June 2013 at 3.00 pm

pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date…………………………..

GUARDIAN RETAIL HOLDINGS LTD v BUDDLE FINDLAY [2013] NZHC 1582 [27 June 2013]

Introduction

[1]      Guardian  Retail  Holdings  Ltd  (GRH)  is  a  member  of  Body  Corporate

323599.  It has brought proceedings against the Body Corporate and three members of the Body Corporate Committee, alleging various breaches of the Body Corporate rules and acts of misfeasance.1   The Body Corporate has purported to ratify the acts that are the subject of the allegations.   It has also resolved to stand  behind the respondent committee members and meet their defence costs.   Buddle Findlay represents both the Body Corporate and the respondent committee members in the

substantive proceedings.

[2]      GRH asserts that there is a conflict of interest between the Body Corporate and the respondent committee members that prevents Buddle Findlay from properly discharging  its  obligations  to  the  Court  and  puts  it  in  breach  of  certain  of  the Conduct and Client Care Rules.2     It says, further, that Buddle Findlay’s own independence is compromised because its advice is in issue in the proceedings. GRH  also  asserts  that  the  Body  Corporate’s  funding  of  defence  costs  for  the

respondent committee members is ultra vires the Body Corporate and not in the

Body Corporate’s interests.

[3]      In this originating application GRH seeks orders restraining: (a)        Buddle Findlay from continuing to act; and

(b)The Body Corporate from funding or contributing to the defence costs of the respondent committee members.

[4]      The Body Corporate and  the respondent  committee members oppose the application.  Their main contention is that because of the ratification by the Body Corporate of the respondent committee members’ acts, their interests are aligned and

there is no, or no significant, conflict between them.

1   CIV-2012-404-002525.

2   Lawyers and Conveyancers (Conduct and Client Care) Rules 2008.

[5]      Buddle Findlay appeared at the hearing of the application on behalf of the Body Corporate and the respondent committee members.   Although named as a respondent, it did not seek to be heard in its own right.

The substantive proceedings

The history of the dispute

[6]      The building at the centre of the dispute is the Guardian building at 101-107

