Grey District Council v Blain

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND GREYMOUTH REGISTRY

CIV-2011-418-000123 [2014] NZHC 939

BETWEEN

GREY DISTRICT COUNCIL

Plaintiff

AND

ANDREW SCOTT BLAIN First Defendant

KEVIN O'CONNOR & ASSOCIATES LIMITED

Second Defendant

CARTER HOLT HARVEY LIMITED Fourth Defendant

LHT DESIGN LIMITED Fifth Defendant

EVAN JONES CONSTRUCTION LIMITED

Third Party

Hearing: 7 May 2014  (Determined on the Papers)

Appearances:

No appearance for Plaintiff

S Lester for First and Second Defendants

D Valente for Fourth Defendant D J MacRae for Fifth Defendant G M Brodie for Third Party

CostsJudgment:

7 May 2014

COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

[1]      This judgment determines costs on the application of the defendants, who have succeeded  in  the  Court  of Appeal  on  their  opposition  to  the third party’s applications to strike out.

[2]      Memoranda have been filed on behalf of all defendants, jointly, and on behalf of the third party.

GREY DISTRICT COUNCIL v BLAIN and ORS [2014] NZHC 939 [7 May 2014]

[3]      There is no debate between the parties on the attendances for which costs should be awarded, nor on the scale which should apply to those attendances.  The sole issue between the parties is whether, as claimed by the successful defendants, they should each have costs or whether, as submitted by the third party, there should be one award of costs to all the defendants jointly.

[4]      The third party relies on High Court r 14.15 which provides:

14.15   Defendants defending separately

The court must not allow more than 1 set of costs, unless it appears to the court that there is good reason to do so, if –

(a)     several defendants defended a proceeding separately; and

(b)     it appears to the court that all or some of them could have joined in their defence.

[5]      This rule requires “the court to exercise some caution before awarding costs, without more, in favour of multiple parties, particularly when there is some overlap or community of interest in the litigation position of those parties:”.1

[6]      I also refer to Jordan v O’Sullivan (No 2):2

[8]   The extent to which the defendants’ interests were materially identical, as well as the extent to which one defendant did or could have relied upon the evidence or submissions of the others, are factors tending to suggest that the defendants could have joined in their defence.   Conversely, factors suggesting that defendants could not reasonably join in their defence include if the plaintiffs ran separate cases against the defendants, or sought separate relief,  the  defendants’ reputations  are  at  stake,  (for example  there  is  an allegation of fraud), a conflict of interest was likely in terms of the way the plaintiffs ran their case and/or the defendants’ relationship is such that they are justified in remaining at arms length from each other.

[7]      As noted by Winkelmann J in Financial Markets Authority v Hotchin:3

Rule 14.15 does not require parties to share one award; the Court has an overall discretion in relation to costs and, where appropriate, a discount may be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grey District Council v Blain and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 939
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand considered the case of Grey District Council v Blain, which involved a dispute over costs following a successful appeal by the defendants against the plaintiff's opposition to third-party applications to strike out. The defendants argued for separate awards of costs, while the third party contended for a single award of costs to all defendants jointly. The court needed to determine whether the defendants were entitled to separate awards of costs or if a single joint award would be more appropriate.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the defendants were entitled to separate awards of costs for their oppositions to the third-party applications or if they should be awarded jointly due to the overlap and community of interest in their litigation positions. The court considered High Court Rule 14.15, which mandates that the court should not allow more than one set of costs unless there is good reason to do so. The court also took into account factors such as the extent to which the defendants' interests were materially identical and the extent to which one defendant could have relied on the evidence or submissions of another.

The court found that while the defendants were entitled to separate awards of costs for filing notices of opposition and appearing at conferences, given their separate representation at that stage, they had not established good reason to depart from the mandate in Rule 14.15 for the preparation and delivery of submissions. The court noted the cooperation between the defendants' counsel, which led to the division of tasks but did not justify separate representation during the hearing. The court concluded that the defendants could have agreed for one counsel to present all submissions on their behalf, which would have resulted in a significant cost saving and been consistent with the High Court Rules. Therefore, the court allowed one set of costs for the preparation and delivery of submissions, awarding item 24 on a 2C basis and item 26 on a 2B basis.

The court further ruled that disbursements were allowed in the sum of $3,022.28. This decision highlights the importance of considering the overlap in litigation positions and the potential for cost savings when determining whether to award separate or joint costs to multiple defendants.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.