Goffe v Police HC Nelson CRI 2011-442-2

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CRI 2011-442-2

JOSEPH TE AHU GOFFE

Appellant

v

NEW ZEALAND POLICE

Respondent

Hearing:         1 March 2011

Counsel:         B Hunt for Appellant

M A O'Donoghue for Respondent

Judgment:      1 March 2011

ORAL JUDGMENT OF RONALD YOUNG J

Introduction

[1]      Mr Goffe had $3,500 worth of outstanding fines.  A bailiff had a warrant to uplift his property and sell it to pay for the fines.   The day on which the bailiff together with a police officer arrived at Mr Goffe’s house was not a good one for him. As the District Court Judge said:

That  morning one  of  his  pig  dogs  went  missing.    His  relationship  was coming to an end, and on top of that, the bailiff and the police officer arrived with a warrant in relation to unpaid fines.

JOSEPH TE AHU GOFFE V NEW ZEALAND POLICE HC NEL CRI 2011-442-2 1 March 2011

[2]      As events unfolded Mr Goffe was charged with assault and driving in a dangerous manner, as relevant in this appeal.  The assault alleged was a threatened application of force to the bailiff, Ms McDowell, the dangerous driving related to the circumstances under which he left his property and drove onto Chamberlain Street.

[3]      Mr Goffe’s case is that he had not ever threatened an application of force either  directly or  inferentially and  therefore  should  not  have  been  convicted  of assault and secondly there was no driving by him which could have been dangerous to members of the public on a public road.

Background facts

[4]      After the bailiff and the police officer arrived at Mr Goffe’s residence they showed him a warrant which entitled them to uplift property to sell.  Mr Goffe was clearly angry and emotional.  He was shouting, indeed screaming at the bailiff and the police officer.  The bailiff identified a motor bike which she proposed to seize under the warrant.  Mr Goffe was angry and upset and told her that it was not his bike and that it belonged to someone else.

[5]      The bailiff, Ms McDowell, said that when she was confronted by Mr Goffe he stood close to her, less than 20 cm away.   She said that he was screaming and extremely agitated.  She did not think he was listening to her and she was frightened. Constable Turner who was also present said the appellant was agitated using abusive language  and  wouldn’t  step  back  when  asked  to  do  so.    She  was  also  of  the impression that Mr Goffe was not listening to what Ms McDowell was saying.

District Court Decision

[6]      The Judge in convicting the appellant said:

[13]      Here the allegation is not of an actual assault, but rather a threatened assault, or a threatened application of force, and in relation to the threatened application of force, before I could convict the accused, I would have to be satisfied that he intended to convey to Ms McDowell that he was capable of harming her, that is, that he had the intention…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goffe v Police HC Nelson CRI 2011-442-2 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of Joseph Te Ahu Goffe versus New Zealand Police was heard. Mr. Goffe, with outstanding fines amounting to $3,500, faced a warrant execution by a bailiff and police officer. During the incident, Mr. Goffe was charged with assault and dangerous driving, related to his actions towards the bailiff and his departure from his property, respectively. He contested both charges, claiming that he did not threaten any application of force and that his driving was not dangerous.

The central legal issues were whether Mr. Goffe's actions constituted an assault by threatening to apply force and whether his driving was dangerous. Regarding the assault charge, the court had to determine if the police could prove that Mr. Goffe intended to threaten force by an act or gesture. For the dangerous driving charge, the court had to assess whether Mr. Goffe's driving was dangerous based on his actions and the circumstances.

The court found that Mr. Goffe's aggressive behavior did not amount to a threat of force, as required by law. There was no evidence of any gesture or words indicating such a threat. Consequently, the conviction for assault was quashed. However, the court upheld the conviction for dangerous driving, as the evidence showed that Mr. Goffe drove off his property at high speed, collided with a gate, and entered the road without ensuring it was clear, which could have endangered the public. The appeal against the dangerous driving conviction was dismissed.

The final orders of the court were to quash the conviction for assault and to maintain the conviction for dangerous driving.