Queen Street, Auckland.   It was redeveloped in about 2003 by Guardian Property Holdings Limited which is related to GRH through its common director, Gregory Scott Wilkinson.  Of the 176 principal units, seven are commercial units situated on the ground or basement floors.  The remaining 169 are residential and located on the first to eighth floors.   The respondent committee members own residential units. GRH owns all…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Guardian Retail Holdings Ltd v Buddle Findlay and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1582
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Guardian Retail Holdings Ltd has brought proceedings against the Body Corporate 323599 and three members of its committee, alleging various breaches of the Body Corporate rules and acts of misfeasance. The Body Corporate has purported to ratify the acts that are the subject of the allegations and has also resolved to stand behind the respondent committee members and meet their defence costs. Buddle Findlay represents both the Body Corporate and the respondent committee members in the substantive proceedings. GRH asserts that there is a conflict of interest between the Body Corporate and the respondent committee members that prevents Buddle Findlay from properly discharging its obligations to the Court and puts it in breach of certain of the Conduct and Client Care Rules. It says, further, that Buddle Findlay’s own independence is compromised because its advice is in issue in the proceedings. GRH also asserts that the Body Corporate’s funding of defence costs for the respondent committee members is ultra vires the Body Corporate and not in the Body Corporate’s interests. In this originating application GRH seeks orders restraining: (a) Buddle Findlay from continuing to act; and (b) The Body Corporate from funding or contributing to the defence costs of the respondent committee members. The substantive proceedings The history of the dispute The building at the centre of the dispute is the Guardian building at 101-107 Queen Street, Auckland. It was redeveloped in about 2003 by Guardian Property Holdings Limited which is related to GRH through its common director, Gregory Scott Wilkinson. Of the 176 principal units, seven are commercial units situated on the ground or basement floors. The remaining 169 are residential and located on the first to eighth floors. The respondent committee members own residential units. GRH owns all but one of the commercial units, which gives it a 21% ownership interest in the Body Corporate. The current dispute centres mainly around the levying for water and gas. Except for unit 6 the commercial units have their own water and gas supply. Prior to 2011 the Body Corporate administered water and gas supply to the residential units and to unit 6 and charged only the owners of those units for the utilities cost, in accordance with the Body Corporate rules as they then stood. The result was that GRH was not levied for these costs. In 2011, however, the Body Corporate received legal advice to the effect that the rules relating to the way levies were set might be ultra vires. One of GRH’s complaints is that, in seeking advice, the Body Corporate Committee did not specifically direct its lawyer’s attention to the issue of costs such as gas that were not truly common because they were not supplied to all the units. After obtaining further advice from another firm (Grove Darlow) the Body Corporate Committee concluded that all levies should be raised on the basis of unit entitlement. The Committee also began to take steps to replace the existing Body Corporate Secretary, Crockers, including inviting a prospective replacement, Mr Leishman of Boutique Body Corporate Ltd, to attend committee meetings. GRH’s representative on the Committee, Aran Blackmore, was excluded from a Committee meeting in November 2011 because of a perceived conflict of interest. He subsequently resigned from the Committee. The remaining members proceeded to terminate Crockers’ contract and engage BBCL in its place. GRH maintains that this contravened clause 2.30 of the rules which provided for the removal of a secretary only at an annual general meeting or an extraordinary general meeting called for that purpose. In January 2012 the Committee resolved to reverse the levies for the 2010-2011 year set by members at the annual general meeting in 2011 and to re-set them, levying all members, including GRH, on a unit entitlement basis. GRH commences proceedings and the Body Corporate counterclaims Efforts to resolve the dispute were unsuccessful and, faced with the prospect of debt collection steps, GRH commenced the substantive proceedings in May 2012. It alleged breaches by the Body Corporate and the respondent committee members of UTA 1972 and the Body Corporate rules. As against the respondent committee members it also alleged failure to act in good faith in carrying out their duties as committee members, including by acting to further their own interests as proprietors of residential units. In its statement of claim GRH sought declarations that the reversal and resetting of the 2011 levies were ultra vires, as well as declarations regarding the legality of excluding Mr Blackmore from a committee meeting, terminating Crockers’ appointment and incurring unauthorised legal and body corporate secretarial costs. In addition, GRH sought specific monetary relief from the respondent committee members through an inquiry into damages and orders that they pay those to GRH. The Body Corporate and the respondent committee members, both represented by Buddle Findlay, filed a statement of defence. In addition, the Body Corporate counterclaimed and sought, by way of summary judgment, declarations that the Body Corporate rules relating to levying were ultra vires and judgment for historical levies for the period 2006-2010 which it claimed GRH had been undercharged for. These levies totalled $305,469.89. GRH accepted that the Body Corporate rules were ultra vires. However, it resisted the claim for historical levies and the Body Corporate’s application for summary judgment was dismissed because the levies were being sought without any Body Corporate resolution to support them. The Emergency General Meeting and ratification The Body Corporate Committee held an emergency general meeting (EGM) on 12 February 2013. Resolutions were passed ratifying the reversal/resetting of the levies, the consulting of Grove Darlow and Wilson Harle, the termination of Crockers/engagement of BBCL and exclusion of Mr Blackmore from a Committee meeting. The Body Corporate also resolved to engage Buddle Findlay to represent it and the respondent committee members in the litigation. GRH asserts that the information circulated by the Committee for the EGM wrongly characterised the dispute as being between the residential owners on the one hand and GRH on the other and gave inaccurate and inadequate disclosure of the legal and other costs incurred by the respondent committee members up to and including the summary judgment application. On the basis of the resolutions passed at the EGM the Body Corporate and respondent committee members filed an amended statement of defence and counterclaim for $305,469.89 for the revised levies for the years 2006-2010 which substantially comprised the supply of gas and water. A second counterclaim seeks levies raised in the 2012 year of which only partial payment has been made, asserting that a further $108,584.52 remains outstanding. GRH’s amended claim Consequent upon the resolutions passed at the EGM, GRH filed an amended statement of claim with four causes of action. The first focuses on various alleged breaches of UTA 1972, Unit Titles Act 2010 (UTA 2010), the Body Corporate rules and resolutions passed by the Body Corporate at the 2013 Annual General Meeting. These breaches generally reflected the conduct ratified (or purportedly ratified) at the EGM, including the reversal/re

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.