Grace v Orion New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2017-409-000454

[2020] NZHC 1867

BETWEEN

C GRACE AND OTHERS

Plaintiffs

AND

ORION NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

First Defendant

LEISURE INVESTMENTS NZ LIMITED PARTNERSHIP

Second Defendant

Hearing: 29 July 2020

Counsel:

C M Stevens and B Cuff for plaintiffs

T C Weston QC, R Scott and S Crosbie for First Defendant G N Gallaway, and W J Hamilton for Second Defendant

Judgment:

29 July 2020


ORAL JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J

As to Interlocutory Applications


[1]                 For some time, this proceeding has been scheduled for a nine-week trial commencing on Monday next, 3 August 2020.

[2]                 Around 10 July 2020, the plaintiffs filed an application for leave to amend their present Fifth Amended Statement of claim by filing a Sixth Amended Statement of claim. This application was supported by a range of affidavits.

[3]                 On 14 July 2020, counsel for the first defendant filed a Notice of Opposition to this application together with supporting affidavits.

GRACE v ORION NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2020] NZHC 1867 [29 July 2020]

[4]                 The plaintiffs’ leave application essentially related to three matters. The first two matters concerned amendments to the quantum of the plaintiffs’ claim and the addition of a family trust as one of the plaintiffs. These amendments were in accordance with an order I had granted on 3 July 2020. They were unopposed by any of the defendants. There is no issue with granting leave to these particular amendments and I now grant leave accordingly.

[5]                 The third matter for amendment, however, is different. It is opposed by the first defendant. It is described in the plaintiffs’ application at paragraph 3.3 as follows:

3.3The amendment [is] to include as a simultaneous contributor to the ignition of the fire, namely that the damage to HA2/117 yellow phase Flounder conductor and to the yellow phase clamp caused molten aluminium to be expelled and ignited the vegetation at the base of AX728:

3.3.1It is necessary to ensure the just determination of the proceedings by ensuring that all real controversies go to trial and are justly determined.

3.3.2The merits of the applicant’s case (including the amendment) are strong and therefore deserving of determination by the Court, as set out in the memorandum accompanying this application.

3.3.3The reason for the delay with the application is that this issue only came to light upon receipt of the first defendant’s electrical engineering evidence on 15 May 2020. The damage was never brought to the attention of the plaintiffs’ investigators and the damaged conductor was discarded by the first defendant, despite evidence of melting and arcing and was never available for inspection.

3.3.4There is no risk of material prejudice to either of the defendants. The amendment only affects the first defendant and the first defendant has extensively dealt with the potential contributor to the ignition in its evidence and rejected it as a contributor to ignition.

3.3.5The first defendant in its defence has already pleaded that the overcurrent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grace v Orion New Zealand Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 1867
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard an application by Grace and others against Orion New Zealand Limited and Leisure Investments NZ Limited Partnership. The plaintiffs sought leave to amend their Statement of Claim for a sixth time, introducing new claims related to the ignition of a fire. The first defendant opposed this amendment, arguing that it would cause significant delay and prejudice to the proceedings. Additionally, the first defendant applied to vacate the upcoming trial date, citing new evidence and the unavailability of a key witness. The plaintiffs and the second defendant opposed this application, emphasizing the importance of proceeding with the scheduled trial.

The court considered the principles guiding amendments after the close of pleadings, as outlined in McGechan on Procedure and case law, which prioritize ensuring the real controversy goes to trial. The judge noted that the amendment application was made very close to the trial date, raising concerns about significant delay. However, the judge also recognized the importance of determining the merits of the proposed amendment, especially since the first defendant had already addressed the potential contributor to ignition in its evidence. Despite the late stage of the proceedings, the judge decided to grant the amendment application to allow the real controversy to be determined in court, while also considering the need for the trial to proceed as scheduled.

The court further addressed the first defendant's application to vacate the trial, balancing the interests of all parties, including those waiting for hearings, and the public interest in efficient use of court resources. The judge concluded that the trial should proceed as scheduled, with provisions for additional evidence and expert examinations as needed during the trial. Directions were given for non-destructive testing of a specific clamp and for reserving leave for further evidence or testing as the trial progresses. Costs for the applications were reserved.

In summary, the court granted the plaintiffs' application for leave to amend their pleadings, while declining the first defendant's application to vacate the trial. The trial was set to commence on the scheduled date, with additional measures in place to accommodate new evidence and expert examinations as required.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established