Godfrey Hirst Limited v Cavalier Bremworth

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2013-404-002065 [2013] NZHC 2256

UNDER  the Fair Trading Act 1986

BETWEEN  GODFREY HIRST LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDCAVALIER BREMWORTH Defendant

Hearing:                   On the papers

Counsel:                  J C L Dixon and J B Hamlin for the Plaintiff

S E Fitzgerald and J Edwards for the Defendant

Judgment:                30 August 2013

COSTS JUDGMENT OF GILBERT J

This judgment was delivered by me on 30 August 2013 at 4.30 pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:

GODFREY HIRST LIMITED v CAVALIER BREMWORTH [2013] NZHC 2256 [30 August 2013]

[1]      In  my  judgment  dated  31  July  2013,  I  found  that  Cavalier  Bremworth breached ss 9 and 13 of the Fair Trading Act 1986 in the way it promoted warranties concerning a new range of synthetic carpet on its website and in a letter it sent to retailers.   However, because Cavalier Bremworth promptly rectified this following issue of the proceedings and provided an undertaking to the Court after the hearing not to publish these statements in any media in the future, I was not prepared to grant the injunction sought by Godfrey Hirst in relation to these statements.

[2]      I  also  found  that  one  of  the  statements  made  by  Cavalier  Bremworth concerning the warranties on stickers attached to the backs of carpet samples was misleading.  These statements were not corrected following issue of the proceeding and  accordingly  I  issued  an  injunction  restraining  Cavalier  Bremworth  from persisting with such statements.

[3]      I reserved the question of costs.   Both parties now seek costs against the other.  Both claim that they were successful in the proceeding.

[4]      There is no dispute between the parties as to the correct approach.   Costs should follow the event.   The dispute concerns what the “event” was  for costs purposes.  The application for costs must be determined by considering which party was successful in reality.

[5]      Cavalier Bremworth contends that it was the successful party because:

(a)      Godfrey  Hirst  claimed  that  Cavalier  Bremworth’s  conduct  was misleading in 16 different respects but only three of these were upheld and these were relatively minor in the overall context of the claim; and

(b)Cavalier Bremworth promptly and responsibly rectified the position in relation to most of the issues after the proceedings were served on it.

[6]      Cavalier Bremworth  submits that Godfrey Hirst ought to have engaged with it  regarding  its  complaints  before  issuing  the  proceeding  but  made  no  genuine

attempt to do so.   In these circumstances, Cavalier Bremworth submits that the appropriate course would be to award costs in its favour reduced by 10 per cent to reflect Godfrey Hirst’s modest success.

[7]      I do not accept Cavalier Bremworth’s position for the following reasons:

(a)      Godfrey  Hirst  succeeded  in  establishing  that  Cavalier  Bremworth made misleading statements regarding the warranties in breach of ss 9 and 13 of the Fair Trading Act on its website and in the letter it sent to carpet retailers;

(b)Godfrey Hirst was entitled to move promptly to have its…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Godfrey Hirst Limited v Cavalier Bremworth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 2256
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Godfrey Hirst Limited, a carpet manufacturer, commenced proceedings against Cavalier Bremworth, a carpet retailer, for alleged breaches of the Fair Trading Act 1986. The dispute arose from the manner in which Cavalier Bremworth promoted warranties for a new range of synthetic carpet, both on its website and in correspondence with retailers. Godfrey Hirst sought an injunction and damages for the breaches. The court had to determine whether Cavalier Bremworth's actions constituted misleading conduct under the Fair Trading Act and, if so, what remedy was appropriate. Additionally, the court had to resolve the issue of costs between the parties.

The court found that Cavalier Bremworth had indeed breached sections 9 and 13 of the Fair Trading Act through its promotional activities. Specifically, the court held that Cavalier Bremworth's statements regarding warranties were misleading and constituted prohibited conduct. While Cavalier Bremworth had rectified the misleading statements on its website and in letters to retailers promptly, it had not corrected the misleading statements on carpet samples until after the proceedings were issued. The court issued an injunction to prevent Cavalier Bremworth from continuing to make these misleading statements. The court then turned to the issue of costs, which both parties sought against the other, claiming success in the proceedings.

In deciding the costs, the court considered which party was successful in reality. Godfrey Hirst succeeded in establishing that Cavalier Bremworth had made misleading statements in breach of the Fair Trading Act, both online and in letters to retailers. Cavalier Bremworth's prompt action to rectify the misleading statements was not enough to shift the outcome in its favour. The court awarded costs to Godfrey Hirst, reduced by 25% to reflect Cavalier Bremworth's partial success in the proceedings.

The court's final orders were that Godfrey Hirst was entitled to costs on a Category 2, Band B basis, reduced by 25%. This decision reflected Godfrey Hirst's overall success in the proceedings, despite not achieving complete victory on all counts.