Greymouth Holdings Ltd v Jet Trustees Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2011-404-005309

[2013] NZHC 2497

BETWEEN

GREYMOUTH HOLDINGS LTD

First Plaintiff

AND

R M P DUNPHY
Second Plaintiff

AND

P H AND J A MASFEN
Third Plaintiffs

AND

JET TRUSTEES LIMITED

First Defendant

AND

J G Sturgess Second Defendant

……/continued over page

Hearing: 19 July 2013

Appearances:

J A Farmer QC, M D O’Brien and S Consedine for plaintiffs and fourth defendant in 5309 proceeding and first, second, seventh and eighth defendants in 5442 proceeding

P G Skelton QC and M Corlett for first, second and third defendants in 5309 proceeding and plaintiffs in 5442 proceeding

J F Anderson for third to sixth defendants in 5442 proceeding

Judgment:

24 September 2013

JUDGMENT OF GILBERT J

This judgment was delivered by me on 24 September 2013 at 4.30 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

GREYMOUTH HOLDINGS LTD v R M P DUNPHY [2013] NZHC 2497 [24 September 2013]

AND  JOHN STURGESS & ASSOCIATES

Third Defendant

ANDGREYMOUTH PETROLEUM HOLDINGS LIMITED

Fourth Defendant and Cross-Claimant

CIV 2011-404-005442

BETWEEN  J G STURGESS

First Plaintiff

AND  JET TRUSTEES LIMITED

Second Plaintiff

AND  JOHN  STURGESS  &  ASSOCIATES LIMITED

Third Plaintiff

AND  R M P DUNPHY

First Defendant

AND  GREYMOUTH HOLDINGS LIMITED

Second Defendant

ANDRICHARD SHANE DUNPHY AND WENDY DUNPHY

Third Defendants

AND  JUGEN KADEL

Fourth Defendant

AND  TOWER HILL INVESTORS LLP

Fifth Defendant

AND  GERMANDA HOLDINGS LIMITED

Sixth Defendant

ANDPETER HANBURY MASFEN AND JOANNA ALISON MASFEN

Seventh Defendants

ANDGREYMOUTH PETROLEUM HOLDINGS LIMITED

Eighth Defendant

[1] The primary relief sought by the 5309 plaintiffs in this proceeding was an order requiring Mr Sturgess and Jet Trustees Ltd to sell their shares in the Greymouth group of companies on the open market. In my interim judgment dated 8 May 2013,1 I declined to make this order and instead granted the alternative relief sought, namely an order that Mr Sturgess and Jet Trustees sell their shares at the fair market value determined by the arbitration currently being undertaken by the parties.2

[2]  The parties did not initially provide submissions on the precise form of order that would be appropriate if I followed this course. For example, they did not address the date the shares should be valued or how the position of the Group 1

minorities should be accommodated. Accordingly, I invited further submissions from the parties.3

[3] I have now received further submissions covering  these  issues.  This judgment is limited to providing directions as to the final orders required in terms of the interim judgment. I note that three further issues will remain outstanding following the release of this judgment. These are:

(a)The assessment of damages recoverable by Greymouth Petroleum Holdings Ltd from Mr Sturgess and John Sturgess and Associates Ltd (JSAL) in relation to the Midhurst operation.

(b)The assessment of damages recoverable by Greymouth Petroleum Holdings Ltd from Mr Sturgess and John Sturgess and Associates Ltd (JSAL) in relation to the Radnor operation.

(c)Costs.

[4]     The 5309 plaintiffs submitted 13 draft…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Greymouth Holdings Ltd v Jet Trustees Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 2497
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand considered a case involving Greymouth Holdings Ltd and others against Jet Trustees Limited and others. The primary dispute centered on the sale of shares in the Greymouth group of companies. The plaintiffs sought an order requiring the defendants to sell their shares on the open market. The court declined to make this order and instead granted an alternative relief, ordering the sale of shares at the fair market value determined by an ongoing arbitration process. Various orders were proposed by the parties to implement this decision, which the court reviewed and decided upon.

The court examined several legal issues, including the appropriate date for valuing the shares, the necessity of certain procedural orders, and the terms under which the shares should be sold. It considered whether orders should be made to facilitate a market sale of the shares, to appoint an independent expert, and to manage the sale process. The court also addressed the issue of the defendants' management fees and damages for certain operational costs. Additionally, it reviewed orders concerning the appointment of a new director, suspension of certain shareholder agreement provisions, and the resolution of any conflicts with existing agreements.

The court reasoned that some proposed orders were unnecessary and inconsistent with its interim judgment. It decided that the fair market value of the shares should be determined as at the date of the arbitration hearing, not as at a previous date proposed by one of the defendants. The court declined to make orders that would require a market sale or appoint an independent expert, as these were not necessary to implement the interim judgment. It also rejected certain procedural orders, such as those relating to the pre-emptive rights and deadlock provisions in the shareholder agreement. However, it did make orders for the appointment of a new director in place of one of the defendants and for the suspension of certain shareholder agreement provisions. The court further addressed the management fees owed to one of the defendants and ordered the payment of damages for certain operational costs to be determined in a future hearing. Finally, the court made orders reserving the determination of costs until after the quantum hearing.

The court's final orders included the determination of the fair market value of the shares as at the arbitration hearing, the appointment of a new director, and the suspension of certain shareholder agreement provisions. It also included orders for the payment of management fees and reserved the determination of damages and costs for future hearings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established