Grant v Il Forno Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2014-404-000627 [2014] NZHC 1847

UNDER the Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF

the liquidation of SM Food Limited (In
Liquidation)

BETWEEN

DAMIEN GRANT and STEVEN KHOV Plaintiffs

AND

IL FORNO LIMITED Defendant

On the papers

Judgment:

7 August 2014

COSTS JUDGMENT OF GILBERT J

This judgment is delivered by me on 7 August 2014 at 3pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

..................................................... Registrar / Deputy Registrar

GRANT and KHOV v IL FORNO LIMITED [2014] NZHC 1847 [7 August 2014]

Introduction

[1]      In a judgment delivered on 23 June 2014 I dismissed the plaintiff liquidators’ application to set aside an alleged voidable transaction.1   I found that the liquidators’ notice was valid and that they had proved that the transaction would have been an insolvent transaction in terms of s 292(2) of the Companies Act 1993 had it been a transaction involving SM Food Limited (In Liquidation).  However, I dismissed the liquidators’ application because I found that the relevant transaction involved the

sole shareholder of SM Food Limited, Skipper Trustees Limited, not SM Food itself.

[2]      The parties have been unable to agree the issue of costs and this judgment deals with that issue.

[3]      The creditor, Il Forno Limited, seeks an uplift of 50 per cent on 2B costs on the grounds that there was no proper basis for the liquidators’ application and the liquidators failed, without reasonable justification, to accept a settlement offer.  The liquidators contend that a 50 per cent reduction on 2B costs should be awarded because Il Forno pursued arguments that lacked merit.   The liquidators also argue that costs should not be allowed for some steps as they contend that these were unnecessary.  Finally, there is a dispute about the recoverable disbursements.

Should scale costs be increased, or decreased, because arguments were pursued that lacked merit?

[4]      Although  I  concluded  that  the  relevant  transaction  was  entered  into  by Skipper Trustees, not SM Food, I do not consider that the liquidators’ contention to the contrary was so lacking in merit as to justify an award of increased costs against them.   There had been a lengthy history of substantial shareholder advances by Skipper Trustees  to  enable  SM  Food  to  meet  payments  due  to  creditors.    The liquidators  considered  that  the  relevant  transaction  fell  into  the  same  category, having regard to the substance, rather than the form, of the payment.  While I did not accept their analysis, I consider that the liquidators acted responsibly in pursuing the

claim.

1      Grant & Khov v Ilforno Ltd [2014] NZHC 1416.

[5]      I found that there was no merit in Il Forno’s contentions that the liquidators’ notice was invalid and that the liquidators had failed to prove that Il Forno received more  as  a  result  of  the  transaction  than  it  would  be  likely  to  receive  in  the liquidation.  However, these issues did not occupy significant time at the hearing and I do not consider that costs should be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grant v Il Forno Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1847
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Grant v Il Forno Limited [2014] NZHC 1847 involves a dispute between the plaintiff liquidators, Damien Grant and Steven Khov, and the defendant, Il Forno Limited. The liquidators sought to set aside an alleged voidable transaction under the Companies Act 1993, but the court dismissed their application. The primary issue in the case was the determination of costs between the parties. Il Forno argued for an uplift of 50 per cent on 2B costs on the grounds that there was no proper basis for the liquidators' application and they failed to accept a settlement offer without reasonable justification. In contrast, the liquidators argued for a 50 per cent reduction in 2B costs, contending that Il Forno pursued arguments that lacked merit.

The court found that the liquidators' contention that the relevant transaction fell into the same category of shareholder advances was not so lacking in merit as to justify an award of increased costs against them. While Il Forno's contentions that the liquidators' notice was invalid and that they failed to prove Il Forno received more from the transaction than it would in liquidation were without merit, these issues did not occupy significant time at the hearing. The court also held that the liquidators were not unreasonable in failing to accept a settlement offer as they were not offered anything but instead invited to pay costs as a condition of discontinuing their claim. Furthermore, the court did not consider the attempt to have preliminary issues determined to be an unnecessary step.

The court awarded Il Forno costs calculated on a 2B basis for all steps in the proceeding, together with its reasonable disbursements. The court also noted that Il Forno is not entitled to travel costs for counsel. The determination of the specific amount of costs and disbursements was to be fixed by the Registrar in the absence of agreement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established