Grant v Independent Livestock 2010 Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CIV-2011-419-001233 [2012] NZHC 3458

UNDER  Part 18 of the High Court Rules and the

Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF     the Independent Livestock Agents Limited

(In Liquidation) and Independent Livestock

2010 Limited

BETWEEN  DAMIEN GRANT AND STEVEN KHOV Plaintiffs

AND  INDEPENDENT LIVESTOCK 2010

LIMITED

First Defendant

ANDIAN CHARLES SCHULER Second Defendant

Hearing:         26, 27 and 28 November 2012

Appearances: C W Grenfell and B J Norling for Plaintiffs

G D Hayes for Defendants

Judgment:      17 December 2012

JUDGMENT OF POTTER J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Potter on

17 December 2012 at 4.30 p.m., pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:

Solicitors:

Edmonds Judd, PO Box 35, Te Awamutu 3840  chrisg@edmondsjudd.co.nz

Hunwick Law Limited, PO Box 782, Hamilton

Copy to: D G Hayes, PO Box 9323, Hamilton  david@taxlaw.co.nz

GRANT V INDEPENDENT LIVESTOCK 2010 LIMITED HC HAM CIV-2011-419-001233 [17 December

2012]

Table of Contents

Introduction ............................................................................................................[1] Summary of factual background ............................................................................[2] Pleadings ..............................................................................................................[13] Relevant provisions of the Companies Act 1993 .................................................[17] Agreed facts .........................................................................................................[29] Factual issues in dispute.......................................................................................[30] When did Fairfax make payment for the stock it purchased through IL Agents from Mr and Mrs Mudge, and when did Mr Schuler become aware, or ought reasonably to have become aware, that payment was made? ................................................[31] Were Mr Schuler’s representations to Mr Mudge about Mr Willoughby fair and honest representations?........................................................................................[47] Was there an agreement for payment of commission to IL Agents on the sale of the Mudges’ farm?......................................................................................................[58] When was the invoice dated 25 May 2008 created? ............................................[87] Did Mr and Mrs Mudge make requests for payment? .........................................[91] What happened to Mr and Mrs Mudge’s money ..................................................[98] First cause of action:  Section 271 of the Companies Act 1993......................... [110] Were IL Agents and IL 2010 related companies? ............................................... [112] Submissions ........................................................................................................ [114] Case law ............................................................................................................. [116] Intermingling of records.....................................................................................[123] Movement of funds .............................................................................................[128] Understanding of those dealing with the companies .........................................[132] Analysis ..............................................................................................................[136] Is there a sufficiently strong relationship in the absence of temporal overlap? [138] Second cause of action:  Phoenix company provisions .....................................[144] Third cause of action:  Section 301 of the Companies Act 1993 .......................[151] Stage one: breach of duty ...................................................................................[153] Section 131: breach of director’s duties ............................................................[155] Section 135: reckless trading ............................................................................[160] Other alleged breaches ......................................................................................[170] Stage two: contribution/compensation ..............................................................[171] Interest................................................................................................................[180] What rate of interest is just in terms of s 301(1)(b)? .........................................[186] Other matters ......................................................................................................[190] Section 217A.......................................................................................................[191] Funding of litigation ..........................................................................................[196] Pleaded defence .................................................................................................[198] Result..................................................................................................................[200] Costs ...................................................................................................................[201] Leave reserved ...................................................................................................[202]

Introduction

[1]      The plaintiffs are the liquidators of Independent Livestock Agents Ltd (“IL Agents”). The second defendant, Mr Schuler, was the sole director and a shareholder of both IL Agents and the first defendant, Independent Livestock 2010 Ltd (“IL

2010”).  In this proceeding the liquidators seek to hold Mr Schuler personally liable

for the debts incurred by IL Agents.

Summary of factual background

[2]      Mr Schuler, as a director of IL Agents, sold stock for Mr and Mrs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grant v Independent Livestock 2010 Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 3458
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Grant v Independent Livestock 2010 Limited involved the liquidators of Independent Livestock Agents Limited (IL Agents) suing Ian Schuler, the sole director of both IL Agents and Independent Livestock 2010 Limited (IL 2010), to hold him personally liable for the debts incurred by IL Agents. The plaintiffs sought to pool the assets and liabilities of IL Agents and IL 2010 under Section 271 of the Companies Act 1993 and to hold Schuler personally liable for the debts of IL 2010 under the phoenix company provisions. The plaintiffs also sought relief under Section 301 of the Act.

The Court found that there was no jurisdiction to make a pooling order under Section 271(1) because the companies were not related within the meaning of Section 2(3). The Court held that the businesses of IL Agents and IL 2010 had not been carried on in a manner that rendered the separate business of each company not readily identifiable. The Court further found that the second cause of action failed as the plaintiffs did not establish that IL Agents was a "failed company" and IL 2010 was a "phoenix company."

The Court held that Schuler breached his duties as a director of IL Agents by failing to consider the positions of the Mudges as creditors, intentionally seeking to defeat their claim on the company, and allocating the available profit as salaries. The Court found that Schuler's actions were deliberate, ongoing, and dishonest, causing the company to act in breach of its fiduciary obligations to the Mudges. The Court ordered Schuler to repay the sum of $70,601 to the liquidators of IL Agents, together with interest at a rate of 8.4% from 14 days after each of the three transactions which gave rise to the sale proceeds due to the Mudges.

The Court awarded costs to the plaintiffs on a category 2 basis, band B, and proper and reasonable disbursements. Leave was reserved for either party to apply should further directions or clarification be required in respect of any of the financial aspects of the compensation awarded by the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established