Grace v Orion New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2017-409-000454

[2021] NZHC 705

BETWEEN

CECILE GRACE

First Plaintiff

(See Schedule A for Complete List of Plaintiffs)

AND

ORION NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
First Defendant

LEISURE INVESTMENTS NZ LIMITED PARTNERSHIP

Second Defendant

Hearing:

Hearing Telephone Conferences:

3-7, 10-12, 18-21, 31 August 2020,

1-2, 9-11, 21-24, 28-29 September 2020 and
9, 12-13 October 2020

14 and 17 August 2020 and 7 and 25 September 2020

Appearances:

C M Stevens, B R D Cuff, S K Battersby and C S M Henley for Plaintiffs

T C Weston QC, M Dennett, R J H Scott and S M Crosbie for First Defendant

G N Gallaway, W J Hamilton and L A Merrick for Second Defendant

Judgment:

31 March 2021

Reissued:

12 April 2021


JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J


GRACE v ORION NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2021] NZHC 705 [31 March 2021]

This judgment was delivered by me on 31 March 2021 at 3 p.m. pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction [1]
Background [13]
Christchurch Adventure Park [13]
Summit Road Fire and the Chairlift Fire [19]
Timeline [23]
Monday 13 February 2017 [24]
Tuesday 14 February 2017 [37]
Wednesday 15 February 2017 [59]
Adventure Park’s Fire Safety Management Plan (FSM Plan) [82]
Doppelmayr manual [87]
Damage caused by the fires [89]
Plaintiff’s pleadings [96]
Section 43 of the Forest and Rural Fires Act 1997 (FRF Act) [100]
Liability under s 43 [100]
Causation under s 43 [115]
Was this an extraordinary event? [121]
Was this an “outbreak” of fire or simply a “spread” of fire? [131]
Conclusion on s 43 FRF Act [147]
Negligence [149]
Duty of care and the scope of that duty? [154]
Breach of the duty of care? [170]
-     Flammability of Chairs? [171]
-     Requirements for a competent chairlift operator [175]
Causation of loss by the breach and remoteness? [182]
Conclusion on negligence [189]
Nuisance [190]
Adventure Park created or participated in the creation of a nuisance? [198]
Adventure Park’s land was used in a way that was unreasonable? [202]
Damage suffered was foreseeable? [209]
Conclusion on nuisance [212]
Damages [213]
Broadly “Non-contested” sums [219]
“Contested” sums [221]
Legal Framework [223]
Reinstatement [234]
Process for quantifying loss [245]
Flanagans’ quantum claim – 165 Early Valley Road [255]
-     Insured loss claim [260]
-     Uninsured loss claim [278]
Cecile Grace’s quantum claim – 349 Worsleys Road [280]
-     Insured loss claim [281]
-     Uninsured loss claim [292]
Kwons’ quantum claim – 339 Worsleys Road [305]
-     Insured loss claim [309]
-     Uninsured loss claim [313]
Pflaums’ quantum claim – 343 Worsleys Road [332]
Repair cost claims [370]
Betterment [385]
Interest [410]
Judgment [419]
Costs [421]

Introduction

[1]                 Two major fires occurred in the Port Hills area of Christchurch in February 2017. The plaintiffs were owners and in most cases residents of property, or business owners, in the area at the time. They and their properties…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grace v Orion New Zealand Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 705
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Grace v Orion New Zealand Limited involved 80 plaintiffs suing the defendants for damage and loss caused by two major fires in the Port Hills area of Christchurch in February 2017. The first defendant, Orion, was sued for loss resulting from the EVR Fire, which began near Early Valley Road. The second defendant, the Adventure Park, was sued for damage and loss said to be caused to properties by the Chairlift Fire, which started about 4 km away on Summit Road. The Adventure Park, which operates a mountain bike, zipline, hiking and sightseeing park, was alleged to have caused the Chairlift Fire outbreak by running its chairlift through the Summit Road Fire, igniting plastic seating on the chairs and causing spot fires which developed into a large fire outbreak. The Remaining Plaintiffs and the Flanagans claimed that the fire which spread from the Adventure Park's property caused over $11 million of damage to their properties for which the Adventure Park is liable. The claims were brought under s 43 of the Forest and Rural Fires Act 1977, in negligence and in nuisance. The court found that the Adventure Park was liable under s 43 of the Forest and Rural Fires Act 1977 for the outbreak of the Chairlift Fire. The court also found that the Adventure Park was negligent in not commencing the removal of the flammable chairs from its chairlift haul rope earlier, which caused the Chairlift Fire. The Adventure Park was also found liable in nuisance for creating a nuisance by running its chairlift and its chairs through the Summit Road Fire, which caused the Chairlift Fire outbreak. The Adventure Park was ordered to pay the Remaining Plaintiffs and the Flanagans damages for their loss, including interest at the rate of 5 per cent per annum from 15 February 2017 to the date of final payment respectively of each judgment sum. The Adventure Park was also ordered to pay costs, which were reserved and to be determined later.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established